WeOrthodox
EN UA
r/OrthodoxChristianity Reddit

Tell your priest when parish conversations drive visitors away

Everyone is on their own Orthodox journey. A person might walk into church for the first time on a Sunday, coming from a completely non-religious background. They might fall in love with the Liturgy, feel drawn to Orthodoxy, and then hear people making political comments or jokes during coffee hour that make them uncomfortable enough to never come back.

I know it's hard to avoid current events when they seem to happen every day, and I recognize people can hold different political and social views without those differences being incompatible with Orthodoxy. But when a visitor hears people taking rigid, uncompromising stances on these issues, it can be hard to reconcile that atmosphere with the welcome and love they experienced in the Liturgy.

My bigger point is this: please tell your priest if this is happening in your parish.

Yes, it's possible he's aware of the conversations and supports them. But it's much more likely he simply doesn't know they're happening. Priests are busy on Sundays. Mine is lucky to make it to coffee hour before the coffee gets cold, and once he arrives he's often surrounded by people wanting to talk with him. He may not have the chance to see or hear everything happening around the room.

He needs to know if there is discord in the parish or if conversations are taking place publicly that could make visitors uncomfortable and discourage them from returning. He can decide whether to address the issue privately with the individual involved or speak to the parish as a whole.

And this applies to so much more than politics.

If someone is telling people they need to go to confession because they voted a certain way, insisting that homeschooling is the only acceptable way to raise children and making mothers who don't homeschool feel inadequate, or declaring that Mickey Mouse is of the devil, please tell your priest.

We cannot assume that everyone who walks through our church doors has the same background, experiences, opinions, or understanding of Orthodoxy. We should be making room for people to grow in their faith, ask questions, and find their place in the Church, not telling them they're unwelcome because of the things we discuss.

Edit to add: I'm on the parish council and we have been given a strict directive by the priest to alert him when we hear these kinds of conversations. Everything I said came from what he told us.

Main points

  • Visitors may be driven away by rigid political or social comments during coffee hour
  • Priests often don't hear these conversations because they're busy on Sundays
  • Parishioners should alert the priest so he can address the issue appropriately
  • The problem extends beyond politics to any extreme stance that makes people feel unwelcome
  • The author's priest directed the parish council to report such conversations
52 opinions in the discussion 21 participants, 39 replies to each other The opinion with the most support I don't believe any serious Christian should lean too hard into any political ideology. I get suspicious when someone clearly puts their political side above their faith. If you'd say someone isn't a Christian just because they vote for a different party than… Read the discussion
127 comments at the source Original on Reddit

Discussion · 52

Opinions are anonymous retellings of real comments from the original discussion. The same colour marks the same participant.

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

  • opinion#3970

    I don't believe any serious Christian should lean too hard into any political ideology. I get suspicious when someone clearly puts their political side above their faith. If you'd say someone isn't a Christian just because they vote for a different party than you, you need to take a hard look at yourself. The right and the left can both become an idol.

  • opinion#3971

    I'm a bit confused and hope I'm not putting words in your mouth. Are you saying nothing political should ever be expressed during liturgy, or only not the "extreme" stuff? Because when people say keep out the "extreme" beliefs, extreme means different things to different people. What one person calls the mildest opinion, another would find shocking.

    • opinion#3983

      Better to skip politics entirely at coffee hour. In my parish it's an unwritten rule, and we're all the better for it.

      • opinion#3993

        It's a good standard to try to hold to. Politics are a stumbling block.

        • opinion#4001

          I tend to think this is an especially American problem. I recently saw a post saying supporters of one Orthodox jurisdiction in a certain dispute were "Republicans" and supporters of another were "Democrats". Not being able to see the church outside the American two party lens should maybe prompt some self reflection.

      • opinion#3994

        Funny how St John Chrysostom has 3 sermons that have been preached countless times over the centuries, and by modern American standards 2 of them are purely political. Yet American Orthodox people are obsessed with being "non-political." It's almost like the church was always political, on the side of the oppressed, and Americans just don't want to hear it.

        • opinion#4002

          Not political, just the social teaching of the Church

          • opinion#4009

            Talk about your neighbors' food and housing at coffee hour and in most churches you'll get accused of talking politics.

            • opinion#4014

              Sadly, in many parishes I've visited, the people pushing for the opposite are the loudest ones.

        • opinion#4003

          Which homilies are you thinking of besides the Pascha homily?

          • opinion#4010

            His "Homilies on Wealth and Poverty". The one that strikes me most is where he says if you have a second set of clothes or food in your pantry, you've stolen them from your brothers.

        • opinion#4004

          On the side of the oppressed, but not on the side of their sins. That's an important distinction the average American doesn't or won't make.

          • opinion#4011

            St Macrina says in "On the Soul and the Resurrection" that when sinful passions take root young it's like wheats and tares: when you pull out the tares you disturb the good soil and the wheat starves, and in some cases removing the sin removes their capacity to love God.

            • opinion#4015

              I'm fairly sure St Macrina wasn't trying to condone the sin.

              • opinion#4017

                She also convinced her mother, when her father died, to free their slaves and live as equals with them in community, sharing joint ownership of the family land. Her reasoning: an enslaved or poor person lacks what's needed to seek God, and slave holders and the wealthy are what stands between the destitute and salvation, not their sin. That doesn't come through as cleanly in a book handed down for 1600 years.

              • opinion#4018

                Have you actually read "On the Soul and the Resurrection"? Because she does address it, and in pretty plain terms too.

                • opinion#4019

                  I think you're mixing up recognizing that someone sins and recognizing that sin can lead to repentance with actually condoning the sin, which would mean treating it as not a sin at all. That's an easy mistake to make if you were raised in the modern West, but you should work on getting rid of it. For a lot of Westerners, condoning equals acceptance. That's really not the job of laypeople like us. That belongs to our bishops.

                  • opinion#4020

                    She says that if lust is the only pull a person has toward love, then stripping them of their lust removes their path to God. Are you seriously going to lecture me on misreading a text you've never even opened, just because you don't like what it says?

                    • opinion#4021

                      "that when SINFUL PASSIONS" I understand it perfectly well. You're skirting the edge of accusing a saint of serious heresy. I think you're the one who needs to look in the mirror and ask whether YOU are the one not understanding, or just not liking, what St Macrina is saying.

    • opinion#3984

      It's not an arbitrary line, it's a context-dependent one. Say you came inquiring into Orthodoxy and heard a parishioner say, "and of course if you're not vegan, can you really call yourself a Christian?" That could scandalize you, right? Especially if the listener is unlearned and untaught. Christians are supposed to avoid unnecessary scandal, especially false scandal. Once while volunteering at church an old man said, "wish we could go back to when only land-owning men could vote." I knew he was just talking out of his ass from some half-formed thought, but what if I were one of these zoomers who can't tell? What if I were new to Christianity, or to organized groups generally? I could drop personal hot takes at coffee hour that would scandalize the average North American parishioner. But I shouldn't, because it's *unnecessary* scandal. Listen twice, speak once, mind where you are. That kind of thing. This is basic Christian stuff, not part of your contemporary discourse about speech or whatever.

      • opinion#3995

        What you say is true. Growing up, we were taught (and graded on) comportment in school. One thing I learned is that in polite company (which includes a house of worship) you didn't discuss things like religion, politics, money, scandalous gossip, complaints about work or school, etc. We were told to stick to the weather, a local event, maybe a movie or a book. Keep it light. In college, when they were preparing us for the professional world, they always recommended following a local team, because it gave you something to talk about with strangers, and no matter how passionate a fan you meet, nobody will think you're offensive for holding a passionate differing view. I don't think this gets taught anymore (or at least it hasn't been learned).

        • opinion#4005

          Following local sports is a big one. Personally, I'd never turn a game on by myself, but I do keep up with the football team of my Alma mater back home, and even though I live two states away now, having a friendly football rivalry with someone (especially if their school was a rival) and then admitting I don't really care for the sport itself, but I love the fandom and the game day rituals, almost a secular liturgy in a way, is a lot of fun for me. I've had some genuinely interesting and even formative conversations that started that way, conversations that never would have happened if I hadn't found something about the game I could talk about.

  • opinion#3972

    And what if the priest is the extreme one...?

    • opinion#3985

      I felt comfortable enough with my priest to call him out when he made a joking statement, and a few days later he emailed everyone who'd heard it with an apology. If you feel comfortable, you can do the same. Otherwise, I'm sorry you have to deal with that.

      • opinion#3996

        Good for you! I have told him some things during confession... but there are other things where pointing them out would make me look self-righteous and judgmental. I mean, what do you do when he thinks women should be trad wives with many many children and homeschool them, and initially berates you for divorcing when the reason is abuse. Not enough people are _______ (brave? Foolish? Concerned?) like you and me...

  • opinion#3973

    Also, make sure you tell your priest if someone speaks about supporting transgenderism, BLM, cultural Marxism, has TDS (Trump Derangement Syndrome), wants to help women get abortions, agrees women should be ordained deacons/and/or priests, etc. See, it goes both ways. So why don't you instead focus on your OWN salvation, and your OWN journey, and let the priest do his job? Now of course, if someone does or says something egregious, or illegal, then please do report it to the priest. But this post has "I'm actually a leftist at an Orthodox church attempting to subvert the Church and I need to weed out all those right wingers!" written all over it.

    • opinion#3986

      Yes, let's not tell the priest that the reason our visitor from Cambodia never came back was that a group of people were loudly discussing how America isn't white enough during coffee hour.

      • opinion#3997

        Yes, let's not tell the priest that the reason a visitor left and never came back was that a group of people were discussing how the parish isn't "diverse enough" and we need more people of color coming to the parish. It can go both ways my friend, it can go both ways... Both statements (not white enough, not diverse enough) come from the same problematic source and both are the opposite of Orthodoxy.

        • opinion#4006

          It can and it should, and anyone discussing controversial things should be addressed. There isn't a problem at my parish with people discussing their frequent abortions, so that's not an example I gave. If that's a problem in your parish, that's what your priest needs to hear about. Edit: I wanted to make clear that the person I originally replied to had a different comment than what he edited it to, and my reply was responding to that. His original comment was more along the lines of saying right wing talk should be "policed." It wasn't a direct comparison to my comment, but rather discussing trans library visits and other extreme left view points.

          • opinion#4012

            You go right ahead and police your coffee hour. I'm sure your fellow parishioners would appreciate the effort. Let me know when you're all alone and you no longer have any friends at your parish. You completely missed my point, but I shouldn't expect anything different. I should lower my expectations of my fellow countrymen's reading comprehension.

            • opinion#4016

              Thanks a lot for editing your comment so that now it looks like I answered in a way I never did.

  • opinion#3974

    My faith shapes how I vote. But that's my own business. I remember when people didn't have to broadcast who they voted for. It's kind of ridiculous! If a Priest wants to share, as the Shepard of the flock, how he feels on political matters, that's one thing. Politics often affect the church. But beyond him, I couldn't care less what the other parishioners' political views are.

    • opinion#3987

      well when voting dictates the lives of others, who you vote for DOES matter. voting leading to abortion and transgender children should be the two easiest examples for the reddit crowd of Orthodox to at least acknowledge as important issues, and if not, I guess I'm one of the extreme ones you want reported

      • opinion#3998

        I don't think anyone's saying people should be "reported" for opposing abortion. I'm pro-life myself. But if someone at my parish's coffee hour keeps dropping comments about how XYZ politician wants to "murder babies" or something like that, people would rightly raise eyebrows. Same if someone kept going on about the government "kidnapping immigrants" or whatever. For me it's not really the content, it's that people feel the need to bring up inherently divisive stuff during fellowship time

        • opinion#4007

          Agreed, in the House of God there are better ways to spend your time than using words you know will divide your fellow worshippers.

  • opinion#3975

    Sadly, especially in the US, I think a lot of people have swapped an unflinching belief in God/the Church for an unflinching belief in political party. It's a bit of a psychological trap: we know God is the only one who can truly cure the ills of this world, but God's time isn't ours, so we grab onto the party that promises to fix everything closest to "our time" - we'll catch up with God later, so to speak. The problem is Christ is "the same yesterday, today, and forever," but politicians, being human and flawed, can barely stay the same for one sentence. The party that backs feeding the poor today might vote for Medicaid/SNAP cuts tomorrow. The party proclaiming Christian values at sunrise will spew hatred by lunch. Can we fix all that ourselves? No. Can we make sure we aren't one of the people spewing hate, putting politics over God, and dividing those around us by forcing political talk? Absolutely. Sometimes a simple "One of the reasons I come to church is to take a break from politics. I'd rather hear how you're doing. How are you? How's your family? Anything fun lately?" really helps.

  • opinion#3976

    See, that's the thing. I did tell my priest. He did nothing. I've had orthobros online and in person threaten me for not submitting to their insane beliefs, so I took the proper steps and reported them to their priests. I can't tell you how many times I've reported something serious to a priest and they did nothing, supported it, or said 'not my problem'. It's happened in the oriental church, in the eastern church, with men, with women, serious offenses and minor concerns alike. Some of you need to accept that a lot of priests genuinely don't care.

    • opinion#3988

      I'm genuinely curious - in your mind, what is the priest supposed to do? He can talk to people, but is correcting political opinions his job? I'm as frustrated as anyone with the bizarre parts of online orthodoxy seeping into real life, but I'm not convinced it's the priest's job to fix it. Mostly because I'm not sure what "fixing it" would even look like, short of telling people not to come to church

    • opinion#3989

      How did they threaten you? Did they threaten to harm you physically? Materially? Threaten to hurt someone you love? If so, you need to contact law enforcement in addition to telling your priest (if this person is in your parish). If they threatened you physically or materially and your priest did nothing, that's egregious. So, how did they threaten you?

  • opinion#3977

    My priest shut down certain conversations at my parish when Russia annexed Crimea. We had both Russian and Ukrainian immigrants. He didn't want arguments hurting the parish. I think that's the only way to serve a congregation. Church is a place for faith and growth of the spirit. A good priest will step in so everyone feels comfortable.

  • opinion#3978

    Maybe this is a man/woman thing, but what you're describing, for men, is total censorship, panopticon-level community policing, and ideological conformity. It keeps everyone's beliefs, opinions, and values locked in a dark closet where nobody knows what anyone believes, everyone's afraid to talk, and every issue festers in their chest. Men have repeatedly come to our parish with *hyper* extreme political views. What happens, if they don't just disappear, is that seasons of fasting and liturgical life, strong community, and hard scrutiny of their ideology dismantles it. It softens them and strengthens them. I've seen it over and over: if we drag each other through Lent and Holy Week, we become better versions of ourselves, political ideology (ideology of all kinds) fades in priority, gets tempered by confrontation with the gospel, and the renewing of the mind happens. But maybe that's because I'm a man and male social dynamics differ, and maybe my parish is unusual in that several core members of the convert cohort (myself included) have socio-political views that are impossible to map and fit no existing box.

  • opinion#3979

    You said "He needs to know if there is discord in the parish or if conversations are taking place publicly that could make visitors uncomfortable and discourage them from returning...." I agree with the second part, learning if uncomfortable and discouraging conversations are happening publicly. But what do you mean he NEEDS to know if there is discord in the parish? What is the priest's business with other people's private group chats to that degree? Sure, bad association spoils useful habits, and the priest should make sure his flock isn't being badly influenced. But I think there's a fine line you have to draw between loving spiritual provision and high-control cult-like Jehovah's Witness tactics

    • opinion#3990

      Discord as in strife, not *a* Discord as in the chat platform. That said... >But what do you mean when you say he NEEDS to know if there is a Discord in the parish. What is the priest's business with other people's private group chats to that extent? There are situations--we've seen this many times over the past seven years--where a religious Discord server starts functioning as an anarchist parasynagogue. People turn to it for fellowship, spiritual guidance, "testing", etc. *over-and-above* the real-life parish. These digital ersatz 'fellowships' become witches' covens of gossip, backbiting, purity-testing, fringe weirdos, anti-hierarchy. If that's happening, parish leadership--priest, maybe lay leaders, even the bishop if needed--should know so it stops working as a parasynagogue.

      • opinion#3999

        "There are situations--and we've seen this many times over the past seven years--where a religious Discord chat server begins to function as an anarchist parasynagogue. People turn to it for fellowship, spiritual guidance, "testing", etc. *over-and-above* the real-life parish. These digital ersatz 'fellowships' become witches' covens of gossip, backbiting, purity-testing, fringe weirdos, anti-hierarchy." That's happening all over social media. Policing other people's conversations and reporting them to the priest isn't the way. It makes you look like the bad guy, people will find out it was you and resent you. What I do instead is suggest to my priest and other parish leaders that they maybe give a talk on what our relationship to social media should be according to Orthodoxy, and I personally encourage and create more in-person activities (hikes, dinners at someone's house, pilgrimages to monestaries, etc)

        • opinion#4008

          >That's happening all over social media. Policing other people's conversations and reporting them to the priest isn't the way to go. They wouldn't have to find out, I'd tell them. >It will make you look like the bad guy and people will find out it was you and resent you. Part of being an adult is being willing to be the bad guy sometimes. This isn't "a bunch of hurt kids getting together to commiserate" that we must write off, and it isn't part of contemporary drama about speech, safety, etc. Rather, if people at the parish start or drive some radtrad discord that becomes a source of scandal, it gets dragged into the light of day one way or another.

          • opinion#4013

            Sure thing, your Grace, I'll be sure to let you know right away whenever I catch wind of any wrongdoing among my fellow parishioners... oh wait, hold on, you're not actually a bishop! Never mind then, my mistake.

    • opinion#3991

      Private group chats aren't really what I mean here. I'm talking about people talking openly at events where the whole parish shows up. But even then, part of a priest's job is knowing what his parishioners are going through. Worst case scenario, he tells you that sounds like something for confession, and you realize you were just gossiping over nothing. Best case, it turns out to be something he genuinely needed to hear about. To be fair, I sit on the parish council, so maybe my sense of duty to see and hear what goes on in the church is different from an ordinary member's.

  • opinion#3980

    I did. He brushed me off, didn't care, and gave me really naive answers about stuff I knew far better than he did. He also dismissed very serious concerns and claims from people I knew, and took no responsibility at all for looking into them, building trust, or even talking with the people involved. So I left that parish, found a new one, and moved on. My faith and my mental health are both better for it. Other people have done the same since, and some have unfortunately left Orthodoxy altogether. It's awful that this is a reality people face. I have huge respect for priests like yours who are willing to openly shield their congregations from that kind of discord.

  • opinion#3981

    This is a real struggle for me. I live in a small, conservative city, so a lot of the people drawn to Orthodoxy here are very right-wing politically, and I'm not. I wish I could have the community, but I end up settling for just attending the Liturgy. We're still polite with each other and can chat about small things, but it's hard to go deeper or get more involved than that.

    • opinion#3992

      Don't assume that being different automatically means conflict. Hearing each other's honest thoughts is part of what makes a community actually work. The world has trained us to retreat into our own little echo chambers where nobody ever objects to anything we say, or else we just keep quiet... but that's not normal, and the church community doesn't have to be squeezed into that disordered way of living. People, both them and you, are allowed to hold a point of view.

      • opinion#4000

        I think politics have become so divisive that people have forgotten how to be at peace with others holding different views. Everyone just wants to be the one who's right and to pull everyone else over to their side. I rarely see people having a real conversation about their differences without some hidden agenda of "converting" the other person, and that's exactly where the problem is.

  • opinion#3982

    It's not that Orthodox theology isn't generally conservative or that the church isn't opposed to abortion. It's just that when someone new walks into a church, that probably shouldn't be the first thing they get talked to about. Abortion absolutely is murder WHEN the baby is viable, and especially so with partial or full birth abortions. You could make an argument in the first couple of weeks that it maybe isn't. And when the mother's life is in danger, it's justified. But none of that is exactly welcoming conversation for newcomers to your church.