WeOrthodox
EN UA

Correcting "ortho-bros" with humility and love

Correcting "ortho-bros" with humility and love

The post addresses the phenomenon of "ortho-bros", a term for aggressive or self-righteous Orthodox Christians online, and urges believers not to condemn them from a position of superiority. The author acknowledges the concerning behavior but warns that judging these brothers while elevating oneself risks becoming the very thing one criticizes.

Citing Matthew 18:15, the text calls for correction rooted in truth, love, and humility, reminding readers that all are sinners in need of Christ's mercy. The accompanying image presents a satirical "starter pack" for the "orthobro" archetype, depicting items such as icons, a prayer rope, the Orthodox Study Bible, canon law books, and merchandise like an "Ortho-Mug" and stickers.

The discussion turns on the tension between calling out harmful behavior and maintaining a spirit of gentleness, emphasizing that the goal is to lead others toward the faith rather than to win arguments or signal virtue.

Main points

  • Warns against condemning "ortho-bros" from a stance of self-righteousness
  • Cites Matthew 18:15 as basis for correction with love and humility
  • Notes that all Christians are sinners needing Christ's mercy
  • Includes a satirical "starter pack" image caricaturing the online archetype
  • Urges guiding others with patience rather than judgment
27 opinions in the discussion 19 participants, 15 replies to each other The opinion with the most support My approach to defending Orthodoxy is simple: SHUT UP, KEEP TO YOURSELF, PRAY FOR OTHERS and LOVE ALL. "Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. It does not dishonor others, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily… Read the discussion
70 comments at the source Original on Instagram

Discussion · 27

Opinions are anonymous retellings of real comments from the original discussion. The same colour marks the same participant.

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

  • opinion#4236

    My approach to defending Orthodoxy is simple: SHUT UP, KEEP TO YOURSELF, PRAY FOR OTHERS and LOVE ALL. "Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. It does not dishonor others, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, always perseveres. Love never fails" - 1 Corinthians 13:4-8

    • opinion#4239

      If by keep to yourself you mean watchfulness and humility, then I'm 100% on board (Matthew 7:1-6)

    • opinion#4240

      Be a coward and bury your talent then.

    • opinion#4241

      I'm far from pious, I'm as messed up as anyone else and I fail constantly. Look to Christ, for He is LOVE. Keep your eyes on Christ with love and let that move you...

    • opinion#4242

      "Love, everything is love. What should concern you, my children, is love for the other person, for his soul. Whatever we do, whether it is prayer or offering advice or pointing out some error, let us do it with love. Without love, prayer is of no benefit, advice is hurtful and pointing out errors is harmful and destructive to the other person, who senses whether we love him or not and reacts accordingly. Love, love, love! Love for our brother prepares us to love Christ more. Isn't that perfect?" - St Porphyrios of Kafsokalyvia

    • opinion#4243

      Correcting others when they're in a dangerous error doesn't seem contrary to love to me.

    • opinion#4244

      Did you follow Matthew 18:15 first? If not, you've fallen short, my brother. I'm guilty of it too, Lord have mercy.

  • opinion#4238

    Yeah, I get it. It is worrying to see how some people carry themselves online, especially the so-called "ortho-bros." But let's not sit on our virtue-signalling thrones judging them. Instead let's try to bring our brothers to the faith through truth, love and humility. Bottom line: if we condemn these brothers while putting ourselves above them, we risk becoming exactly the people we're calling out. Remember that we're sinners too, in need of Christ's mercy. Correct with love, guide with patience, and never forget where the Lord brought us from. (Matthew 18:15) May the Lord humble us all.

    • opinion#4245

      I'm new to Orthodoxy and taking it slowly. I have a study bible and a welcome to the Orthodox Church book. I don't want to get icons or prayer beads until I know how to properly interpret and incorporate them.

  • opinion#4233

    I've honestly never seen an orthobro in real life. It's basically an online boogeyman.

    • opinion#4246

      Because they're normal people in real life lol

    • opinion#4247

      I have a theory that they're all exclusively American

    • opinion#4248

      What even is an "orthobro"? Some might call me one because I watch every Jay Dyer livestream and end up debating in comment sections. But we're all anonymous online and inconspicuous in person, so of course you may not recall seeing one in person.

  • opinion#4237

    I don't see anything wrong with the post. Orthodox people in general use all these things, they're not exclusive to orthobros! What sets orthobros apart is their *behaviour* (especially online), not the basic stuff every Orthodox person owns...

    • opinion#4249

      I only use the term "orthobros" for people on the internet who are annoying about their faith, to the extent that they're full of themselves.

    • opinion#4250

      You're right brother, I literally own all these items. Except a 1000 knot prayer rope, I wouldn't dare have one - strictly for true Orthodox Christians (Monastics). But you nailed it, it's all about emulating Christ not serving our own wretched will. Lord have mercy

  • opinion#4230

    Before I was orthodox I used to go hard after cathtrads. Later I had to catch myself plenty of times for getting too zealous correcting people's misreadings of orthodoxy or taking rage bait. Then I remembered that nobody's mind ever gets changed in a comment thread. So I started occasionally asking questions that make them think, with some mild success. But what's actually worked is people I know seeing my scripture posts and DMing me that they want to inquire, just from watching me live my faith. I was an inquirer myself 6 months ago, and now 5 people around me have inquired and more will come. The moment we engage in those threads we've already lost, but let's not fall into the trap of thinking we're above it either, because honestly I enjoy it sometimes. Pray that we stay out of the comment sections and for those stuck in them. Especially when I can barely keep my own prayer rule as it is.

    • opinion#4251

      Amen brother, wise words. As Orthodox Christians, we evangelise by living the faith. We emulate our Lord Jesus Christ and let our lives be an example to society of what it means to follow Him. Ultimately the battle begins inwardly. Constantly correcting, judging and trying to refute others through arguments won't bring people into the Church or transform their hearts. We risk just cornering people with arguments, much like the judgmental street preaching you see in certain Protestant circles. Let's focus on our own repentance, humility and relationship with Christ. Let our actions speak louder than our arguments. We can't preach humility while neglecting to practise it ourselves. May the Lord humble us all. Glory to God for all things!

  • opinion#4235

    A 1000 knot prayer rope would be pretty cool though lol

    • opinion#4252

      I have one of 300 and believe me they're unwieldy. Stick to 33 or 100 knots and go slow, nice and gently, repeat if you need to. It'll have an even greater effect than a large one... take it from me

    • opinion#4253

      It's only cool when worthy servants of the Lord (Monastics) have and use them properly. I struggle to keep my prayer rule, imagine me getting one. Lord, have mercy

  • opinion#4232

    I'm still an inquirer so I don't know all the ins and outs, but aren't laypeople supposed to get a blessing from their priest before doing apologetics or anything like that online? It seems like a lot of these Orthobros never did, or their priest just isn't paying attention.

  • opinion#4234

    All you theology bros need to watch your tone and attitude. Debating and defending with arguments is fine, but you also have to think critically about what you're saying and care about how you deliver the truth. Even St Paul says love is the greatest gift. I've taught biblical studies to college students for 19 years and the best approach is to listen first, ask questions, then discuss. Pray and discern before you speak.

  • opinion#4227

    One thing I've noticed is the contrast. On Catholic pages I see posts of Christ and the saints; on a lot of Orthodox pages, I see posts attacking Catholics and sometimes Protestants. Not all of them, but enough that it stands out. Maybe I'm blind to the Catholic side of it, I'm not naive, but it seems to come mostly from Orthodox accounts. When those posts show up, I'll leave a comment saying I'll pray for them. Some take it as sincere (it is), others refuse to believe it and throw slurs at me (fun fact: "papist" has always been an insult, just saying). The craziest one was when I said I'd pray for them and got told something like "keep your heretical prayers to yourself," even though we supposedly worship the same Lord????? Pointing out pride and wrath in the Orthodox Church isn't hatred or condemnation. It wasn't hate when the lust, greed and crimes in the Catholic Church were called out either. It's followers of Christ holding each other accountable. My comments come from love, that's all I can really do at the end of the day. I'll keep praying for you all; please forgive me for my sins against you, and I'll pray our merciful God forgives you of yours.

  • opinion#4228

    But honestly I've drifted away from using the term "Orthobro" because the problem just isn't as widespread as it was back when I converted. It's more of a boogeyman or a phantom punching bag these days, mostly thrown around by non-Orthodox or by people who think they're holier than everyone else.

  • opinion#4229

    They're awful. If I hear "that's a fallacy" or the phrase "ad hominem" one more time I'll lose it. I hate this Orthodox trend. Thankfully it's just a trend. Orthodox Christians are only 1.7% of Christians in the US, so they'll crawl back into their hole soon enough.

  • opinion#4231

    Funny thing: I got about 90% of that treatment when I started my journey into Orthodoxy, and I still avoided listening to any podcast or anything else talking about the Orthodox faith. Even now I just try to work out my own salvation and give my take on who others label "Orthobros." God will judge every one of our thoughts and actions. Lord have mercy!