Accepting the Canon While Rejecting the Church That Witnessed It
The speaker argues there is no factual historical evidence that John wrote the Gospel attributed to him. He directs the listener to early church history and apostolic succession, the chain of disciples who learned from John and taught others, as the basis for the text's authority. The speaker then criticizes a figure known as "The God Logic" for appealing to the early church to defend the Bible while rejecting its teaching on the real presence in the Eucharist and the authority of bishops.
He contends that if the apostolic church was wrong about its doctrines, there is no reason to trust its testimony about Scripture. The argument concludes that one cannot reject the very church whose witness undergirds the canon.
Key moments
- The speaker states there is no factual historical evidence that John wrote the Gospel attributed to him.
- The speaker directs the listener to early church history and the concept of apostolic succession, those who knew the disciples and their disciples.
- The speaker describes apostolic succession as people who learned from John becoming teachers themselves.
- The speaker accuses "The God logic" of relying on the early church to defend the Bible but rejecting it when it contradicts his theology.
- The speaker notes that "The God logic" appeals to apostolic succession but dismisses the church's teaching on the real presence in the Eucharist and episcopal authority.
- The speaker argues that if the apostolic church was wrong about its teachings, one cannot be certain it was right about the Bible.
- The speaker concludes that you cannot reject the very church whose testimony you depend on to defend your scripture.