Why Orthodox Call Priests 'Father' Despite Matthew 23:9
9:51
The video addresses the Protestant objection to calling priests 'father' based on Matthew 23:9. It argues that isolating this verse ignores its context: Jesus condemns the Pharisees' pride and love of honorific titles like 'rabbi' and 'teacher,' not the words themselves. The chapter is a sustained condemnation of the scribes and Pharisees who loved prestige, outward appearances, and honorific titles.
A literal reading would also forbid calling anyone 'teacher' in verse 10, yet Scripture everywhere acknowledges teachers and fathers as legitimate roles. The commandment to honor one's father and mother remains in force, and Paul explicitly describes spiritual fatherhood in 1 Corinthians 4:15, saying he became the Corinthians' father in Christ Jesus through the gospel.
He also refers to Timothy and Titus as his sons in the faith. The Pharisees' error was seeking honor for themselves and building a cult of personality, directing loyalty to themselves rather than to God. Christ condemns leaders who burden others, seek recognition, and accumulate disciples loyal to themselves instead of God, making an idol of a person.
Orthodox priests are called father because they participate in God's fatherhood, not because they replace it; all fatherhood derives from God, as Ephesians 3:14-15 states. The Church's liturgical structure intentionally minimizes personality cults by centering worship on Christ. The priest disappears into the liturgy, and kissing his hand venerates Christ's priesthood, which the priest shares through apostolic succession, just as honoring icons or Scripture points to God.
The video also notes that Orthodox Christians have used the title since the earliest centuries of the church, showing continuity with apostolic practice.
Key moments
- Protestants cite Matthew 23:9 to forbid calling priests father, but Orthodox Christians have used the title since the earliest centuries of the church.
- Matthew 23 is a sustained condemnation of the scribes and Pharisees who loved prestige, outward appearances, and honorific titles like "rabbi," not a prohibition on the vocabulary itself.
- Jesus also says "neither be called teachers" in verse 10; a literal interpretation would forbid both titles, yet Scripture everywhere acknowledges teachers and fathers as legitimate roles.
- The Pharisees' error was seeking honor for themselves and building a cult of personality, directing loyalty to themselves rather than to God.
- The commandment "Honor your father and mother" and Paul's statement "I became your father in Christ Jesus through the gospel" (1 Cor 4:15) show spiritual fatherhood is biblical and does not contradict Christ.
- Christ condemns leaders who burden others, seek recognition, and accumulate disciples loyal to themselves instead of God, making an idol of a person.
- All fatherhood derives from God (Eph 3:14-15); biological and spiritual fathers reflect God's fatherhood, not compete with it.
- Orthodox structure minimizes personality cults: the priest disappears into the liturgy, and kissing his hand honors Christ's priesthood received through apostolic succession.