WeOrthodox
EN UA
r/OrthodoxChristianity Reddit

Why are Orthodox parishes in America less accessible than Catholic churches?

It appears that parishes in this country are not very active. Several parishes are near me, yet each offers only vespers and a single Divine Liturgy on Sunday at a set time. My work schedule prevents me from attending most Liturgies. I have noticed that Catholic churches remain open daily, with at least one Mass each day or some form of adoration, making the church accessible. Why is the Orthodox Church never accessible?

18 opinions in the discussion 16 participants, 9 replies to each other The opinion with the most support Catholic priests are basically monks in practice. Their only responsibility is the parish, they often have several priests plus paid staff who can be at the building outside service times. We usually have one paid person, the priest, and he's frequently out… Read the discussion
76 comments at the source Original on Reddit

Discussion · 18

Opinions are anonymous retellings of real comments from the original discussion. The same colour marks the same participant.

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

  • opinion#4022

    Catholic priests are basically monks in practice. Their only responsibility is the parish, they often have several priests plus paid staff who can be at the building outside service times. We usually have one paid person, the priest, and he's frequently out on pastoral visits. So the doors might not be open as often, but there's a lot happening behind the scenes with very limited resources.

    • opinion#4031

      That's really sad. I wish every member of the clergy could get paid, and I'd honestly give up part of my own salary to help make that happen.

      • opinion#4038

        Donating to your local parish is a great place to start! Parishes here in the states get no outside funding, unlike those in historically Orthodox countries. It all comes from the congregation.

    • opinion#4032

      Also worth remembering that an Orthodox priest can only consecrate the Eucharist once a day. So with just one priest at a parish, that means one Liturgy per day at most. (As far as I understand it.) That's another reason most of our churches don't offer multiple Liturgy times.

      • opinion#4039

        If I recall right, the limit isn't only on the priest but also tied to how many altars the parish has.

    • opinion#4033

      Most of the priests I've met also hold a full time job on top of their priestly duties. We have a shortage of orthodox priests in this country too.

    • opinion#4034

      Also keep in mind a priest has to abstain from sex before serving the Divine Liturgy. If he's married and serves it every single day, that puts a real strain on his marriage.

  • opinion#4023

    I really think it comes down to numbers. My church gets 225 people on a Sunday, and there's a Greek, an Antiochian, and another OCA parish within 20 minutes of us. We're pretty blessed there. Where I used to be in Eastern PA, we were lucky to hit 30 on a Sunday, and the closest other Orthodox church was 45 minutes away. Daily services there would maybe draw 5 people. Even with the current boom in Orthodoxy, we're still tiny next to Catholics and Protestants in the US.

    • opinion#4035

      Honestly you're probably close to me, I'm in the Lehigh valley. Plenty of churches, not a lot of services (from what I know).

  • opinion#4024

    Basically: we're fewer than Catholics, spread thinner, we've kept the old weekly cycle with the rule of one liturgy per altar per day, and we're all at work all day far from the church, so nobody can keep it open around the clock. If you find a little chapel always open in the Old Country (TM), that's because people living right there look after it. Meanwhile in America, three drug-addicts broke into my brother's church last week, trashed the altar, and tried to steal the shiny stuff to pawn.

  • opinion#4025

    First, a man ordained to the catholic priesthood is required to say mass every day for the rest of his life. Some big catholic churches used to have all those side altars where a priest could say mass alone with no congregation. With the Orthodox, you need 2 (maybe 3) people present for a Divine Liturgy, one being the priest. So there has to be a "congregation." Even big parishes don't do a liturgy daily. We have 600 families (2 full time priests, 2 retired ones). Some weeks we have 1 weekday liturgy, some weeks 4 or 5 depending on feast days; usually 1 or 2. Weekday attendance is mostly retirees, and unless the senior group is meeting afterward, they often have to ask the sexton or church secretary to step in so a liturgy can happen. Monasteries do usually have daily liturgy. Parishes generally don't, not just in America but everywhere.

    • opinion#4036

      I believe the daily Mass requirement was dropped in the 1960s. Still, daily Mass culture runs deep among Catholics, to the point most have probably never even heard of Matins and Vespers. Vatican II's call to celebrate the Divine Office more often went unheeded, unfortunately (like a lot of other things). The big difference, though, is that all Catholic priests draw a salary and it's their only job.

  • opinion#4026

    You must be in the Northeast or Rust Belt where parishes mainly served one immigrant group. Very by Greeks for Greeks. (Serbs for Serbs, Russians for Russians etc.) That reads as exclusive to White American converts/inquirers. In reality a few things happened. 1. The founders' descendants assimilated and moved past their heritage, sadly including the church. 2. Some of these neighborhoods went downhill and the remaining members no longer live nearby. 3. Many of these parishes were founded with a strong pro-acting-American attitude, which often meant only Divine Liturgy and functioning as a social club. That said, I think it's changing, but you'll have to put in some effort to break in.

    • opinion#4037

      Lol I'm black, but I get exactly what you mean. I partially agree. My home parish is full of the original founders and there's no exclusivity problem. Just the right mix of ethnic and, I guess, what we'd see as normal American church stuff.

  • opinion#4027

    I moved several states away and I'm continually amazed at how constantly busy and active the church is here in the new place---- it's HUGE! Compared to what I'm used to, it's quite a shock.

  • opinion#4028

    Monasteries hold services every morning and evening, plus some in between. Parishes don't do it as often, depends on the priest, though some will do weekday services on major feasts. During Advent a lot of parishes keep the "sarantoleitourgo" (40 liturgies) with liturgy every day up to Nativity (Christmas). In Great Lent there are usually parish services Mon, Wed, and Fri on top of Sat/Sun. And from Aug 1-15 there are daily services for the Theotokos. But you're right, all things permitting, more weekday prayer services and liturgies would be better.

  • opinion#4029

    Our GOARCH parish has Wednesday Vespers and Friday Paraklesis regularly, plus Sunday Matins and Divine Liturgy. We have occasional weekday Liturgies on particular feasts too. The most recent was Exaltation of the Cross in September, and Dormition of the Theotokos before that. We also do some "special" services during the year. Next Wednesday (the day before Thanksgiving) will be an Akathist instead of regular Vespers, for example. We celebrate the Hours on Christmas Eve. Etc.

  • opinion#4030

    There are 2.6 million Orthodox in the US, there are 76 million Catholics. 30x the number. The simple fact is they have massively more resources, and outside of strongholds like Wichita, KS parishes just can't afford to do more than they do. You can ask if you can meet with your priest personally