WeOrthodox
EN UA
r/OrthodoxChristianity Reddit

Concern about convert disdain toward other Christians

I am a cradle Orthodox Christian living in the United States, and I am growing increasingly concerned and saddened by the disdain that many converts to the Orthodox faith display toward Christians of other denominations.

By the grace of God we belong to the original Church. Many Protestants, sincere in their faith, lived according to Christ's commandments and died in the hope of the resurrection and the life to come without ever knowing holy Orthodoxy.

This closed-mindedness and zealous self-righteousness reveals a lack of love and humility, and it actually harms our credibility as stewards of the true faith.

"If anyone says, 'I love God,' and hates his brother, he is a liar; for he who does not love his brother whom he has seen cannot love God whom he has not seen." Let us remain humble and take care not to lose sight of God's commandment, for He can raise up children of Abraham from stones. May God help us and save us by His mercy.

Main points

  • Converts often show disdain toward Christians of other denominations
  • Sincere Protestants lived faithfully and died in hope without knowing Orthodoxy
  • Self-righteousness reveals lack of love and humility
  • Such attitudes damage Orthodox credibility as stewards of the true faith
  • We must stay humble; God can raise children of Abraham from stones
19 opinions in the discussion 16 participants, 8 replies to each other The opinion with the most support Look at it from their side. Most converts came to Orthodoxy for a reason. Everyone coming from another tradition has something concrete that felt lacking where they were. Some left because something seemed incomplete, like the gap between most Protestant… Read the discussion
42 comments at the source Original on Reddit

Discussion · 19

Opinions are anonymous retellings of real comments from the original discussion. The same colour marks the same participant.

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

  • opinion#3902

    Look at it from their side. Most converts came to Orthodoxy for a reason. Everyone coming from another tradition has something concrete that felt lacking where they were. Some left because something seemed incomplete, like the gap between most Protestant communion and the Liturgy. Grape juice and crackers weren't enough. Worship that felt like a rock concert wasn't enough. That was me, even though I hadn't been to church in decades before Orthodoxy. Others were driven out by secular culture openly reshaping their faith. I'd be furious too if I walked in and saw the pastor, sometimes a woman, in a rainbow sash while the church celebrated pride and did same-sex weddings, or said things that defy basic common sense, let alone church teaching. As a group, converts have seen where Sola Scriptura leads in their old churches, and they hated it. Meeting people is hard, for some of us anyway. But a shared thread makes friendship easier. For most new catechumens, that thread is their bad experience in their old Protestant church. Not the same complaints, but everyone has a reason they went looking for Orthodoxy. That's their common ground and what they naturally talk about. As a cradle, you'll never walk in and see a lesbian pastor in rainbow robes preaching, under church authority and supposedly the Holy Spirit, that God is trans. Many converts have lived that or something like it.…

    • opinion#3913

      I'll say it even more simply. Being right does not give you license to look down on anyone.

    • opinion#3914

      Let me put it more simply. If a convert's attitude is more than half "thank God I'm not THERE anymore" versus "thank God I'm HERE now," you can't count on time alone to fix that. And on the point that catechism highlights the failures of other traditions and covers Sola Scriptura at length: I'd say that's overdone today and crowds out the fundamentals.

  • opinion#3903

    I think one role cradle Orthodox play in a parish full of converts is modeling moderation, showing that you can be Orthodox and still be a normal person in the world.

    • opinion#3915

      Absolutely. I've been Orthodox twenty years, more than half my life, and in some ways I'm basically cradle now. I was lucky to learn from the old generation that fled and survived Communism. The kindest, humblest, most devout people I've ever met. Without their example I probably would have left early on. Sadly that generation is gone. Now it's on us to be the example.

  • opinion#3904

    That zeal usually goes one of two ways. Either it fades as they mature in the faith, or it hardens, especially once online personalities feed it. Pray for these people, but also don't hold back on some brotherly and sisterly advice.

  • opinion#3905

    I'm cradle too and I agree. We can pray, set a good example, and give a friendly correction when needed. I think once they're in a community and see others NOT acting that way, they naturally calm down. I barely met any protestants growing up, mostly Catholics and other orthodox, and the protestants really lean into the self interpretation and sola scriptura thing. If a convert is getting overzealous, I think it matters to remind them that it's the priest's job to guide us through the Bible and Christ's teachings. Liturgy and prayer come first. Sure, you may have read and researched a lot, but none of us are experts or have the right to talk down to people. We're an ancient faith, not a modern politicized one... Lol....

  • opinion#3906

    It's the "zeal of the convert." The Catholic Church is seeing a similar wave of young traditionalist catechumens and converts. I don't think these young men and women streaming into the Apostolic churches are insincere. They were faithful Protestants looking for something more consistent and historically grounded in a world shaken by fast social and economic change. Orthodoxy has been called "Christianity unabridged" for a reason: the rituals and doctrines of its national churches have changed less over the past thousand years than any other Christian group, maybe except the Oriental Orthodox.

  • opinion#3907

    I recently went to a weekday vespers and bible study at my church, mostly catechumens, and afterward during the snacks and conversation I was honestly put off by how aggressive they were. It felt like they were importing the fire and brimstone attitude straight into the Orthodox Church. As a cradle Orthodox I never had that attitude and I don't like it.

    • opinion#3916

      I'm a convert but I sat in on the catechumen class at my new parish too. Turns out it's 95-100% male and under 25. They were debating whether we should even allow people in the church who miss more than three Sundays in a row without a proper excuse, per the canons or wherever. I kept quiet since it was my first time, but oh boy, I'm ready to be disliked. What I want to say is: I fully back what you're saying, it matches my own experience.

      • opinion#3919

        There are definitely people who spiritually misspell "canon" as "cannon" and want to fire it at people, yes.

      • opinion#3920

        Wow, that's crazy, almost identical to my experience! I literally told my husband, who's converting, that I was sorry and hoped it didn't put him off, because that attitude is so foreign to me. He hasn't seen much of it since after catechumen class he sits with me and our family and friends at coffee hour instead of with the catechumens, luckily. I know several of them are genuinely nice, but a lot are worryingly overzealous and self righteous and it makes me sad. I've always believed God is love above all, and that's not the vibe I get there.

    • opinion#3917

      We need to press our priests on teaching compassion too. Fine, teach the intellectually correct material, but if they're not living Orthodoxy, what's the point?

  • opinion#3908

    Love is central in Orthodoxy. Jesus said love thy neighbor. He didn't say love thy neighbor unless you're better than him because you were raised in or discovered the original church. Jesus forgave the people who betrayed and killed him. He said judge not lest ye be judged. He said what you do to the least of these you do to me. We have no right to judge people, we're actively told not to, especially over how they pray.

  • opinion#3909

    True, and excess is a problem. **But** as someone teaching a sunday school class of mixed cradle and convert teens, I can tell you cradles often act like their church is just one option among many, with an assumption that not everyone can be Orthodox, and that VERY often slides into religious indifferentism. Cradles brought in at 40 days old who've never been anywhere else don't realize they're on a boat while everyone else is drowning out there. People in our cities are well read, media saturated, doing amateur theology, reading the Bible with no guide, making bold claims about morality, religion, ethics, doctrine, history and God himself. They're not rural afghanis on a goat farm. Converts are like that because they wish someone had been that way to them sooner.

  • opinion#3910

    I think the problem is that people can't separate Christ's actual teachings and the mystical tradition from the institutional structures and the human failures they're angry about. The criticism aims at the wrong target, especially since Orthodoxy has the same institutional flaws, the same hypocrisy, and the same abuses of religious authority. Though honestly, religious legalism was around in Christ's day too, and He called it out directly.

  • opinion#3911

    I don't really disagree with most of what you said, but the internet makes everything look more extreme, including the impression that there's an epidemic of extremism or that "many" people are self-righteous. Who are these "many" and do their errors actually matter to us? What are ordinary laymen supposed to do besides just live our lives without being extremists (or ecumenists) ourselves? I have a strange reaction to posts like this. I mostly agree with the content, but I'm not sure it needs to be said so often. If you know someone holding extreme wrong views and you can correct them, fine. But how does stirring up reactions to supposed trends on Reddit do anything besides create a rival faction and more division? So I have very mixed feelings. And maybe I shouldn't post either.

  • opinion#3912

    My parish has a Bonhoeffer biography in its lending library, and when I bring up the moral theology and philosophy of Ratzinger (Caritas in Veritate, for example) or Wojtyła (Love and Responsibility), nobody assumes I accept papal primacy or that I'm a schismatic. I just think some of the furniture from my earlier traditions is really good furniture, with plenty of wisdom for everyone to learn from. I took a lot of it with me when I changed churches over the Filioque, of course, but the bookcase, not the chair of Peter.

    • opinion#3918

      Also, I just remembered an embarrassing moment from when I was a brand new Catholic convert in my early twenties and, out of pain aimed at my former community but generalized to all Protestants, said something like that they had no grace or truth in them. My old confessor overheard and said, ah ah ah, be charitable! They may not believe in the Real Presence or the Pope, but they believe in Jesus and 66 books of the Bible, and they're our separated brethren. Then about a decade later, when I told him I was leaving communion with Rome to become Orthodox, he said something like: of course he disagreed with me on the Filioque, but the Orthodox have Jesus in the sacraments and apostolic succession, and wherever I went, keep following Jesus and go in peace. Even though I'm Orthodox now, I think about those moments constantly when dealing with people outside the church and discussing faith and our differences with them. We can state those differences with charity, but we must never forget the human being on the other side of the conversation.