WeOrthodox
EN UA

The Primitive Church Was Visible and Sacramental, And Why That Leads to Orthodoxy

1:36

The speaker recounts a discussion in which Andrew challenges Wes on whether any modern Christian tradition can be identified with the primitive church. Wes concedes that none of the current churches fully preserve primitive Christianity, a concession the speaker says creates a larger problem. The speaker argues that the primitive church was a visible, sacramental, apostolic body governed by episcopal succession and conciliar authority, not a vague invisible unity centered on undefined core doctrines.

Orthodoxy claims to have maintained this continuity. The speaker cites St. Ignatius of Antioch: "Wherever the bishop shall appear, there let the multitude also be, even as wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the Catholic Church." This continuity with the first‑century church is the reason the speaker gives for being an Orthodox Christian.

The conversation described portrays Orthodox Christians as having held to the original faith while Catholics changed doctrine and Protestants introduced further reforms. Andrew presses Wes on the assumption that his own tradition can be found in the early church, and Wes struggles to answer. The speaker dismisses a reference to the Coptic Church as a red herring and notes that Wes never identifies which church has continuity with first‑century Christians.

Andrew observes that the speaker's position "feels kind of orthodox." The speaker concludes with the affirmation that this historical and sacramental continuity is exactly why they are Orthodox, ending with "All glory to God."

Key moments

  1. The speaker describes a conversation where Orthodox Christians are portrayed as having held true while Catholics changed doctrine, then Protestants changed it further through successive reforms.
  2. Andrew challenges Wes's implicit assumption that his own tradition can be identified within the early church, and Wes struggles to answer.
  3. Wessentially says that none of the current churches actually preserve primitive Christianity, which the speaker says creates a bigger problem.
  4. The speaker argues the primitive church was a visible sacramental apostolic church with episcopal succession and conciliar authority, not a vague invisible body united around undefined core doctrines.
  5. Orthodoxy claims to have preserved this continuity, and the speaker notes Andrew's observation that this position 'feels kind of orthodox.'
  6. The speaker dismisses the Coptic Church reference as a red herring and notes Wes never answers which church has continuity with first-century Christians.
  7. The speaker quotes St. Ignatius of Antioch: 'Wherever the bishop shall appear, there let the multitude also be, even as wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the Catholic Church.'
  8. The speaker concludes that this continuity with the primitive church is exactly why they are an Orthodox Christian, ending with 'All glory to God.'
8 opinions in the discussion 8 participants, 3 replies to each other The opinion with the most support What on earth does "Jesus' house in Cairo" have to do with figuring out which church is the true one? St. Peter's church sits in Rome, and that doesn't make papism true Read the discussion
111 comments at the source Original on Instagram

Discussion · 8

Opinions are anonymous retellings of real comments from the original discussion. The same colour marks the same participant.

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

  • opinion#4256

    What on earth does "Jesus' house in Cairo" have to do with figuring out which church is the true one? St. Peter's church sits in Rome, and that doesn't make papism true

    • opinion#4259

      He's trying to argue that older churches don't automatically have legitimacy just because of their age, which is a red herring

    • opinion#4260

      The emperor Constantine moved Rome's status over to Constantinople

  • opinion#4254

    Orthodoxy isn't merely a claim, it's something that can actually be verified through history

    • opinion#4261

      No, it isn't. You people seriously can't prove or show even a single ounce of evidence for it, and all you've got is trust me bro. And before you say "do your research", no. Show me. Show me what verse, what chapter, and what historical evidence proves the Orthodox Church is the true and original church.

  • opinion#4258

    In my opinion, calling the split between the Coptic Orthodox and Eastern Orthodox Church a red herring is intellectually and historically dishonest. The Eastern Orthodox Church and the Coptic Orthodox Church (part of the Oriental Orthodox family) broke apart after the Council of Chalcedon in 451 AD over disputes about the nature of Jesus Christ, along with political tensions and language barriers inside the Roman Empire. For me personally, the Orthodox Church allowing divorce and remarriage, allowing contraception, and the Russian patriarch calling the attacks on Ukraine a "holy war" are show stoppers.

  • opinion#4255

    I'm Catholic and I have real love for my orthodox brothers and sisters. I don't want to argue here, just an honest question: if your own Saints and ecumenical councils both teach that the Bishop of Rome heads the Universal church, and also teach that the office in Rome exists by divine origin because Christ gave authority to St. Peter, an authority that continues forever through his successors, then what are you supposed to do with that information?

  • opinion#4257

    There are the Oriental Orthodox, who are original Christianity, then Eastern Orthodox, then Roman Catholic, then protestant, going by history. But for the first several hundred years there was only one church, and that church is Orthodox, no matter the Oriental and Eastern split. I think the reasons behind that split will one day be healed. Roman catholicism is a falsehood that needs to come back to Orthodoxy, and so does protestantism.