Eastern Orthodoxy Daily He/Who/Is
Instagram
Why Freemasonry Contradicts Christian Faith
The speaker argues that Freemasonry is bound up with Judaism in its sources and theology, while denying that Christianity shares this bond. He states that containing Jewish elements does not make something Judaism. He criticizes Masonic reliance on the Zohar and Talmud, citing Masonic authority Albert Mackey who directs readers to these texts for the secrets of God, which the speaker calls rabbinic theology rather than ancient wisdom.
He disagrees with Mackey and Harvard scholar William Green, who writes that Masonry's ethos is Jewish. The speaker observes that Masonry can be shaped into whatever one wants because it lacks emphasis on Christianity, except perhaps in later York Rite versions. He states that Masonry downplays the divinity of Christ and the specifics of Christianity.
Referencing Albert Pike, he says Masonry is based on syncretism, the idea that all religions are masks of one ultimate God, which contradicts Christian absolutes. He concludes that participating in Masonry as a Christian is like joining with ecumenists and is antithetical to the absolutes of Christianity.
Key moments
- The speaker asserts that Freemasonry is bound up with Judaism to some degree.
- The speaker denies that Christianity is bound up with Judaism, stating that containing Judaism does not make something Judaism.
- The speaker says Freemasons, through Mackey, direct people to read the Zohar and the Talmud for the secrets of God, which he calls rabbinic theology and not ancient.
- The speaker disagrees with Mackey and with Harvard scholar William Green, who writes that Masonry's ethos is Jewish.
- The speaker observes that Masonry can be made into whatever one wants because it lacks emphasis on Christianity except perhaps in later York Rite versions.
- The speaker states that Masonry downplays the divinity of Christ and the specifics of Christianity.
- The speaker references Albert Pike, saying Masonry is based on syncretism, the idea that all religions are masks of one ultimate God.
- The speaker concludes that participating in Masonry as a Christian is like joining with ecumenists and is antithetical to the absolutes of Christianity.