WeOrthodox
EN UA

День Седьмой. Alexey Uminskiy

YouTube ↗ 14 discussions

Alexey Uminskiy

Fr. Alexey Uminsky: Why Christians Cannot Accept Reincarnation

Fr. Alexey Uminsky: Why Christians Cannot Accept Reincarnation 2:54

In a live-streamed question-and-answer session from August 25, 2026, Fr. Alexey Uminsky responds to a viewer's question about reincarnation. He states plainly that a Christian cannot believe in reincarnation because it is completely absurd for a Christian and contradicts the faith in the general resurrection. Christians believe that each person will rise in the body in which they were born, since a person is the image and likeness of God as a…

In a live-streamed question-and-answer session from August 25, 2026, Fr. Alexey Uminsky responds to a viewer's question about reincarnation. He states plainly that a Christian cannot believe in reincarnation because it is completely absurd for a Christian and contradicts the faith in the general resurrection. Christians believe that each person will rise in the body in which they were born, since a person is the image and likeness of God as a whole, spirit, soul, and body together, not as separate parts.

The Son of God became incarnate, took upon Himself the fullness of human nature, rose bodily in the very body in which He was born, ascended to heaven, and abides at the right hand of the Father in that body. Every person will rise bodily in the body in which they were born; every person is a unique personality and unique in their physicality.

The body is not a worn-out work uniform that can be changed; human gender and what a human is are not things that can be changed, they are what a person is born as and who they become, part of their personhood. Therefore Christians do not believe in any kind of reincarnation, and a person who believes in reincarnation cannot call themselves a Christian in the true sense of the faith.

The session was part of a regular live broadcast; Fr. Uminsky also announced the next stream for November 17 at 19:00 Moscow time and invited questions via email or live chat.

Key moments

  1. 0:00 If a person is a Christian and believes in Christ, they simply cannot believe in reincarnation, because it is completely absurd for a Christian.
  2. 0:32 Christians believe in the general resurrection, the resurrection of each of us in the body in which we were born.
  3. 0:32 A person is the image and likeness of God, spirit, soul, and body, the whole person, not separate parts.
  4. 1:04 The Son of God became incarnate, took upon Himself the fullness of human nature, rose bodily in the very body in which He was born, ascended to heaven, and abides at the right hand of the Father in that body.
  5. 1:35 Every person will rise bodily in the body in which they were born; every person is a unique personality and unique in their physicality.
  6. 2:06 The body is not a worn-out work uniform that can be changed; human gender and what a human is are not things that can be changed, they are what a person is born as and who they become, part of their personhood.
  7. 2:06 Therefore Christians do not believe in any kind of reincarnation, and a person who believes in reincarnation cannot call themselves a Christian in the true sense of the faith.
4 opinions in the discussion The soul part is unclear. Either God creates a new soul for each new person, or a person gets their soul along with the body from their parents. The theory that God created all souls in… Read the discussion

Father Alexey Uminsky on faith, emigration, and reconciliation after war

Father Alexey Uminsky on faith, emigration, and reconciliation after war 20:13

Father Alexey Uminsky speaks with Sergey Nikolaevich for ZIMA Magazine in London about preserving faith during war and catastrophe. He says there are no techniques for faith; the Book of Job shows God answers with presence, not explanations. True faith requires a personal encounter with God, not just ritual, and crisis can become the moment that encounter begins. He describes his unchosen move to France, where Father Vladimir Yegel gave him a…

Father Alexey Uminsky speaks with Sergey Nikolaevich for ZIMA Magazine in London about preserving faith during war and catastrophe. He says there are no techniques for faith; the Book of Job shows God answers with presence, not explanations. True faith requires a personal encounter with God, not just ritual, and crisis can become the moment that encounter begins.

He describes his unchosen move to France, where Father Vladimir Yegel gave him a parish at the Church of the Sign of the Mother of God and housing, and a multinational congregation that includes Russian-French families, other Orthodox nationalities, French converts, and recent relocants. The initial shock has passed; he maintains contact with parishioners through a YouTube channel.

The endless war is his only real worry; he and his parish pray constantly for peace, including a special petition by Father Vladimir for the end of bloodshed in Ukraine, the Middle East, and everywhere. His father died last year and he could not attend the funeral; parishioners surrounded his father with care and arranged the funeral while he watched online.

He notes that one can be freed from guilt but not from pain. Migration places terrible stress on families, and children suffer acutely. Reconciliation between Russians and Ukrainians may or may not happen; it requires repentance, as the unreconciled Armenian Genocide shows.

The church's only role in war is to work for peace, which he sees Pope Francis modeling by rejecting all war justifications and intervening for ceasefires.

Key moments

  1. 1:04 There are no techniques for faith and no manuals; the Book of Job screams the question of suffering to heaven and gives no answer, only God's presence.
  2. 2:05 Preserving faith requires a personal encounter with God, not just ritual or moral rules, because crisis reveals when faith hasn't actually happened yet.
  3. 5:13 He did not choose France; Father Vladimir Yegel offered him the parish at the Church of the Sign, gave him housing at the church, and organized his life.
  4. 8:21 The parish includes Russian-French families, other Orthodox nationalities, French converts, and recent "relocants," with services in a mix of languages.
  5. 12:34 The endless war is his only real worry; the parish prays constantly for peace, and Father Vladimir composed a special petition for the end of bloodshed in Ukraine, the Middle East, and everywhere.
  6. 13:38 His father died last year and he could not come to bury him; parishioners surrounded his father with care to the end and arranged the funeral, while he watched via the internet.
  7. 14:40 A person can free themselves from guilt by understanding it was impossible, but cannot free themselves from the pain.
  8. 17:14 Reconciliation between nations is possible only with repentance; without it, hatred remains entrenched, as with the Armenian Genocide, and the church's sole role in war is to work for peace, which Pope Francis exemplifies.
Read more

Fr. Alexey Uminsky on the Rich Man and Lazarus: True Wealth and Seeing Our Neighbor

Fr. Alexey Uminsky on the Rich Man and Lazarus: True Wealth and Seeing Our Neighbor 10:56

Fr. Alexey Uminsky preaches on the parable of the rich man and Lazarus from Luke 16. He notes Luke's particular indignation toward the wealthy who show no mercy, emphasizing that God casts down the mighty and exalts the humble. Wealth itself does not make a person bad, nor poverty good; poverty can drive people to crime and decay, and there is nothing good in poverty itself. Lazarus is named while the rich man remains unnamed. The name Lazarus…

Fr. Alexey Uminsky preaches on the parable of the rich man and Lazarus from Luke 16. He notes Luke's particular indignation toward the wealthy who show no mercy, emphasizing that God casts down the mighty and exalts the humble. Wealth itself does not make a person bad, nor poverty good; poverty can drive people to crime and decay, and there is nothing good in poverty itself.

Lazarus is named while the rich man remains unnamed. The name Lazarus means "God is my help," indicating he is not forgotten by God and represents a path to God. The sermon connects Lazarus to the Canaanite woman who asked for crumbs from the Lord's table; both images show faith and humility that accept life as a gift from God's hand, even bitter bread.

Lazarus is comforted because he accepted his bitter bread from the Lord, while the rich man suffers; a fixed chasm separates them. The rich man knew Lazarus by name but did not want him in his life, not wanting to disturb his peace; he did not do evil actively but ignored the poor at his gate. In hell the rich man comes to his senses, realizes he lived wrongly, and asks Abraham to send Lazarus to warn his brothers so they might repent.

Abraham replies that they have Moses and the prophets; the rich man insists they would believe if someone rose from the dead, but Jesus raises Lazarus of Bethany and many still refuse to believe. The sermon concludes by applying the greatest commandment to Orthodox Christians today, warning against clinging to tradition and comfortable prosperity while overlooking suffering neighbors who need help, prayer, and love.

Key moments

  1. 0:30 Luke's Gospel shows particular indignation toward the rich who are unmerciful and cruel, emphasizing God casts down the mighty and exalts the humble.
  2. 1:33 Wealth does not make a person bad nor poverty good; poverty can drive people to crime and decay, and there is nothing good in poverty itself.
  3. 2:36 Lazarus is named while the rich man remains unnamed; the name Lazarus means "God is my help," showing he is not forgotten by God and represents a path to God.
  4. 4:09 Lazarus parallels the Canaanite woman who asked for crumbs from the Lord's table; both images show faith and humility that accept life as a gift from God's hand.
  5. 5:43 Lazarus is comforted because he accepted his bitter bread from the Lord, while the rich man suffers; a fixed chasm separates them.
  6. 6:13 The rich man knew Lazarus by name but did not want him in his life, not wanting to disturb his peace; he did not do evil actively but ignored the poor at his gate.
  7. 7:15 In hell the rich man comes to his senses, realizes he lived wrongly, and asks Abraham to send Lazarus to warn his brothers so they might repent.
  8. 8:16 Abraham says they have Moses and the prophets; the rich man insists they would believe if someone rose from the dead, but Jesus does raise Lazarus of Bethany and they still do not believe.
Read more

Fr. Alexei Uminsky Explains How to Understand the Gospel

Fr. Alexei Uminsky Explains How to Understand the Gospel 51:21

Priest Alexei Uminsky answers viewer questions about Gospel interpretation. He says the path to God begins with prayer and a thirst for God, not with resolving doctrinal contradictions, and directs readers to the Sermon on the Mount to hear Christ's voice. On Matthew 10:36, he explains that "a man's enemies will be those of his own household" describes the conflict when a person embraces the Beatitudes' vision of blessedness while their family…

Priest Alexei Uminsky answers viewer questions about Gospel interpretation. He says the path to God begins with prayer and a thirst for God, not with resolving doctrinal contradictions, and directs readers to the Sermon on the Mount to hear Christ's voice. On Matthew 10:36, he explains that "a man's enemies will be those of his own household" describes the conflict when a person embraces the Beatitudes' vision of blessedness while their family clings to earthly notions of well-being.

This division is now seen in families split over war and patriotism versus the Gospel. He addresses the Pharisees' Corban tradition as a legalistic loophole to avoid honoring parents, contrasting it with Christ's care for the widow of Nain's son and His entrusting of Mary to John from the cross. On Luke 14:31, he reads the context: discipleship requires counting the cost, forsaking all, and serious renunciation.

Regarding "turn the other cheek" and "give your cloak," he rejects the view that these avoid self-abasement, citing Chrysostom and Theophylact: they mean stopping evil by absorbing it, doing more than required, and losing property rather than love. He teaches that Christ's bodily healings always accompany spiritual healing ("go and sin no more"), and that Gethsemane shows the God-man taking full human fear and god-forsakenness, submitting His human will to the divine will.

On "sell your cloak and buy a sword," he says "sword" in Christ's mouth always means the Word of God, not a weapon. He dismisses apparent contradictions in the parables of the wedding banquet and the minas: the first speaks of inviting the poor who rejoice, the second depicts the Last Judgment on those who reject Christ, not forced conversion.

Key moments

  1. 2:40 The path to God begins with personal prayer and a thirst for God, not with resolving contradictions between religions; one should start with the Gospel, especially the Sermon on the Mount, to hear Christ's voice.
  2. 4:43 Matthew 10:36 ("enemies of his own household") describes the clash when a convert embraces the Beatitudes' true blessedness while their family holds earthly views of happiness, leading parents to oppose the Christian choice, a division now acute in families split over war and "Holy Rus" propaganda.
  3. 10:30 The Pharisees' Corban rule let people declare money for parents as a gift to God, nullifying the commandment to honor parents; Christ exposes this legalism, contrasting it with His resurrection of the widow of Nain's son (who was her sole support) and His own entrusting of Mary to John from the cross.
  4. 15:44 Luke 14:31's parable of the king with ten thousand illustrates the cost of discipleship: one must forsake all, deny self, take up the cross, and make serious renunciations before following Christ.
  5. 21:58 The Sermon on the Mount commands (turn the other cheek, give cloak, go two miles) are not about avoiding self-abasement but about absorbing evil without retaliation, doing more than required, and losing property rather than love, per Chrysostom and Theophylact.
  6. 29:17 Christ's bodily healings always accompany spiritual healing ("go and sin no more"); behind physical illness stands spiritual illness, and the miracles signify the healing of the soul.
  7. 31:52 In Gethsemane, the God-man (per Chalcedon) takes the fullness of human nature including fear, despair, and god-forsakenness; His human will resists death but submits to the divine will, showing the immensity of divine love.
  8. 42:44 At the Last Supper, Christ's "buy a sword" means the Word of God, not a weapon; the parables of the wedding banquet and the minas depict joyful invitation to the poor and the Last Judgment on those who reject Christ, not forced conversion.
6 opinions in the discussion A maniac who meets resistance stops attacking. If you don't stop him, evil will keep living on. But that's an extreme case. In general, Jesus Christ is right because he is holy. Not… Read the discussion

Fr. Alexey Uminsky on the Parable of the Sower: God sows His Word in every heart

Fr. Alexey Uminsky on the Parable of the Sower: God sows His Word in every heart 5:20

Fr. Alexey Uminsky preaches on the Parable of the Sower, opening with God's words to Adam before the expulsion: the earth will bring forth thorns and thistles, and you shall labor by the sweat of your brow; you are earth and to earth you shall return. The parable is precisely about this earth, which the Lord compares to a trodden path, stones, and thorns growing on the land. The sower in the parable is a strange figure because an experienced…

Fr. Alexey Uminsky preaches on the Parable of the Sower, opening with God's words to Adam before the expulsion: the earth will bring forth thorns and thistles, and you shall labor by the sweat of your brow; you are earth and to earth you shall return. The parable is precisely about this earth, which the Lord compares to a trodden path, stones, and thorns growing on the land.

The sower in the parable is a strange figure because an experienced sower chooses only good prepared soil, yet this sower scatters seed on the path, on stones, and among weeds where it is useless to sow. The seed obviously perishes in such places, but the strange sower does not stop sowing; the Lord explains to His disciples that this sower sows the Word of God.

The Lord Himself interprets the parable: when the seed falls into bad soil it perishes, birds peck it, cares of life choke it, and only good soil brings forth fruit thirty, sixty, and a hundredfold. The good soil must be found in us, in that same earth of which the Lord said it brings forth thorns and thistles; the seed is sown as divine hope that a person may work on heart, soul, and mind by the sweat of the brow to become fertile ground.

The Word of God is not only the Lord's teaching or commandments but the Word who was in the beginning with God and was God, He Himself, our Lord Jesus Christ, the incarnate Word. Christ is not afraid to sow Himself by the wayside, on stone, among thorns, anywhere at all, only to save man, to find man, and to give every person, despite hardness, trampled state, and lifelessness, the chance to live with Him and have eternal life.

The post also mentions a new project of reading books with Fr. Alexey, but the sermon itself centers on the call to become good ground for the divine seed.

Key moments

  1. 0:00 The speaker begins with God's words to Adam before the expulsion: the earth will bring forth thorns and thistles, and you shall labor by the sweat of your brow; you are earth and to earth you shall return.
  2. 0:33 Today's parable, the Parable of the Sower, is precisely about this earth, which the Lord compares to a trodden path, stones, and thorns growing on the land.
  3. 1:04 The sower in the parable is a strange figure because an experienced sower chooses only good prepared soil, yet this sower scatters seed on the path, on stones, and among weeds where it is useless to sow.
  4. 1:34 The seed obviously perishes in such places, but the strange sower does not stop sowing; the Lord explains to His disciples that this sower sows the Word of God.
  5. 2:06 The Lord Himself interprets the parable: when the seed falls into bad soil it perishes, birds peck it, cares of life choke it, and only good soil brings forth fruit thirty, sixty, and a hundredfold.
  6. 2:37 The good soil must be found in us, in that same earth of which the Lord said it brings forth thorns and thistles; the seed is sown as divine hope that a person may work on heart, soul, and mind by the sweat of the brow to become fertile ground.
  7. 3:40 The Word of God is not only the Lord's teaching or commandments but the Word who was in the beginning with God and was God, He Himself, our Lord Jesus Christ, the incarnate Word.
  8. 4:12 Christ is not afraid to sow Himself by the wayside, on stone, among thorns, anywhere at all, only to save man, to find man, and to give every person, despite hardness, trampled state, and lifelessness, the chance to live with Him and have eternal life.
Read more

Fr. Alexey Uminsky on asking God for material needs

Fr. Alexey Uminsky on asking God for material needs 3:47

Father Alexey Uminsky addresses whether Christians may ask God for material goods such as a home or employment. The questioner notes that some priests say it is fine but wonders why we should ask if God already knows our needs. The host references a program titled "Why doesn't God hear our prayers?" that discusses the Gospel words "Ask and you will receive" and "Whatever you ask the Father in My name, He will give you." Father Alexey affirms…

Father Alexey Uminsky addresses whether Christians may ask God for material goods such as a home or employment. The questioner notes that some priests say it is fine but wonders why we should ask if God already knows our needs. The host references a program titled "Why doesn't God hear our prayers?" that discusses the Gospel words "Ask and you will receive" and "Whatever you ask the Father in My name, He will give you."

Father Alexey affirms that we can ask God for material help, pointing to the Lord's Prayer petition "Give us this day our daily bread" as evidence that we ask for help in earthly life. He warns that earthly life and God's help in it should not take first place, because the promise "whatever you ask in My name" must be read in the context of the Sermon on the Mount: "Seek first the Kingdom of God and His righteousness, and all these things will be added to you."

If a person asks for God's things, spiritual goods such as salvation, wisdom, understanding, and God's will, that prayer will certainly be heard and joy will be complete. Once that primary prayer is heard, it is normal to also ask for earthly help; those in need of a home can ask for a home, and those seeking work can ask the Lord to help them find a good job.

Requests for material things should be for what is truly needed to get on one's feet and continue moving toward God, not to increase wealth like the rich man who hoarded his harvest and said, "My soul, rejoice for many days, eat, drink, and be merry." Father Alexey concludes with the line "There is a season turn turn turn and a time to every purpose under heaven."

Key moments

  1. 0:00 The questioner asks whether it is permissible to ask God for material goods, noting that some priests say it is fine but wondering why we should ask if God already knows our needs.
  2. 0:31 The host refers to a program titled "Why doesn't God hear our prayers?" that discusses the Gospel words "Ask and you will receive" and "Whatever you ask the Father in My name, He will give you."
  3. 1:01 Father Alexey affirms that we can ask God for material help, pointing to the Lord's Prayer petition "Give us this day our daily bread" as evidence that we ask for help in earthly life.
  4. 1:32 He warns that earthly life and God's help in it should not take first place, because the promise "whatever you ask in My name" must be read in the context of the Sermon on the Mount: "Seek first the Kingdom of God and His righteousness, and all these things will be added to you."
  5. 2:03 If a person asks for God's things, spiritual goods such as salvation, wisdom, understanding, and God's will, that prayer will certainly be heard and joy will be complete.
  6. 2:34 Once that primary prayer is heard, it is normal to also ask for earthly help; those in need of a home can ask for a home, and those seeking work can ask the Lord to help them find a good job.
  7. 3:06 Requests for material things should be for what is truly needed to get on one's feet and continue moving toward God, not to increase wealth like the rich man who hoarded his harvest and said, "My soul, rejoice for many days, eat, drink, and be merry."
  8. 3:39 Father Alexey concludes with the line "There is a season turn turn turn and a time to every purpose under heaven."
3 opinions in the discussion I've seen it more than once: help arrives at exactly the right moment even without asking, and it's so unlikely that it doesn't fit even into a millionth of a probability. All I really ask… Read the discussion

Christ's compassion at Nain reveals God-man action in us

Christ's compassion at Nain reveals God-man action in us 5:23

The sermon by Fr. Alexey Uminsky examines the Gospel account of Christ raising the widow's son at Nain. The reading describes the first resurrection miracle where Christ encounters a funeral procession for a widow's only son and approaches the bier to raise him. The text notes that Jesus had compassion on the widow. This detail shows Christ's human heart at work, revealing that miracles are God-man actions where human nature acts together with…

The sermon by Fr. Alexey Uminsky examines the Gospel account of Christ raising the widow's son at Nain. The reading describes the first resurrection miracle where Christ encounters a funeral procession for a widow's only son and approaches the bier to raise him. The text notes that Jesus had compassion on the widow. This detail shows Christ's human heart at work, revealing that miracles are God-man actions where human nature acts together with the divine rather than stepping aside.

The young man is the only son of a widow, just as Christ is the only son of the widowed Theotokos. The miracle may occur before her eyes as he tells the grieving mother not to weep. The widow loses not only her son but her entire future support, since the law required children to provide for aging parents, leaving her with no one to look after her.

Christ's care for his mother is fulfilled on the cross when he entrusts her to John, obeying the law that commands children to care for widowed parents. From the cross Christ gives his mother the care of John and of every believer, making the Gospel passage a revelation of God-man compassion and God-man care. The Apostolic reading declares that it is no longer I who live but Christ lives in me, which is itself a God-man action and the pattern for Christian life.

Because the God-man has conquered death, this life is given to each person in whom Christ dwells. The Lord calls believers to act in a God-man way with his strength, love, authority, gospel word, and healing. The conquest of death by the God-man is shared with all in whom Christ lives.

Key moments

  1. 0:00 The Gospel reading describes the first resurrection miracle where Christ encounters a funeral procession for a widow's only son and approaches the bier to raise him.
  2. 0:31 The detail "He had compassion on her" shows Christ's human heart at work, revealing that miracles are God-man actions where human nature acts together with the divine rather than stepping aside.
  3. 2:02 The young man is the only son of a widow, just as Christ is the only son of the widowed Theotokos, and the miracle may occur before her eyes as He tells the grieving mother "Do not weep."
  4. 2:32 Christ's care for His mother is fulfilled on the cross when He entrusts her to John, obeying the law that commands children to care for widowed parents.
  5. 3:06 The widow loses not only her son but her entire future support, since the law required children to provide for aging parents, leaving her with no one to look after her.
  6. 3:37 From the cross Christ gives His mother the care of John and of every believer, making the Gospel passage a revelation of God-man compassion and God-man care.
  7. 4:08 The Apostolic reading states "It is no longer I who live, but Christ lives in me," which is itself a God-man action and the pattern for Christian life.
  8. 4:38 The Lord calls believers to act in a God-man way with His strength, love, authority, gospel word, and healing, because the God-man's conquest of death is given to all in whom Christ lives.
Read more

Father Alexey Uminsky on crisis of faith as encounter with God

Father Alexey Uminsky on crisis of faith as encounter with God 1:21:28

Father Alexey Uminsky describes crisis of faith as the collapse of rational certainties and external religious forms. He explains that a person discovers clergy can err, church history contains injustices, and emotional comfort in worship fades. The priest distinguishes between crisis as destructive judgment and crisis as divine light revealing truth. He argues that true faith begins not with rules or feelings but with a personal encounter with…

Father Alexey Uminsky describes crisis of faith as the collapse of rational certainties and external religious forms. He explains that a person discovers clergy can err, church history contains injustices, and emotional comfort in worship fades. The priest distinguishes between crisis as destructive judgment and crisis as divine light revealing truth.

He argues that true faith begins not with rules or feelings but with a personal encounter with God, as in Job's experience where God's presence, not explanations, became the answer. Father Alexey criticizes the church for imposing heavy burdens, confusing patriotism with the Gospel, and covering up abuse. He says faithfulness to Christ may require leaving familiar structures.

He emphasizes that spiritual fatherhood is not obligatory for laypeople, that freedom means trust not submission, and that suffering is not identical to the cross. Psychological healing and wise spiritual accompaniment are needed together, but many priests are now silenced from public ministry. The discussion also covers how converts encounter an overwhelming system of external rules, incomprehensible language, and aesthetic beauty that leaves no energy to seek God.

The Greek word 'crisis' means judgment: light entering a dark room reveals both good and evil, and the person either flees feeling deceived or goes deeper. Prayer is described not as sending an SMS to God but as desiring to know and speak with a Person; the liturgy originated from Christians gathering to pray and commune, not from ritual performance.

Father Alexey describes his former state of certainty where faith seemed rational and the path clear, with priests as reliable answer-givers. Crisis arrives when habitual answers lose meaning, the person doubts God and faith, and stands before a wall not knowing where to go. The crisis deepens when one realizes saints, priests, and bishops can err, and that hagiographies contain untruths.

Today's crisis for many thoughtful Christians stems from the church blessing weapons, declaring killing in war not a sin, and replacing the Gospel with patriotism. The way through crisis begins with the question 'Did you meet God?', Job's friends offered rational explanations, but Job insisted on speaking to God directly, and God's presence, not answers, became the resolution.

Key moments

  1. 4:10 Father Alexey describes his former state of certainty where faith seemed rational and the path clear, with priests as reliable answer-givers.
  2. 5:13 Crisis of faith arrives when habitual answers lose meaning, the person doubts God and faith, and stands before a wall not knowing where to go.
  3. 7:16 The crisis deepens when one realizes saints, priests, and bishops can err, and that hagiographies contain untruths.
  4. 11:27 A convert comes to church to learn faith but encounters an overwhelming system of external rules, incomprehensible language, and aesthetic beauty that leaves no energy to seek God Himself.
  5. 14:29 The Greek word 'crisis' means judgment: light entering a dark room reveals both good and evil, and the person either flees feeling deceived or goes deeper.
  6. 23:54 Today's crisis for many thoughtful Christians stems from the church blessing weapons, declaring killing in war not a sin, and replacing the Gospel with patriotism.
  7. 39:36 The way through crisis begins with the question 'Did you meet God?', Job's friends offered rational explanations, but Job insisted on speaking to God directly, and God's presence, not answers, became the resolution.
  8. 46:50 Prayer is not sending an SMS to God but desiring to know and speak with a Person; the liturgy originated from Christians gathering to pray and commune, not from ritual performance.
9 opinions in the discussion The crisis of faith is a very important topic. I came to faith in the late 80s. I joyfully took on all the traditional rules: fasting, morning and evening prayers, weekly services. I… Read the discussion

Priest's harsh confession demands called violence against the person

Priest's harsh confession demands called violence against the person 12:45

A layperson describes a confession where the rector, serving alone and visibly irritated, angrily refused a request to shorten the confession because of a long line. The priest demanded a detailed list of sins and criticized the layperson for missing the Saturday all-night vigil. The layperson explains that both they and their wife are full-time students undergoing expensive psychotherapy for serious mental health conditions, making Saturday…

A layperson describes a confession where the rector, serving alone and visibly irritated, angrily refused a request to shorten the confession because of a long line. The priest demanded a detailed list of sins and criticized the layperson for missing the Saturday all-night vigil. The layperson explains that both they and their wife are full-time students undergoing expensive psychotherapy for serious mental health conditions, making Saturday evening their only time to rest. The encounter left the wife in tears and both shaken before communion.

The responding priest calls the incident real violence against the human person. He argues that Christ invites the sick to communion, not the sinless, and that priests who impose formal barriers, mandatory canons, and vigil attendance act like border guards rather than physicians. He states that the only sin barring communion is unrepented enmity, citing the pre-communion prayer and Christ's command to reconcile before offering one's gift.

He contrasts this with the practice for clergy: priests in the Moscow diocese are required to confess only twice yearly, and their confession is never tied to each Eucharist they serve, unlike the heavy burdens they lay on the laity.

Key moments

  1. 0:00 The layperson recounts being forced into infrequent communion in 2020-21 due to excessive preparation requirements, later finding priests who explained the rules were not mandatory.
  2. 1:04 At today's liturgy, only the rector was present to serve and hear confessions simultaneously; he appeared irritable and angrily rejected the layperson's offer to skip a detailed sin list to save time.
  3. 1:34 The priest insisted on a formal confession, leading the layperson to list made-up sins, and criticized their absence from the Saturday all-night vigil.
  4. 2:05 The layperson explains they and their wife are in psychotherapy for a mental disorder and a personality disorder, are full-time students working to afford therapy costing far more than 500 rubles per session, and need Saturday evening to rest.
  5. 3:07 The wife left the church in tears, already in a spiritual crisis unable to accept God's love; both eventually communed but found the sermon on God's love and joy unbearable after the encounter.
  6. 4:43 The responding priest calls the incident real violence against the human person, emphasizing that the faithful come to God at communion, not to a priest acting as a controller.
  7. 5:45 The priest argues that treating confession as a checkpoint requiring sinlessness before communion contradicts Christ's words that the sick need a physician, and cites 1 John on sins leading to death versus the daily Christian state.
  8. 11:29 The priest notes that priests in the Moscow diocese are required to confess only twice yearly, their confession never tied to each Eucharist they serve, unlike the heavy burdens they lay on the laity.
11 opinions in the discussion So, Father Alexey! I don't have these problems anymore. I've been going to the same church for a long time. Our wise rector allowed me not to confess before communion if I haven't fallen… Read the discussion

Taking Up the Cross as a Joyful Response to Love

Taking Up the Cross as a Joyful Response to Love 7:57

Fr. Alexey Uminsky's homily for the Exaltation of the Cross reinterprets Christ's call to deny oneself and take up the cross not as a heavy obligation but as a voluntary invitation born of love. The priest explains that the Gospel words — "deny yourself, take up your cross, and follow Me" — are often perceived as the most severe and frightening in Scripture because they seem contrary to human nature. However, Fr. Alexey argues that true…

Fr. Alexey Uminsky's homily for the Exaltation of the Cross reinterprets Christ's call to deny oneself and take up the cross not as a heavy obligation but as a voluntary invitation born of love. The priest explains that the Gospel words — "deny yourself, take up your cross, and follow Me" — are often perceived as the most severe and frightening in Scripture because they seem contrary to human nature.

However, Fr. Alexey argues that true self-denial happens naturally and joyfully when one loves deeply: the lover forgets themselves, making the beloved the center of life. This divine self-denial brings happiness, light, and freedom, not cruelty or heaviness. The "cross" Christians are called to bear is not worldly suffering, illness, or misfortune; rather, it is the Gospel itself — the good news of Christ's sacrificial love and resurrection.

As the Church sings, "Through the Cross joy has come to all the world." Therefore, taking up the cross means embracing a life according to the Gospel, imitating Christ in selfless love. This burden is light and liberating because it is chosen freely in response to love, not imposed by force.

God does not send crosses; a person voluntarily takes them up. The homily concludes that following Christ means denying only oneself, not Christ, and that such a life is marked by the joy of the resurrection.

Key moments

  1. 0:00 The feast of the Exaltation of the Cross concludes; the Gospel reading (Mark) states that to follow Christ one must deny oneself, take up the cross, and follow Him.
  2. 0:31 These words are described as the most troubling and severe in the Gospel, similar to the command to love Christ more than family, because they seem alien to human nature.
  3. 1:35 The concepts of self-denial and the cross are hardest to accept; the cross is usually perceived negatively as something heavy, gloomy, and frightening.
  4. 2:38 Christ's appeal is a calling, not a command; no one is forced or handed a cross—God does not send crosses, a person voluntarily takes it up.
  5. 3:10 Self-denial is explained through the experience of deep love: when one truly loves, they forget themselves joyfully, making the beloved the center of life.
  6. 4:13 Selflessness is identified as happiness and the lightness of love; divine self-denial brings joy, light, and freedom, not cruelty or heaviness.
  7. 5:17 The cross offered by Christ is not life's misfortunes or illnesses; the Church sings 'Through the Cross joy has come to all the world,' identifying the Cross with the Gospel of resurrection and eternal life.
  8. 6:21 Taking up the cross means taking up the Gospel and a life according to it (imitation of Christ); one cannot deny Christ but only oneself, and this burden is light and joyful.
Read more

Divine Punishment as Loving Admonition, Not Retribution

Divine Punishment as Loving Admonition, Not Retribution 2:19

In a recent broadcast, Archpriest Alexei Uminsky addresses a viewer's question about whether God ever punishes, clarifying a common misunderstanding. The viewer inferred that if God never punishes, He must forgive everyone automatically, rendering confession unnecessary. Father Alexey corrects this premise: he never claimed God never punishes. Rather, he distinguishes between suffering, disease, and death — which are not divine retribution for…

In a recent broadcast, Archpriest Alexei Uminsky addresses a viewer's question about whether God ever punishes, clarifying a common misunderstanding. The viewer inferred that if God never punishes, He must forgive everyone automatically, rendering confession unnecessary. Father Alexey corrects this premise: he never claimed God never punishes.

Rather, he distinguishes between suffering, disease, and death — which are not divine retribution for sins — and true divine punishment, which exists as a form of loving admonition. This punishment is not torture or revenge but God's pedagogical action through life circumstances, encounters, and the inner realization of one's mistakes, often leading to repentance.

Forgiveness, Father Alexey emphasizes, is not automatic; it requires active seeking, genuine desire, striving, and acceptance through sincere remorse and repentance. This dynamic is precisely why the sacrament of confession exists: it provides the structured means to seek, express, and receive that forgiveness. The discussion thus centers on the nature of God's justice as restorative rather than punitive, and the indispensable role of human cooperation in the process of reconciliation.

Key moments

  1. 0:00 A viewer asks: if God never punishes anyone, it follows He forgives everyone, so why is confession necessary?
  2. 0:34 Father Alexey corrects the premise: he never said God never punishes; diseases, suffering, and death are not punishments for sins, but divine punishment does exist as admonition and lesson.
  3. 1:04 Divine punishment is not torture or revenge; it is God admonishing a person through life encounters, collisions, and the realization of mistakes, including through repentance.
  4. 1:37 Forgiveness is not automatic; one must seek, desire, strive for, and accept it from God through sincere remorse and repentance.
  5. 1:37 That is exactly why confession exists.
Read more

Fr. Alexey Uminsky: Faith Beyond Rules and Rituals

Fr. Alexey Uminsky: Faith Beyond Rules and Rituals 1:03:13

In this conversation, Fr. Alexey Uminsky responds to a letter from a lifelong Orthodox Christian who, challenged by non-Christian friends, finds herself unable to articulate the meaning of the Trinity, Christ's divinity, or the Eucharist. Her crisis reveals a widespread problem: many 'churched' people have reduced faith to moral compliance and ritual observance — worrying about cross-shaped drains or lists of permissions and prohibitions — while…

In this conversation, Fr. Alexey Uminsky responds to a letter from a lifelong Orthodox Christian who, challenged by non-Christian friends, finds herself unable to articulate the meaning of the Trinity, Christ's divinity, or the Eucharist. Her crisis reveals a widespread problem: many 'churched' people have reduced faith to moral compliance and ritual observance — worrying about cross-shaped drains or lists of permissions and prohibitions — while missing the living God.

Fr. Alexey argues that such religion mistakes tradition for faith and behavioral conformity for a relationship with the invisible, incomprehensible God who is infinitely greater than human categories.

The core of Christianity, he insists, is not a moral code but the revelation that God is eternal, self-giving love (1 John 4:8). This love explains the Holy Trinity not as a mathematical puzzle but as a communion of Persons: the Father eternally begets the Son, the Spirit eternally proceeds, three hypostases consubstantial and united in one will.

The Incarnation is God's union with humanity; the Son takes on sin and death, destroys hell by divine love, rises as the God-man, and grants deification through Baptism and the Eucharist. The talk concludes with a testimony of a child's direct encounter with the living God as love, illustrating that true faith begins not with rules but with a personal meeting with the One who is Love itself.

Key moments

  1. 0:00 Opening critique: reducing faith to lists of what is allowed or forbidden (e.g., a cross-shaped drain) empties Christianity of its content; the true God is invisible, incomprehensible, and infinitely greater than human categories.
  2. 1:03 Introduction of the letter from Yulia, a cradle Orthodox Christian whose conversations with friends of other faiths exposed her inability to explain the Trinity, Christ's unique divinity, or the meaning of Communion, leading her to avoid prayers to Jesus and the Theotokos.
  3. 8:23 Diagnosis: many 'churched' people mistake religious tradition and behavioral conformity for faith; they have not entered into a personal relationship with the living God who is invisible, intangible, and infinitely greater than human consciousness.
  4. 10:27 Two inadequate concepts of God: (1) a generic higher intelligence, and (2) a moralistic lawgiver of 'allowed/forbidden' common to all religions; Christian faith transcends both by revealing God as self-giving love.
  5. 13:07 Critique of popular clergy media that answer casuistic questions (bathtub drains, euthanasia, interfaith communion) as if they were the heart of faith; if the Son of God became man for such trivialities, 'it is a very strange faith indeed.'
  6. 16:47 The core of Christian faith: 'God is love' (1 John 4:8). This love is eternal, unconditional, and the source of all dogma; the Trinity is not a mathematical puzzle but the fullness of divine love—Father, Son, and Holy Spirit as three personal expressions of one divine essence.
  7. 18:20 Patristic explanation of the Trinity from love: the Father is eternally Father only if He eternally begets the Son; the Spirit eternally proceeds. The three hypostases are consubstantial, equal in glory, and united in one will—unity in threeness, not tritheism.
  8. 42:57 Salvation through the Incarnation: the Son of God becomes man to unite humanity with God, takes on sin and death, destroys hell by divine love, rises as the God-man, and grants deification (theosis) through Baptism (death/resurrection with Christ) and the Eucharist (union with His Body and Blood).
8 opinions in the discussion Dear Father Alexei. I'm about your age, a psychiatrist, and for years I've been surrounded by deprived, suffering people. I know well the helplessness and burnout that come with it. I… Read the discussion

The More You Sleep, the Less You Sin? A Sermon on Risking the Gifts of God

The More You Sleep, the Less You Sin? A Sermon on Risking the Gifts of God 12:04

This post presents a sermon by Protopriest Alexiy Uminsky for the 16th Sunday after Pentecost, the Sunday before the Exaltation of the Holy Cross. The sermon reflects on two Gospel readings that at first seem contradictory: John 3, where Christ says He came not to judge the world but to save it, and the Parable of the Talents from Matthew 25, which speaks of judgment. The preacher shows that the two readings illuminate one another. The talents,…

This post presents a sermon by Protopriest Alexiy Uminsky for the 16th Sunday after Pentecost, the Sunday before the Exaltation of the Holy Cross. The sermon reflects on two Gospel readings that at first seem contradictory: John 3, where Christ says He came not to judge the world but to save it, and the Parable of the Talents from Matthew 25, which speaks of judgment.

The preacher shows that the two readings illuminate one another. The talents, he explains, are not modern 'abilities' but a vast sum of money entrusted to servants at great risk; likewise, the Lord entrusts each Christian with far greater wealth—Christ Himself, grace, faith, and love—which must be risked and multiplied through living, active faith.

He cites St. Athanasius the Great ('God became man so that man might become god') to describe the Christian calling to ascend with Christ. The sermon contrasts this with the third servant, who buried his talent out of fear: he represents the merely 'religious' person who seeks safety in rules, correct candle-lighting, fasting, and rote prayer rules, but never prays from the heart or risks anything for God.

Such a person, the preacher warns, judges himself and lives in self-imposed darkness, for God is not a cruel master but love and mercy, like the father who welcomed the prodigal son. The ironic saying in the title—'the more you sleep, the less you sin'—captures the spirit of this fearful, self-protective piety that the sermon calls Christians to overcome.

Key moments

  1. 0:00 On the Sunday before the Exaltation of the Cross, two Gospels are read: John 3, where Christ comes into the world to save it, not to judge it, including the words 'For God so loved the world...'
  2. 1:04 The Parable of the Talents from Matthew 25 is about judgment; the two seemingly contradictory readings actually explain each other.
  3. 2:09 The calling of every Christian is to ascend to heaven as Christ did, becoming a son of God just as the Son of God became a son of man—'God became man so that man might become god' (St. Athanasius the Great).
  4. 3:43 A talent is not modern 'ability' but a large sum of money; the master entrusts his servants with great wealth, which involves huge risk of loss.
  5. 5:21 If we fear risking money, how much more does the Lord entrust us with Himself: the gifts of the Holy Spirit and grace are Christ Himself, His word and life, which must multiply and bear fruit.
  6. 6:26 The Apostle writes that Christians are known by all though nobodies, killed yet alive, poor yet making many rich, having nothing yet possessing everything—do we resemble such Christians today?
  7. 7:30 The Lord distributes gifts to each according to their strength; faith, love, and prayer are not guarantees of comfort but great labor—seeking, doubt, trust, standing for truth—so take risks and be a living Christian.
  8. 8:33 The third servant represents the merely religious person who seeks safety in rules, correct candle-lighting, fasting, and rote prayer rules, never praying from the heart or risking anything—'the more you sleep, the less you sin'—and such a person judges himself, for God is love and mercy, like the father who welcomed the prodigal son.
13 opinions in the discussion God, this sermon turned out to be so unexpectedly saving for me right now — I was ready to drown in despair! I cannot stop our catastrophe, but I can stand firm in trust in Christ — that… Read the discussion

Fr. Alexey Uminsky Reads Taneda Santōka: Poetry of Ordinary Grace

Fr. Alexey Uminsky Reads Taneda Santōka: Poetry of Ordinary Grace 1:02

In this episode of "Reading Books with Fr. Alexey Uminsky," the priest introduces the Japanese poet-monk Taneda Santōka, who remains largely unknown to Russian-speaking audiences. Santōka's poetry is characterized by its simplicity, conversational tone, and tactile immediacy. Fr. Alexey reads a representative poem: "Drinking, drinking sake. Blossoms on the branches, buds on the trees. An ant wanders across my eyelash." He reflects on how these…

In this episode of "Reading Books with Fr. Alexey Uminsky," the priest introduces the Japanese poet-monk Taneda Santōka, who remains largely unknown to Russian-speaking audiences. Santōka's poetry is characterized by its simplicity, conversational tone, and tactile immediacy. Fr. Alexey reads a representative poem: "Drinking, drinking sake.

Blossoms on the branches, buds on the trees. An ant wanders across my eyelash." He reflects on how these seemingly mundane lines — depicting everyday moments like drinking, observing nature, or noticing a tiny insect — open a space of profound joy and peace. The discussion emphasizes that Santōka's work teaches us to see beauty in the most ordinary circumstances and to accept life as it is.

The poems function as a kind of essential spiritual tranquilizer, providing hope, joy, and the quiet assurance that the world rests in God's hands. The post invites viewers to engage with this poetic vision through the ongoing series, which is supported via various subscription platforms.

Key moments

  1. 0:00 Introduces reading Taneda Santōka and quotes a poem: 'Drinking, drinking sake. Blossoms on the branches, buds on the trees. An ant wanders across my eyelash.' Notes the words seem almost meaningless.
  2. 0:30 Describes the poems as ordinary lines that can be opened anywhere and read with amazing joy, acting as the most essential tranquilizer, giving hope, joy, and assurance that the world is in God's hands.
Read more