WeOrthodox
EN UA

r/OrthodoxChristianity

Reddit ↗ 63 discussions

A subreddit dedicated to discussion of Eastern Orthodox Christianity.

r/OrthodoxChristianity Reddit

Identifying icons found at a flea market

I found these icons at a flea market a few days ago and thought they were interesting. Could someone tell me what the icon on the right depicts? Also, what is Jesus holding in that icon, and what does the inscription say? I know a little Greek but I can't decipher the letters.

  • What is the icon on the right?
  • What is Jesus holding?
  • What does the Greek inscription say?
  • The author knows some Greek but cannot read the letters.
Read more

Why is Kaleb/Elesbaan venerated as a saint despite monophysitism?

I am an inquirer into Eastern Orthodoxy after leaving Protestantism, and I am still learning. I am torn between Catholicism and Orthodoxy, though I am leaning more toward Orthodoxy. I personally reject monophysitism, and I am curious why Kaleb is venerated as a saint when Eastern Orthodoxy also rejects that teaching. I would appreciate an answer, as it would help me on my journey.

17 opinions in the discussion The split over Chalcedon wasn't sudden. For a few hundred years it stayed an argument inside the Church. That's why St. Elesbaan is a saint for us and St. Theodora is a saint for the… Read the discussion

What do Orthodox believe happens to babies who die before Baptism?

I have lost four babies, three early miscarriages and one stillborn. We have named all of them and ask for their intercession constantly. But I feel tremendous guilt that my body failed them. And when people tell me "I'll pray for them," it makes me feel like they didn't go to heaven.

My children never sinned; they didn't choose to die before baptism. Am I being scrupulous? Is there a teaching that these children go to heaven? I just can't imagine God wouldn't immediately take them in.

  • Lost four babies (three miscarriages, one stillborn) and named them all
  • Asks for their intercession but feels guilt over body failing them
  • Distressed when people say "I'll pray for them", implies they didn't go to heaven
  • Notes children never sinned and didn't choose to die unbaptized
  • Asks if scrupulous and whether Orthodox teaching says they go to heaven
24 opinions in the discussion God is love. He said let the little children come to me, and that unless you become like a little child you cannot enter the kingdom of heaven. I hope that paints a picture of God's… Read the discussion

Considering Orthodoxy but family is Muslim and I'm dependent on them

This is my first time posting like this, so I apologize for any mistakes or if this is too long. I think I want to convert to Orthodox Christianity, but my entire family is Muslim. I live in a Western country, which helps since I want to leave Islam, but the area has many people from my ethnic group who are almost entirely Muslim and generally religious. In my home country apostasy is punishable by death or imprisonment. Islam is treated almost…

This is my first time posting like this, so I apologize for any mistakes or if this is too long.

I think I want to convert to Orthodox Christianity, but my entire family is Muslim. I live in a Western country, which helps since I want to leave Islam, but the area has many people from my ethnic group who are almost entirely Muslim and generally religious. In my home country apostasy is punishable by death or imprisonment.

Islam is treated almost as an ethnic identity; I have heard people say you cannot be part of my ethnic group and not be Muslim, so leaving is not forgiven.

My parents are very religious and always remind me to pray. Recently I started hearing things about Islam from other Muslims that did not sit right with me, morally and theologically. I looked further and I am disgusted and deeply doubtful, especially about the moral issues. I do not understand how a prophet meant to be an example for all society did some of the things he did.

It is hard because I spent my whole life hearing only the good and loving him for it, only to learn these things later and hear other Muslims say my objections come from propaganda or lack of faith. Seeing how Muslims treat those who leave or doubt, and the hatred directed at them, has affected me. Of course that is not proof the religion is false, but it has had an impact.

This caused me to lose faith and stop praying. My family knows I do not pray much, but I do when they tell me to, and they still think I am Muslim, just struggling or sinning. I am even unsure if I am still Muslim. I think it might be fear-based: "What if I am wrong and go to hell?" "What if I ruin my life and fracture my family?" It is ingrained in everything I have known, including my culture.

My friends are Muslim as well. I mentioned to my best friend that I was struggling with religion, but I framed it as a struggle with the existence of God, too scared to say it was about Islam itself, and sprinkled in some moral issues like concubinage. She listened and directed me to scholars, but said believing in Allah is just a given for her, not something she has struggled with.

Eventually I told her my concerns were resolved, which was half true. I now fully believe in the existence of a God; the question is which one.

I have been interested in Orthodox Christianity and am starting to read more. It might be too early to say I am fully convinced, as I still have lingering theological issues, mainly with the Trinity. I know that is important, but I spent my whole life hearing how horrible the Trinity is, so bear with me. However, Orthodoxy makes more sense to me than Catholicism or Protestantism.

I cannot really convert because of my situation, and it is causing emotional issues. My internal thoughts and external life are completely different. I have worn hijab since I was eight. I did not necessarily choose it; my parents told me to.

I did not understand it, and I liked looking like my mother and sisters, so I did not fight it. I hate the hijab now and hate being perceived as Muslim. Every aspect makes me worry about what others think. Oddly, I do like dressing modestly, but not to that extent. I am self-conscious even showing my forearms, worried people will view me badly.

This has largely been my relationship with hijab: how others view me. Hijab has also caused more anxiety as hatred toward Islam rises. Being a woman who looks Muslim means we bear the brunt of it. I am scared of being harassed because I wear it when I do not even want to.

I also have to pretend to pray, love Islam, and have others see me as Muslim. I thought about taking off the hijab and "being Muslim" but acting like I struggle with that concept. Unfortunately all the women in my family wear it, and in my culture girls wear it young, so around ninety percent of the girls I know also wear it.

  • Wants to convert to Orthodoxy but entire family and ethnic community are Muslim, with apostasy punishable by death in home country
  • Struggles with Trinity after lifelong teaching that it is horrible; finds Orthodoxy more coherent than Catholicism or Protestantism
  • Dependent on parents at 18, cannot drive or attend church, has family at university preventing a double life
  • Hates wearing hijab since childhood, feels humiliated and anxious, but removing it would cause massive family and community conflict
  • Experiencing severe emotional exhaustion, mood swings, cycles of doubt and reconviction, and daydreams of a different life; cannot access therapy
11 opinions in the discussion I'm really sorry you're going through all this. Going from Protestant to Catholic to Orthodox myself, and now being the only Orthodox Christian in my family, I know how hard it is not to… Read the discussion

American Orthodoxy is not a culture anyone owns

I was recently banned from the ex-Orthodox subreddit after replying to a cradle Orthodox Christian who said converts are stealing her culture. I want to say this plainly, and I mean no offense to cradle Orthodox here, but the conversation needs to happen. American Orthodoxy is not new. The Church has been rooted in America for well over a century, with its own rich and often overlooked history shaped by generations of immigrants, their…

I was recently banned from the ex-Orthodox subreddit after replying to a cradle Orthodox Christian who said converts are stealing her culture.

I want to say this plainly, and I mean no offense to cradle Orthodox here, but the conversation needs to happen. American Orthodoxy is not new. The Church has been rooted in America for well over a century, with its own rich and often overlooked history shaped by generations of immigrants, their descendants, converts, parishes, monasteries, and communities. The current growth in converts does not erase that history.

I am tired of seeing cradle Orthodox take issue with converts who embrace the faith seriously and develop an interest in the cultures historically tied to Orthodoxy. Enjoying Greek food, taking an interest in Slavic traditions, or embracing Eastern European culture is suddenly treated as larping or heritage theft.

I am an ex-Muslim. My cultural background was shaped by Islam, but that does not mean I must preserve every aspect of my former life simply because I was raised in it. Nor should another convert be expected to approach Orthodoxy exactly as I do.

Let's be honest about the cultural argument. My people would say we invented baklava. Many cradle Orthodox from the Middle East would say the same. Does anyone actually own baklava? What about shawarma, plov, or the countless other foods and traditions that have crossed borders, been shared between neighboring peoples, and developed into regional variations over generations?

I have a Russian friend who owns a plov restaurant and is married to an Uzbek woman. I would not accuse him of larping as an Uzbek because he has embraced Uzbek food and culture. Cultures interact, influence one another, and become intertwined.

So why can Europeans, Eastern Europeans, and Middle Eastern communities share and adopt aspects of one another's cultures without constantly questioning authenticity, but when an American convert enjoys baklava, learns Slavic traditions, or takes an interest in Eastern European culture, the accusation of cultural appropriation appears?

The irony is that someone can grow up in America, live an entirely American lifestyle, eat American food, and have little personal experience with the countries they claim to protect, yet the moment someone else expresses genuine interest in those cultures, they are offended.

The argument becomes harder to take seriously when ordinary cultural exchange is framed as oppression or theft. There is a significant difference between genuinely disrespecting someone's heritage and simply appreciating, participating in, or adopting aspects of a culture you were not born into.

I say this as someone who has lived through a major religious and cultural transition. Becoming Orthodox does not mean I must completely abandon my previous cultural background, and I do not expect every other convert to do so either. Some converts will retain almost everything about their former lifestyle. Others will naturally develop new interests, habits, traditions, and cultural connections through their life in the Church.

That is perfectly fine.

Orthodoxy is not an ethnic inheritance that only certain people are entitled to participate in. It is the faith of the Church, and people from all backgrounds are called to embrace it. We should encourage people to take their faith seriously rather than scrutinize how they choose to live it.

You do not have to eat Greek food, drink Turkish coffee, learn Russian, celebrate Serbian traditions, or adopt any particular cultural practice to be Orthodox. But if someone genuinely enjoys those things, why should that bother you?

  • American Orthodoxy has over a century of history shaped by immigrants, descendants, converts, parishes, and monasteries
  • Cradle Orthodox accuse converts of cultural theft for enjoying foods and traditions historically tied to Orthodoxy
  • Cultures naturally share and adopt from one another across European, Eastern European, and Middle Eastern communities without authenticity disputes
  • Orthodoxy is the faith of the Church for all people, not an ethnic inheritance restricted to certain groups
  • Spiritual growth and serious practice of the faith matter more than cultural authenticity standards
57 opinions in the discussion I used to post regularly on that ex-Orthodox sub (from a different account). Whatever the topic, they'll twist it into another reason to trash the faith, including my own old posts there,… Read the discussion

Struggling with Jesus calling Gentiles dogs in Mark 7:27

I've been trying to hold onto the faith for years; it's a deliberate choice for me. Though I was raised Greek-American Orthodox, I walked away around age twelve and only returned in my early twenties. You know the pattern, skepticism and all. The verse that troubles me is Mark 7:27, where Jesus tells the Syrophoenician woman, "Let the children be fed first, for it is not right to take the children's bread and throw it to the dogs." The…

I've been trying to hold onto the faith for years; it's a deliberate choice for me. Though I was raised Greek-American Orthodox, I walked away around age twelve and only returned in my early twenties. You know the pattern, skepticism and all.

The verse that troubles me is Mark 7:27, where Jesus tells the Syrophoenician woman, "Let the children be fed first, for it is not right to take the children's bread and throw it to the dogs."

The "children" are understood as the Jews, and the "dogs" as Gentiles.

I cannot reconcile this; it sickens me. Has the Lord of Spirits podcast or any comparable academic Orthodox source addressed this passage? I haven't been able to locate such a discussion.

God bless you all. Please pray for me if you can.

  • Struggling to reconcile Mark 7:27 with faith
  • Asks if Lord of Spirits or similar Orthodox academic source has discussed this passage
  • Requests prayers
17 opinions in the discussion The Greek word Jesus uses here isn't for wild street dogs (kyon), but kynaria household puppies under the table. He's painting a domestic picture, not hurling an insult, and she matches His… Read the discussion

Catechumen seeks guidance on atheist girlfriend and marriage

I am a soon-to-be catechumen and love my girlfriend very much; she means everything to me. She is a very kind soul who cares a lot about the world and other people. Honestly she does it better than I do depending on how you look at it. But she is an atheist. I have tried to tell her that in order for us to get married she will have to become Orthodox or at least some sort of Christian. I told her that getting married in the church is…

I am a soon-to-be catechumen and love my girlfriend very much; she means everything to me. She is a very kind soul who cares a lot about the world and other people. Honestly she does it better than I do depending on how you look at it. But she is an atheist.

I have tried to tell her that in order for us to get married she will have to become Orthodox or at least some sort of Christian. I told her that getting married in the church is non-negotiable and that marriage to me is not just a civil union but a union between us and God. She respects my religious beliefs but gets very upset when I bring up that I want her to also seek Christ.

I beg God to show her a sign. It breaks my heart to see someone I love so much be so misled. I think every day that if something happens to her I will not be able to see her again.

She has given me reasons why she does not believe: science disproves religion, religion is oppressive, and it is just a coping mechanism. These are things that I can easily disprove and debunk. But she still does not listen. I know she is annoyed at me, but I am doing this because I love her and she does not understand that. I do not want to lose her and I do not know what to do.

  • Marriage in the Church requires her to become Orthodox or at least Christian
  • Girlfriend respects his faith but gets upset when he asks her to seek Christ
  • He fears for her salvation if she dies without faith
  • She raises objections: science disproves religion, religion is oppressive, a coping mechanism
  • He does not know what to do and does not want to lose her
51 opinions in the discussion I'm gonna say it, and you're not gonna listen, but here it goes: do not be unequally yoked. It's gonna be strife and pain and friction and frustration and eventually, to keep the peace,… Read the discussion

I think my priest doesn't like me after confession

I went to confession at my church last Sunday and confessed a sin I know was serious. I didn't want to go anywhere else or confess to any other priest, this church is practically my second home, and I'm very happy there. Since then I've had the feeling that the priest doesn't like me anymore. He didn't say anything harsh or give any sign of disapproval; it's just my own thought. I'm taking the sin very seriously, praying and repenting over it.

30 opinions in the discussion You're overthinking it. He's probably heard it before. Read the discussion

Eastern Catholicism is proof the schism should end?

I am Orthodox, and I realize no one here will agree with me, but I want to understand why. I have known that Eastern Catholicism exists but not the details. Because my wife is Roman Catholic, I have been learning more, and Eastern Catholicism appears to match what I imagine a reunited Church would look like after the schism ends. The Eastern churches keep their traditions, rites, and theology while acknowledging the primacy of the Pope. From…

I am Orthodox, and I realize no one here will agree with me, but I want to understand why.

I have known that Eastern Catholicism exists but not the details. Because my wife is Roman Catholic, I have been learning more, and Eastern Catholicism appears to match what I imagine a reunited Church would look like after the schism ends. The Eastern churches keep their traditions, rites, and theology while acknowledging the primacy of the Pope.

From what I have read, it seems I could attend a Melkite Catholic parish and my spiritual life would stay the same. I would still celebrate the Divine Liturgy of Saint John Chrysostom, keep my Orthodox theology, and the filioque would still be missing from the Creed.

So why are we not united? Is it pride? The Catholic Church seems to have extended several olive branches and provided ways to unite, yet the Orthodox remain stubborn. Am I being uncharitable?

I strongly favor a single, united Church. I see the mistakes of Protestantism and the disorder that followed when pride caused them to separate from the Catholic Church (they had valid reasons, I do not deny that). But I am starting to see similar problems in Orthodoxy arising from what looks like pride: bishops breaking communion, no agreement on rebaptism, the inability to convene councils, and so on.

Eastern Catholics appear to regard us Orthodox as siblings. We may participate in their mysteries, they are not allowed to proselytize us, and conversion is straightforward. Why do we not extend the same grace to them?

For Eastern Catholics: what do you think? Is my limited knowledge of Eastern Catholicism causing me to see this through rose-colored glasses?

  • Eastern Catholicism appears as a model for unity, and joining a Melkite parish would not alter my spiritual life.
  • Why has unity not been achieved? Could pride be the obstacle?
  • Orthodoxy exhibits similar pride-driven divisions (broken communion, rebaptism disputes, no councils).
  • Eastern Catholics treat Orthodox as siblings; why not reciprocate?
  • Is my view overly optimistic due to ignorance?
19 opinions in the discussion Honestly, the Eastern Catholics came into existence in far uglier, messier, often violent and coerced ways than they like to admit, and Rome was more of a scheming, meddling busybody than a… Read the discussion

Have I done something wrong?

I have been attending Divine Liturgy for a few months. About six weeks ago a woman told me to go forward during communion and ask for a blessing, so I have been doing that ever since. The priest seems fine with it and always gives me a blessing.

Yesterday I heard that some people are complaining to the priest, saying I should not come up for a blessing. What should I do?

22 opinions in the discussion What you should do is talk to your priest about it and ignore literally everyone else. If your priest says "No, it's ok" then keep doing it, if he says "well, I'd rather you not but I'm not… Read the discussion

Is it okay to have icons in the bedroom?

Is it acceptable to keep icons in the bedroom? A friend who is Eastern Orthodox told me that in Orthodoxy you shouldn't have icons in your room because you change clothes there and so on. Is that true?

I don't believe my icons can actually see anything; I think that idea borders on idolatry, so I don't see why my actions in front of an object would matter. God is always watching anyway, right?

  • Is it okay to have icons in the bedroom?
  • A friend says Orthodoxy forbids icons in the bedroom because of changing clothes.
  • Is that claim true?
  • The author does not believe icons can see and considers that view borderline idolatry.
  • God is always watching regardless.
31 opinions in the discussion The only version of this I've ever come across is "no icons in the bathroom." Read the discussion

My ex-boyfriend, a catechumen, died by suicide two weeks ago

The title sums it up. I miss him terribly. I am also a catechumen, but continuing my catechesis feels wrong now. I do not want to be baptized without him. When we first started dating he told me his goal was to be baptized before he died. I joked and asked if he was planning to die soon. Looking back, it is horrible to think his plan all along was to take his own life. I am staying in the Church, yet every Liturgy now brings me sadness, even…

The title sums it up. I miss him terribly. I am also a catechumen, but continuing my catechesis feels wrong now. I do not want to be baptized without him. When we first started dating he told me his goal was to be baptized before he died. I joked and asked if he was planning to die soon. Looking back, it is horrible to think his plan all along was to take his own life.

I am staying in the Church, yet every Liturgy now brings me sadness, even though I know it should not.

I am in a strange stage of grief. His death has made it hard to focus on some of my responsibilities. I am considering going back on antidepressants to manage the pain. After the funeral I spent days crying and staying in bed; I was also sick, which made everything harder. I have accepted that he is gone, but I still wish more than anything that I could go back in time and bring him back.

I do not even see his name on the pamphlets at church that list the catechumens. He loved the Church so much, and that absence is deeply disheartening.

  • Grief over the suicide of an ex-boyfriend who was a catechumen
  • Struggle to continue catechesis and face baptism without him
  • Sadness during the Liturgy despite remaining in the Church
  • Considering antidepressants to cope with the pain
  • His name missing from the catechumen list at church
7 opinions in the discussion Please, I beg you, don't quit praying for his soul right now. Keep praying for him and his salvation, and if you can, try to find a Spiritual Father at your baptism who can keep praying for… Read the discussion

Protestant exploring Orthodoxy, family surprisingly open, seeking advice on first liturgy

I grew up Baptist, attended a Lutheran church and school through seventh grade, then spent years in nondenominational Bible churches. As I got older I lost interest in the church we were attending. It was exhausting to hear the same recycled contemporary music, to listen to someone beg for money for the first ten minutes of every service, and to have every sermon feel like it was lacking. I married my wife, who did not grow up going to church,…

I grew up Baptist, attended a Lutheran church and school through seventh grade, then spent years in nondenominational Bible churches. As I got older I lost interest in the church we were attending. It was exhausting to hear the same recycled contemporary music, to listen to someone beg for money for the first ten minutes of every service, and to have every sermon feel like it was lacking.

I married my wife, who did not grow up going to church, and after about eighteen months I took a "break" from church for six years. This was entirely on me; she wanted to go, but I was so fed up that I figured I would read the Bible at home or something.

Recently both of us started feeling a pull to get back into church in some capacity. We started taking our kids to a nondenominational church that my parents and grandparents attend.

Throughout my life, even as a teenager, I always struggled with the sermons. They constantly felt shallow, like something was missing or standing in the way of the truth. I have always believed in God, even in the years I was staying home on Sunday mornings. But I had a hard time taking any of the churches we went to seriously because I was always left with a lingering, "That was it?" feeling.

Now I'm thirty with multiple kids, and my wife (who didn't grow up religious) and I decided to start our family back in church. She was worried about where to even start learning the faith, and I told her it's okay to be intimidated, and that I would do all of the beginner Bible study with her.

It has been a long time since I was regularly reading the Bible, and I think I finally realized that just because I grew up passively going to church that did not make me the expert in Christianity that I pretended I was. I felt I needed to be absolutely sure that the foundation we build for our children is based on truth.

I started researching what was necessary for salvation just to help explain generic western Protestantism, but that led me to realize sola scriptura isn't a universally agreed upon idea. At first I was completely dismissive. I assumed it was just elitism or pagan-influenced "Catholic" baggage. But I stumbled onto Protestant versus Orthodox debates, expecting a logical Protestant PhD to effortlessly dismantle a "magic idol worshiping" opponent.

Instead, watching the Orthodox side pick apart Protestant assumptions completely blew my mind. It was a whole world I had been completely blind to.

Why did we have a different Bible? Which one is right? What is even in those extra books? What even is a Church Father? Is that like the first Pope? (Looking back at this note is funny.) How did 1,500 years of Christian history between Jesus and Martin Luther fail to ever be taught to me at any church or class?

Also why had I never even thought of it a single time? Why are we NOT doing the same thing as Christians in the year 100? They probably know more than we do, right?

I spent the next six months reading everything I could get my hands on. I kept it a secret because while I started to feel an undeniable pull towards Orthodoxy, my father and grandfather are very religious men who are both Protestant. Just the word Catholic makes them recoil in physical pain (my grandmother had some bad times in a Roman Catholic upbringing). They are both people I've always looked up to for guidance.

My grandfather was involved with Campus Crusade back in the day and knows retired pastors everywhere. My father was constantly, judgment-free, pestering me over those six years I was away from the church.

Carrying the weight of this, I finally decided to talk to my grandfather. I was fully expecting him to gently tell me I was insane and easily disprove everything I was looking into. In a way I was actually hoping for that, just to make the soul searching stop. Instead, he listened, humored me, and took my copy of Becoming Orthodox to read.

  • Struggled with shallow sermons and "That was it?" feeling across Protestant denominations
  • Research into salvation led to discovering Orthodoxy and 1,500 years of missing church history
  • Grandfather (83, Campus Crusade background) read Becoming Orthodox and said "we've essentially been lied to"
  • Father also acknowledged ignorance of Great Schism and bought books to learn more
  • Still wrestling with icon veneration, saint intercession, Marian theology, and anxiety about first liturgy with toddlers
25 opinions in the discussion Mental blocks are just mental blocks. It's great that you are aware you have them. It took my wife 10 years to kiss an icon. We are very different from Protestantism but, from what you… Read the discussion
r/OrthodoxChristianity Reddit

Terrorist attack on Orthodox church in Jordan kills eight

Reuters, the New York Times, and several official sources report that three gunmen opened fire on about two hundred mourners at the Orthodox Hammoud Church in Karak, Jordan. The shooting lasted five minutes and left seven dead and thirty-seven wounded. Footage circulating online shows the attackers. This is not the first time Christians in Karak have been targeted. Ten years ago, the 2016 Al-Karak attack took place, for which the Islamic State…

Reuters, the New York Times, and several official sources report that three gunmen opened fire on about two hundred mourners at the Orthodox Hammoud Church in Karak, Jordan. The shooting lasted five minutes and left seven dead and thirty-seven wounded. Footage circulating online shows the attackers.

This is not the first time Christians in Karak have been targeted. Ten years ago, the 2016 Al-Karak attack took place, for which the Islamic State claimed responsibility.

Please pray for the victims; they need it. Pray for this wave of terrorism across the world to end, because we are exhausted.

Edit: A recording I had included turned out to be unrelated.

Edit: One of the wounded has died at Prince Ali Hospital, raising the death toll to eight martyrs.

Eternal glory and peace to the souls of the martyrs of Christ. May they rest in the eternal embrace of the Lord.

  • Three gunmen attacked the Orthodox Hammoud Church in Karak, Jordan, killing eight and wounding thirty-seven
  • The 2016 Al-Karak attack by Islamic State shows a pattern of targeting Christians in the area
  • The author asks for prayers for the victims and for an end to global terrorism
  • A previously shared recording was corrected as unrelated
  • The death toll rose to eight after a victim succumbed to injuries
Read more

Priest's daughter questions Orthodox family ideal after traumatic upbringing

I'm drawn to many things in Orthodoxy and would like to keep it in my life and raise a family within it, though differently. I believe in God, but the traditions, the lifestyle, and some priests' views are sometimes hard for me to handle. The problem is I carry a lot of trauma from my upbringing, and it's difficult to reconcile certain things. My father has been a priest for over thirty years, respected, serving in several churches and having…

I'm drawn to many things in Orthodoxy and would like to keep it in my life and raise a family within it, though differently. I believe in God, but the traditions, the lifestyle, and some priests' views are sometimes hard for me to handle.

The problem is I carry a lot of trauma from my upbringing, and it's difficult to reconcile certain things. My father has been a priest for over thirty years, respected, serving in several churches and having built several. My mother is held up as an example for Orthodox women: nine children, never worked outside the home, devoted her life to them, helped extensively at church, now sings in the choir.

I grew up inside this family and know it from within. Converts who come as adults probably have a different experience because they lack this background. I'm not just from an Orthodox family; I'm from a family presented as a model of Orthodoxy.

We grew up in a village. Seven of the nine children never attended kindergarten. We observed all the fasts, including Wednesdays and Fridays, and even the little ones didn't eat dairy. If we ate or drank anything before communion, we didn't receive.

We prayed for twenty-five minutes every morning and night, often not starting the evening prayers until ten or eleven. We attended church every Sunday, often Saturdays too, and on feast days. I sang in the choir, my brothers served at the altar.

I'm the third child and the first girl. Whenever my mother was in the maternity ward, I stayed home in charge: putting the kids to bed, checking homework, cooking. I cried and called her because it was so hard. My father lacked patience with the children and was often absent. He drove us to the metro for school, but I don't recall him spending time with us or talking to me. He never asked how I was, didn't even know what grade I was in.

We were punished frequently. We were struck on the buttocks with hands and a belt, hard enough to leave bruises. We could also be hit on the back, shoved, sometimes slapped in the face in anger, with clothing, with a stick. Once my little brother misbehaved and my mother sat on him and stuffed a rag in his mouth to quiet him.

My father would splash us with cold water in the bathroom when we cried. We were made to kneel on buckwheat and stand in corners. The last severe punishment I received was around age thirteen; I had stripes of bruises because I hadn't picked up the little ones' toys, though no one had told me to. There's much more.

My mother can be verbally harsh. She would say things like "dirty pig," "what a lazy breed," "didn't you already get the belt this morning? Do you want it?", "get out, I don't want to see you," "go ahead and cry, I'm hurt too," "I didn't think you were this brainless." She never apologized afterward. My parents never apologized for their behavior, ever.

They never said they loved us, weren't particularly warm, and my father often spoke to us in a distant, strict manner.

I understand my mother runs out of patience, but she doesn't hide that she considers this normal. She says: "If a child doesn't know how to behave, he needs to be whipped, and harder. The earlier you start the better, after six it's too late." I have no words. She also often said we'd drive her to an early grave, that she'd die young because of us, that she has no free time and can't do anything for herself.

At seventeen I moved abroad and lived alone for almost four years. Now circumstances have brought me back to live with them for a year. Because of the war they moved to Europe, and they treat the younger children better now, but I still hear name-calling and they still sometimes smack a child. Yesterday my mother hit my eight-year-old brother hard on the neck and called him a ram several times because he forgot his jacket.

I'm twenty-two, my older brothers are twenty-four and twenty-six.

  • Whether rejecting the family model means she's stubborn or normal
  • Whether the abusive upbringing represents the ideal Orthodox family
  • Why having many children is seen as more pious than fewer raised with love
  • How to reconcile Orthodox teachings on discipline, gender roles, family size with her trauma
  • Difficulty relating to Orthodox men who expect traditional roles
19 opinions in the discussion By coming here, I think you already realize that a lot of the harm in your childhood didn't come from Orthodoxy's actual teachings and practices. It came from how your parents twisted them,… Read the discussion

My sons' godfather left Orthodoxy for Protestant churches

The godfather of my sons has left the Orthodox Church and now attends two non-denominational Protestant congregations. He gives several reasons: he believes he cannot find a wife within Orthodoxy, he prefers the teaching of assured salvation, he feels he has not received what he needed spiritually from the local Orthodox parishes, and he is burned out, partly because his spiritual father was very strict. I am speaking with him, trying to grasp…

The godfather of my sons has left the Orthodox Church and now attends two non-denominational Protestant congregations. He gives several reasons: he believes he cannot find a wife within Orthodoxy, he prefers the teaching of assured salvation, he feels he has not received what he needed spiritually from the local Orthodox parishes, and he is burned out, partly because his spiritual father was very strict.

I am speaking with him, trying to grasp his reasoning and to present the Orthodox perspective, but I find myself at a loss in many ways. The situation is harder because I now live halfway across the country and cannot meet him in person for at least six months.

Mostly I grieve for my boys. We chose this man because he seemed to be on a good path and would have been an excellent guide for them, but unless he returns to the Church that guidance is lost.

Perhaps I am writing this only to vent.

  • Godfather left Orthodoxy for two non-denominational Protestant churches
  • Reasons: cannot find a wife in Orthodoxy, prefers assured salvation, unmet spiritual needs, burnout from strict spiritual father
  • Author discussing with him but feels at a loss
  • Distance prevents in-person meetings for six months
  • Sadness for sons who lose their chosen spiritual guide
11 opinions in the discussion One of my college roommates' godfather left Orthodoxy years ago. Then he got hit by a truck crossing the street. His godchildren, who had never stopped praying for him, were the first ones… Read the discussion

Mortified after wardrobe malfunction during weekday liturgy with toddler

I have been attending an Orthodox church as an inquirer for a few months and am genuinely enjoying it. I have been reading and learning a lot, and I want to attend more often, get to know the community and the priest, and continue learning. I am a stay-at-home mother to a young toddler, so I decided to try a weekday liturgy for the first time, thinking it would help my child get used to the services if we go more frequently. My child behaved for…

I have been attending an Orthodox church as an inquirer for a few months and am genuinely enjoying it. I have been reading and learning a lot, and I want to attend more often, get to know the community and the priest, and continue learning. I am a stay-at-home mother to a young toddler, so I decided to try a weekday liturgy for the first time, thinking it would help my child get used to the services if we go more frequently.

My child behaved for most of the service, but right before communion she had a meltdown. I picked her up and she seemed to calm for a moment, then I looked down and saw the front of my dress had come unclasped and my bra was exposed right in front of the priest and everyone else. My child kept crying, so I quickly gathered my things and ran out.

I am completely mortified. The worst part is that I felt angry with my child, and this whole experience made me feel so far from what I was trying to do. I recently bought this dress specifically as something nice to wear to church. I am trying to do everything I can, and I feel like it all blew up in my face today. I am feeling really down about it.

  • Inquirer attending Orthodox church for a few months
  • Toddler meltdown right before communion at weekday liturgy
  • Dress came unclasped exposing bra in front of priest and congregation
  • Felt angry at child and spiritually discouraged
  • Feels like efforts to participate blew up in her face
18 opinions in the discussion Stuff like this just happens. Toddlers act like toddlers and you handled it as well as anyone could. I'd sew a stitch or put a button on the dress, and if anyone brings it up, just own that… Read the discussion

Can someone explain why Patriarch Bartholomew is hated?

As an Orthodox Christian, I think I should be cautious about judging clergy, since I might be deeply mistaken. Being Bulgarian, I have seen the Patriarch's current visit to my country provoke insults, hatred, and criticism. The negative remarks come from both a harshly judgmental stance and a seemingly Christian one, from churchgoers and from people who do not attend church but are full of hate. The attacks are both political and church-related.…

As an Orthodox Christian, I think I should be cautious about judging clergy, since I might be deeply mistaken. Being Bulgarian, I have seen the Patriarch's current visit to my country provoke insults, hatred, and criticism. The negative remarks come from both a harshly judgmental stance and a seemingly Christian one, from churchgoers and from people who do not attend church but are full of hate. The attacks are both political and church-related.

Can someone help me understand the full picture? Is the situation in Ukraine the main issue, or is it his ecumenism? Why is he so controversial, and how should I best approach these topics?

It has been heartbreaking to watch insults fly and divisions grow. We do not need more division in the Orthodox Church, yet we also need honest assessments.

I would appreciate it if someone knowledgeable could weigh in.

God bless you all.

  • Why is Patriarch Bartholomew so hated, especially in Bulgaria during his visit?
  • Is the Ukraine issue the primary cause, or his ecumenical activity?
  • Why is he so controversial overall?
  • How should one approach these topics?
  • The post expresses sorrow over division and insults, and a desire for honest assessment.
16 opinions in the discussion There are three problems here. First, ecumenism. Some people freak out over the slightest contact with Catholics, but others are legitimately bothered that Pat. Bartholomew spends more time… Read the discussion
r/OrthodoxChristianity Reddit discussion

Unwelcome at a ROCOR parish, questioning ethnic focus

My wife and I are Orthodox. One Sunday we visited a ROCOR parish on a whim instead of our usual church, and the experience was rough. Everyone stared at us constantly. Even when we bought candles it was obvious they did not want us there, and they made us feel very unwelcome. They commented on our children. I get the feeling this is just how Russians are in general? Is ROCOR like this? We have never been treated this way by anyone. When we were…

My wife and I are Orthodox. One Sunday we visited a ROCOR parish on a whim instead of our usual church, and the experience was rough. Everyone stared at us constantly. Even when we bought candles it was obvious they did not want us there, and they made us feel very unwelcome. They commented on our children.

I get the feeling this is just how Russians are in general? Is ROCOR like this? We have never been treated this way by anyone. When we were Catholic everyone was quite happy to have us at their parish. It makes me wary to try any other parish besides our usual one, honestly. I do not understand why everything has to be so ethnically focused.

Sometimes it makes me remember and yearn for when we were Catholic and never had to worry about visiting any parish, or about suspicions directed at me and my family.

  • Visited a ROCOR parish and felt stared at and unwelcome
  • Treated poorly even when purchasing candles
  • Comments made about their children
  • Asks if this is typical of Russians or ROCOR specifically
  • Contrasts with Catholic parishes where they felt welcome; questions ethnic focus in Orthodoxy
19 opinions in the discussion Just last week a priest gave a very brief sermon in our monastery: a woman with two children came into the church wearing pants with her hair uncovered, and one of the older women… Read the discussion