Speaker contrasts Nostra Aetate with canons forbidding prayer with heretics
The speaker, an Orthodox Christian, argues that the Roman Catholic Church contradicts itself. He notes that Nostra Aetate declares Muslims adore the one God, only years after the same church claimed to expel anyone who departs from its magisterium. He adds that Catholicism now recognizes Orthodox sacraments, apostolic succession and a valid priesthood, yet forbids Orthodox faithful from receiving Eucharist, confessing to Catholic priests or praying with the heterodox.
Against this he sets the canons: any clergyman or layman who enters a synagogue of Jews or heretics to pray is to be deposed and excommunicated, no one may join in prayer with heretics or schismatics, and one must not accept blessings from heretics. He cites Saint Photios the Great, who calls the Filioque a Filioque of godlessness, and Saint Gregory Palamas, who calls it polytheist and demonic, and mentions Saint Paisios, who would not pray with heretics and named the Latin Church as heretical.
The speaker rejects the claim that Muslims and Orthodox worship the same God, arguing that a different ecclesiology amounts to a Nestorian declaration. He also quotes a dialogue in which a saint tells a Muslim that since Christ is the judge of the human race, prayers must be addressed to him as God, which displeased the Muslim, and warns against reading that passage as an affirmation of Islam.
The original post itself is combative, accusing Catholics of pride and urging readers to put the truth first, with 'Ecumenism is death. Lord have mercy.'
Key moments
- 0:00 Nostra Aetate states that Muslims adore the one God, and the speaker calls this dogmatic, contrasting it with the same church's earlier claim that those who depart from its magisterium are rebels expelled from her children.
- 0:34 The Catholic Church now says the Orthodox possess true sacraments, apostolic succession, and a valid priesthood, yet an Orthodox Christian cannot receive Eucharist, confess to a Catholic priest, or pray with the heterodox.
- 1:07 The canons state that any clergyman or layman who enters a synagogue of Jews or heretics to pray is to be deposed and excommunicated, that no one shall join in prayer with heretics or schismatics, and that one must not accept blessings from heretics.
- 1:22 Heresy is demonic: Saint Photios the Great calls the Filioque of godlessness, and Saint Gregory Palamas calls it polytheist and demonic.
- 1:41 Modern saints such as Saint Paisios also held heresy to be demonic and would not pray with heretics, noting the Latin Church as heretical and departed from the body of Christ.
- 1:55 The speaker argues that calling Muslim Trinitarian theology different while claiming Nicene Trinitarianism makes no sense, since the church is the body of Christ and a different ecclesiology is a Nestorian declaration.
- 2:11 He quotes a dialogue in which the saint tells a Muslim that since Christ is the judge of all the human race, prayers must be addressed to him as God, inseparable from the Father as his natural Word, and the Muslim was displeased by this.
- 2:42 He warns that anyone who reads this passage as affirming the Muslim is lying and misrepresenting the book, and tells them to read it, since it is short.