WeOrthodox
EN UA
Holy Resurrection YouTube

St. Maximus the Greek Refutes the Filioque and Latin Innovations

St. Maximus the Greek Refutes the Filioque and Latin Innovations 18:16

This post presents the first part of St. Maximus the Greek's treatise "Response to Nicholas the Latin," a detailed polemic against several Latin doctrinal and liturgical innovations. Written in response to inquiries about the Latin separation from Orthodoxy, the work addresses four principal points of contention: the Filioque clause, Saturday fasting, mandatory clerical celibacy, and the use of unleavened bread in the Eucharist.

St. Maximus begins by reciting the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed without the Filioque, affirming it as the apostolic faith of the ancient fathers. He then systematically dismantles the Latin justification for the Filioque, particularly their appeal to Christ's breathing on the disciples in John 20:22. Drawing on Scripture and the exegesis of St. John Chrysostom, he demonstrates that this act conferred a partial, preparatory gift of the Spirit — authority to forgive sins and power over demons — ahead of the full outpouring at Pentecost, and does not constitute evidence of the Spirit's eternal hypostatic procession from the Son.

St. Maximus argues that while the Son possesses the Spirit by essence and natural communion, the property of causing the Spirit's procession belongs to the Father alone. He appeals to the consensus of the first seven ecumenical councils and early Roman popes who upheld this teaching and anathematized any alteration of the patristic dogmas.

The treatise frames the dispute as a spiritual struggle for truth, warning against hard-heartedness and love of falsehood.

Key moments

  1. St. Maximus the Greek examines principal disagreements between Orthodox and Latin doctrine: Filioque, Saturday fasting, priestly celibacy, unleavened bread, arguing they contradict ancient tradition.
  2. Specific arguments: Filioque lacks patristic foundation; Saturday fasting violates Apostolic Canons; mandatory celibacy contradicts Apostles and Sixth Ecumenical Council; unleavened bread derives from Jewish practice and is condemned by canons.
  3. St. Maximus writes in response to a request about when/how Latins separated, their use of unleavened bread, and blasphemy against the Holy Spirit.
  4. He frames the discourse as a spiritual struggle for truth, quoting Psalm 4:3 against hard-heartedness and love of falsehood.
  5. He recites the Nicene Creed (without Filioque) as the apostolic, patristic, Orthodox faith of the ancient forefathers.
  6. He refutes the Latin claim that the Filioque was added from foresight, addressing their two proofs based on Christ's bestowals of the Spirit before Pentecost.
  7. He demonstrates from Scripture and St. John Chrysostom that Christ's breathing on the disciples gave partial gifts (authority to forgive sins, power over demons) as preparation for the full outpouring at Pentecost, not evidence of eternal hypostatic procession from the Son.
  8. He argues the Son possesses the Spirit in essence and natural communion, not as cause of procession; this property belongs to the Father alone, and the early popes and ecumenical councils upheld this teaching, anathematizing any alteration of the fathers' dogmas.
6 comments at the source 2.5K views Original on YouTube

Discussion · 0

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

There is no discussion from the source for this post. Be the first to comment.