WeOrthodox
EN UA

Speaker contrasts Nostra Aetate with canons forbidding prayer with heretics

The speaker, an Orthodox Christian, argues that the Roman Catholic Church contradicts itself. He notes that Nostra Aetate declares Muslims adore the one God, only years after the same church claimed to expel anyone who departs from its magisterium. He adds that Catholicism now recognizes Orthodox sacraments, apostolic succession and a valid priesthood, yet forbids Orthodox faithful from receiving Eucharist, confessing to Catholic priests or praying with the heterodox.

Against this he sets the canons: any clergyman or layman who enters a synagogue of Jews or heretics to pray is to be deposed and excommunicated, no one may join in prayer with heretics or schismatics, and one must not accept blessings from heretics. He cites Saint Photios the Great, who calls the Filioque a Filioque of godlessness, and Saint Gregory Palamas, who calls it polytheist and demonic, and mentions Saint Paisios, who would not pray with heretics and named the Latin Church as heretical.

The speaker rejects the claim that Muslims and Orthodox worship the same God, arguing that a different ecclesiology amounts to a Nestorian declaration. He also quotes a dialogue in which a saint tells a Muslim that since Christ is the judge of the human race, prayers must be addressed to him as God, which displeased the Muslim, and warns against reading that passage as an affirmation of Islam.

The original post itself is combative, accusing Catholics of pride and urging readers to put the truth first, with 'Ecumenism is death. Lord have mercy.'

Key moments

  1. 0:00 Nostra Aetate states that Muslims adore the one God, and the speaker calls this dogmatic, contrasting it with the same church's earlier claim that those who depart from its magisterium are rebels expelled from her children.
  2. 0:34 The Catholic Church now says the Orthodox possess true sacraments, apostolic succession, and a valid priesthood, yet an Orthodox Christian cannot receive Eucharist, confess to a Catholic priest, or pray with the heterodox.
  3. 1:07 The canons state that any clergyman or layman who enters a synagogue of Jews or heretics to pray is to be deposed and excommunicated, that no one shall join in prayer with heretics or schismatics, and that one must not accept blessings from heretics.
  4. 1:22 Heresy is demonic: Saint Photios the Great calls the Filioque of godlessness, and Saint Gregory Palamas calls it polytheist and demonic.
  5. 1:41 Modern saints such as Saint Paisios also held heresy to be demonic and would not pray with heretics, noting the Latin Church as heretical and departed from the body of Christ.
  6. 1:55 The speaker argues that calling Muslim Trinitarian theology different while claiming Nicene Trinitarianism makes no sense, since the church is the body of Christ and a different ecclesiology is a Nestorian declaration.
  7. 2:11 He quotes a dialogue in which the saint tells a Muslim that since Christ is the judge of all the human race, prayers must be addressed to him as God, inseparable from the Father as his natural Word, and the Muslim was displeased by this.
  8. 2:42 He warns that anyone who reads this passage as affirming the Muslim is lying and misrepresenting the book, and tells them to read it, since it is short.
33 opinions in the discussion 27 participants, 14 replies to each other The opinion with the most support Why am I not surprised you'd drop a hate-filled video on the Lord's day? God bless you brother! We love you and we pray for your repentance. Read the discussion
409 comments at the source Original on Instagram

Discussion · 33

Opinions are anonymous retellings of real comments from the original discussion. The same colour marks the same participant.

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

  • opinion#3703

    Why am I not surprised you'd drop a hate-filled video on the Lord's day? God bless you brother! We love you and we pray for your repentance.

    • opinion#3706

      Where was the lie? You made a video saying Protestants are invoking demons, I showed your church doesn't teach that and explained how Palamas called Muslim prayer rituals good. You clearly haven't read Norman Russell's book on this, and your take on St. Gregory Palamas is pure cope. He reorients their understanding to show them the God they already pray to is actually Jesus Christ, since they already believe he'll return to judge mankind. I genuinely pray for you brother. Anyone who's actually read Palamas knows this. You haven't read his writings. God bless!

  • opinion#3705

    Nice strawman buddy, but you might need some reading comprehension. It says they PROFESS to worship the God of Abraham, key word profess. And it's not dogmatic

    • opinion#3707

      Key words: "WHO ALONG WITH US"

    • opinion#3708

      Roman Catholic ecumenical councils are dogmatic, all this cope is pure sophistry.

    • opinion#3709

      An ecumenical council has the authority to define dogma, but not everything an ecumenical council says automatically becomes a defined dogma.

    • opinion#3710

      Again, read further. It says they PROCLAIM to hold the faith of Abraham, not that they actually do. The point of that document was that religion as a whole points to a creator, and Muslims believe more truths about our faith than some protestants do, like about mary and jesus. That doesn't mean they don't get vital things wrong, it just highlights that they also believe in one God

    • opinion#3711

      They don't care 😂, you're dealing with Orthobros

    • opinion#3712

      Resorts to namecalling. Very Catholic of you

    • opinion#3713

      Dime store sophistry to cover for bad stuff coming out of Rome.

    • opinion#3714

      Oh and Orthodox brothers are all super charitable I'm sure...

    • opinion#3715

      You still have to believe everything in a council, Vatican 1 declares it so. Maybe you're the uninformed one here.

  • opinion#3699

    @thelordsgiant in case yesterdays video mislead you from the lies of roots.

    • opinion#3716

      Are you aware that this person openly praises the Romanian Legionary Movement, a fascist and antisemitic organization responsible for political assassinations and mass murder? He also mocks Hispanic Catholics with deportation rhetoric. How is any of this compatible with Orthodox Christianity?

  • opinion#3700

    Not to mention how they are the definition of "Christian zionists". "Finally, those who have not yet received the Gospel are related in various ways to the people of God. In the first place we must recall the people to whom the testament and the promises were given and from whom Christ was born according to the flesh. On account of their fathers this people remains most dear to God, for God does not repent of the gifts He makes nor of the calls He issues." Lumen Gentium paragraph 16, on the "chosen people".

    • opinion#3717

      Wow, what a total larper 😂. Nice job quote mining Lumen Gentium 16 by the way. Quoting Scripture and Vatican II texts that acknowledge the historical roots of the Jewish people and God's faithfulness to the covenant, which literally echoes Saint Paul in Romans 11, isn't zionism, it's just basic orthodox Christianity. We call out zionism and Israel plenty ourselves, maybe actually read the documents in context sometime.

    • opinion#3718

      Please bro, please, just submit to Rome and learn some reading comprehension. That's not a quote mine, it's the exact text within its context.

    • opinion#3719

      Kek, notice how you completely dodged Romans 11:28-29 ("beloved for the sake of their forefathers, for the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable"). Lumen Gentium 16 is literally just quoting St. Paul. Calling Scripture Zionism while hiding behind tired memes just proves you don't actually know the theology you're trying to attack, big dog.

  • opinion#3694

    As someone who left Roman Catholicism for Holy Orthodoxy (which is truly catholic) and was raised Muslim - I was very alarmed by this when I was Roman Catholic. It's just not true that they worship the same God. I lived it. I lived in Pakistan as a teen, so I've lived in a Muslim country. We do not worship the same God as Muslims. 🙅🏽‍♀️ Thank you for posting about this!

  • opinion#3695

    Everyone should read nostra aetate itself. It's not really that crazy. Muslims and Jews worship the same abrahamic God as Christians. It may be an initially misleading statement but it's still technically true. Just because Muslims and Jews attribute specific properties to God that aren't true doesn't mean the source material (Torah) isn't the source material as the God of Christianity. For example, if we both knew a hypothetical friend from college, the book author named John, and you said "John is married." And I said "no John is still a college bachelor." We are still talking about the same John, but one of us is obviously wrong about the nature of John. There's also a point where you or I could describe John so drastically that it makes us feel like the other doesn't know who John is or attributed another person's actions to the John we both know from college. But regardless if we both agree we're talking about John the book author and friend from college, we'd still be talking about the same John. Nostra Aetate is just trying to highlight the small bit of truth in the other abrahamic religions that Christians can appeal to when evangelizing. Quote from NA: "Indeed, she (the church) proclaims, and ever must proclaim Christ, 'the way the truth, and the life' (John 14, 6), in whom men may find the fullness of religious life, in whom God has reconciled all things to Himself."

  • opinion#3691

    You shouldn't be posting mis-interpreted information like this. The number of times Catholics have had to bite their tongues dealing with this kind of arrogance and pride from the Orthodox and Protestant Churches is disappointing; all these schismatic groups don't prioritize Christian unity whatsoever, obvious from the fact that they don't even have any semblance of unity among themselves. It's always these Orthobros who emerge broken out of some Protestant sect and then join some Orthodox Church with guns ablaze against Catholicism. How about redirecting that zeal toward praying for unity as Jesus wanted? I know this is harsh of me to say, but it's important to self-reflect before posting something so inflammatory and potentially incorrect. Even your Orthodox Bishop/Priest would swiftly correct you here.

  • opinion#3701

    "But the plan of salvation also includes those who acknowledge the Creator. In the first place amongst these there are the Muslims, who, professing to hold the faith of Abraham, ALONG WITH US adore the one and merciful God, who on the last day will judge mankind." -lumen gentium paragraph 16. They try to use sophistry and say "nuh uh, they pRoFeSs their faith". It's like they don't even know what profess means. "ALONG WITH US" is inescapable, the kill shot to any way around the same god argument. Your church has literally bound you to the same god as the Muslims.

  • opinion#3698

    It just occurred to me that Jonathan using St. Gregory Palamas to make this point makes him even less serious. Palamas was a hesychast monk on Mount Athos who only wanted a life of intense prayer. He was pulled into public life because the Church needed him to defend the faith against Barlaam, and he did it uncompromisingly. When the Ottomans captured him, he debated Muslims face to face, defended the Trinity and the Incarnation, and refused to accept Muhammad as a prophet. The idea that this man would say Muslims and Christians worship the same God is so disingenuous that it's hard to take Jonathan seriously.

  • opinion#3696

    How is it a contradiction? All it's saying is that "You worship the same God, but you do it wrong." It's no different than their position on, for example, Protestantism. Protestants worship the same God as Catholics but because they have abandoned the liturgy and teachings of the Catholic Church, they are expelled.

  • opinion#3704

    You're too slow to get it. It says they believe in the God of Abraham but worship incorrectly. Read the documents properly instead of cherry picking. You're turning into the needgod.net of orthodoxy

  • opinion#3693

    do Ishmael and Isaac worship the same God? Basic yes or no on the referent.

  • opinion#3702

    So like, what if my whole family is protestant, if I become orthodox can I never pray with them again? What about Christmas and thanksgiving, we pray together every night. We even pray in the car together in the mornings. I honestly don't know how I'd work that out if I converted

  • opinion#3689

    You completely misunderstand what this means, nobody is saying Muslims can enter Heaven or that they're Christians, what it's saying is that HISTORICALLY they follow the Abrahamic God that they all agree spoke to Abraham 🤦‍♂️

  • opinion#3692

    Brother, I understand your concern but the Patriarch of Russia has said the same thing, here are 2 direct quotes you can search. "I know that there are both Christians and Muslims here. Each one appeals to the same God the Creator. And in response to this, we receive real help from God." "the one God, in Whom both Orthodox Christians and Muslims believe," and said that on the land where both live, "we all turn our prayers to one God, who saves the human race." Building churches or mosques shows that "faith lives in the heart." Both the Vatican's and the Patriarch's words are not dogmatic, so both Catholics and Orthodox can disagree with them. As members of the original apostolic churches we shouldn't be dividing each other but instead pray for unification. God bless ✝️☦️

  • opinion#3697

    Yes because there are zero Orthodox patriarchs or Saints that hold Muslim prayers reach God. I honestly think you should delete your account, you are calling for a deportation because he pointed out that your patriarchs teach this. It seems like you use Orthodoxy to act based rather than basing your content in the teachings of the church. I'm not even talking about the Muslims, your content is not representative of the teachings of Orthodoxy.

  • opinion#3687

    Didn't Paul tell the people at the Areopagus that they were ignorant of the God they already worshipped? The altar inscribed "to an Unknown God". So you repost this guy stirring up more division instead of looking for ways to bring Muslims to Christ? Which one profits more. Muslims already proclaim the God of Abraham, and like the Areopagus crowd, they're ignorant of His identity in the Man Jesus Christ. Or are you going to claim Paul was a hypocrite too.

  • opinion#3688

    Comical history. Go read some sources that aren't 200 years old and learn about intercommunion, shared priests and even bishops. The Orthodox Church today has no epistemic rationale to reject the Catholic Church and you're just misrepresenting Catholicism here in plain sight. I'd be more worried about the state of your soul. Convertodoxy is dangerous and will lead many to hell because of the aesthetic appeal rather than true spiritual repentance.

  • opinion#3690

    Eh. This is deceiving. The Catechism says Muslims profess to worship the God of Abraham. It makes no binding or infallible statement on other religions' worship. That's not the business of the Catholic Church. A Catholic is permitted to believe Allah and the Triune God differ in dramatic enough ways to say they're different altogether. However, as Trent Horn has commented on, the question isn't particularly helpful. Regardless, we should always criticize Islam for its violent nature and blatant disregard for human dignity and its rejection of Jesus Christ.