WeOrthodox
EN UA

Why Icons Are Not Idolatry: Kissing and Bowing as Respect

The speaker argues that Orthodox Christians face accusations of idolatry for using icons, while kissing and bowing before them are expressions of love and respect, not worship. He cites Saint Paul's instruction to greet one another with a holy kiss and the example of King Solomon bowing before his mother as biblical precedents for such gestures.

The speaker questions why religious images are labeled idolatry only when Orthodox Christians have them, implying a double standard in the criticism.

Key moments

  1. 0:04 The speaker asks why Orthodox Christians are accused of idolatry for having icons when kissing and bowing are expressions of love and respect, citing Saint Paul's command to greet with a holy kiss and King Solomon bowing before his mother.
14 opinions in the discussion 11 participants, 9 replies to each other The opinion with the most support To venerate means to treat someone or something with deep respect, reverence, or intense admiration. Do you "worship" your country's flag or venerate it? Medal of Honor recipients? What about that favorite athlete whose jersey you wear, whose cards you… Read the discussion
150 comments at the source Original on Instagram

Discussion · 14

Opinions are anonymous retellings of real comments from the original discussion. The same colour marks the same participant.

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

  • opinion#3853

    To venerate means to treat someone or something with deep respect, reverence, or intense admiration. Do you "worship" your country's flag or venerate it? Medal of Honor recipients? What about that favorite athlete whose jersey you wear, whose cards you collect, and whom you go out of your way to see? You walk down your hallway, see pictures of your mother, father or grandparents, stop and pray for them or maybe kiss their picture in loving remembrance. Worship? Or veneration? The martyrs are the same. Rome became Christian not by the sword but by sacrifice and martyrdom, and remembering those who went before is not worship. We look to them as examples. Throw in presidents' days etc. Got a picture of George Washington or Abraham Lincoln in a classroom? Better smash it, you might venerate it. Remember their life, sacrifice and what they did for others. Or keep being hateful and divisive.

    • opinion#3856

      Incoming "I don't kiss pictures of the president" replies

    • opinion#3857

      The funny thing is I bet they do 😂

  • opinion#3855

    Simple. One isn't worshiped, the other is.

    • opinion#3858

      But you know how Catholics are. Instead of addressing the actual point, they turn it into some philosophical conundrum and bring up things that have nothing to do with the argument. The second commandment is pretty straightforward: God tells us not to make graven images or bow down to them. Then they bring up the cherubim on the Ark as if that somehow disproves the commandment. But God specifically commanded those to be made; they weren't objects of worship. It's really not that complicated.

    • opinion#3859

      Acknowledging the worth of an artwork as something meaningful rather than simply existing is not the same as worshipping an idol. Otherwise all art is inherently sinful, which would make God the greatest sinner of them all since he's literally the first artist. And on top of that, He commands the creation of icons. Icons r not idols, period

    • opinion#3860

      It is worship. You know how many times I've seen Catholics bow down to these images, pray to them, and think there's nothing wrong with it? Prayer is an act of worship, and I've even seen people kiss the actual images. Secondly, you're assuming these images represent what God or holy figures look like. That's where you get the pictures of Jesus, Mary, and the saints. You're creating physical representations of things Scripture never tells us to represent through images. That's idolatry.

    • opinion#3861

      You know what's interesting? I actually think the opposite. If every religious image, painting, and sculpture disappeared tomorrow, we'd still believe in God. Our faith doesn't depend on having pictures of Jesus, Mary, or the saints hanging on a wall. We have Scripture, and that's where our faith is rooted. Just look at David and the Psalms. Scripture is full of examples of how much God loves to be worshipped through prayer, praise, and song. The issue isn't worshipping God; it's turning that worship into something image-based when God has explicitly warned against it. God wants our worship, but He doesn't need us to create images of Him.

  • opinion#3851

    Young man, 1. who cares what non Orthodox say? 2. Please never again compare an icon to a decorative statue. You have a lot to learn. Did your priest bless you to post online? If not, stop.

    • opinion#3862

      I'm a 60 year old Orthodox Christian who happened to stumble on this reel. This whole phenomena of young people posting about and misrepresenting Orthodoxy when they have very little knowledge, as evidenced by this post, is spiritually dangerous for the person posting. Since you're a catechumen, I hope you've been taught that icons are holy, not just pictures.

    • opinion#3863

      He's not literally comparing them. It's the same argument used by St. John Damascus on The Holy Images. The argument isn't that they are ontologically the same but rather an internal critique against iconoclasts.

  • opinion#3852

    I'm not orthodox, and I see both sides. On one hand, images are used to venerate the saints who are no longer on this side of reality and as a form of respect; but on the other hand, icons and decorations aren't made equally or treated equally, so asking "why is that okay and icons aren't?" is unreasonable. It's a completely different thing.

  • opinion#3854

    Will agree. But I'll also say this. There's a fine line between worship and idolatry. Some worship the cross while others worship the king who died on it without even knowing.

    • opinion#3864

      While I agree it can become a fine line for some, I think a good majority understand it just fine. If someone is worshipping the cross that means they think the actual cross jesus was crucified on is a god lmao nobody thinks that. Representation is a thing.