WeOrthodox
EN UA

Accepting the Canon While Rejecting the Church That Witnessed It

The speaker argues there is no factual historical evidence that John wrote the Gospel attributed to him. He directs the listener to early church history and apostolic succession, the chain of disciples who learned from John and taught others, as the basis for the text's authority. The speaker then criticizes a figure known as "The God Logic" for appealing to the early church to defend the Bible while rejecting its teaching on the real presence in the Eucharist and the authority of bishops.

He contends that if the apostolic church was wrong about its doctrines, there is no reason to trust its testimony about Scripture. The argument concludes that one cannot reject the very church whose witness undergirds the canon.

Key moments

  1. The speaker states there is no factual historical evidence that John wrote the Gospel attributed to him.
  2. The speaker directs the listener to early church history and the concept of apostolic succession, those who knew the disciples and their disciples.
  3. The speaker describes apostolic succession as people who learned from John becoming teachers themselves.
  4. The speaker accuses "The God logic" of relying on the early church to defend the Bible but rejecting it when it contradicts his theology.
  5. The speaker notes that "The God logic" appeals to apostolic succession but dismisses the church's teaching on the real presence in the Eucharist and episcopal authority.
  6. The speaker argues that if the apostolic church was wrong about its teachings, one cannot be certain it was right about the Bible.
  7. The speaker concludes that you cannot reject the very church whose testimony you depend on to defend your scripture.
10 opinions in the discussion 10 participants, 1 replies to each other The opinion with the most support Only leans on apostolic succession when convenient, tosses it when it's not Read the discussion
36 comments at the source Original on Instagram

Discussion · 10

Opinions are anonymous retellings of real comments from the original discussion. The same colour marks the same participant.

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

  • opinion#4048

    Only leans on apostolic succession when convenient, tosses it when it's not

  • opinion#4045

    With all due respect because I love Avery and his content, but it's ironic because it's the same thing the very people he debates do. Like Muslims who cherry pick, saying this is corrupted but that isn't. Same with the apostolic faith: appeals to it when it's in his favor, rejects it when it goes against what he believes. Lord have mercy on us and save us ☦️🤍

  • opinion#4046

    We'd be seeing a lot more contradictory clips like this but he mostly debates Muslims. I'd like to see more of what he actually believes.

    • opinion#4049

      Same here, because I followed Dr. Solberg for months and then he hit me in the gut with some kind of pro Israel stance. For a man with the title of Doctor you'd think he'd have a clearer picture of how and why the New Israel is every Christian who believes Jesus Christ is God. I don't want that to happen again, but it's mostly Protestants and Catholics on my feed so it keeps happening anyway.

  • opinion#4040

    It's easy to call out Protestants for this and it's a fair critique, but how are the Eastern Orthodox any better when they reject the apostolic teachings on the Primacy of the Bishop of Rome or the Filioque? You do the exact same self-serving thing when it doesn't fit your "theology" while still promoting apostolic teachings when it comes to "Orthodoxy".

  • opinion#4047

    That's because the further they got from the apostles, the more the errors grew. By the time of the schism it was all over the place. The fathers were never infallible. I can take whatever I want from them and reject whatever I want, because they aren't apostles and they're fallible men. Unless you think the church fathers wrote infallible scripture? If not, get over it and stop crying.

  • opinion#4041

    I think he's slowly moving toward the truth so let's wait and see. Little by little I've noticed a small change in his answers on this. That last debate with the Unitarian guy was sad to hear, his answer on the Eucharist. For people with big platforms it's really hard to leave all that behind for the truth. In their minds they think "I WORKED HARD FOR THIS" without realizing it's God blessing these things to help others and to help them come to the truth too. But pride is the root. Once you knock that down and humble yourself, everything gets easy.

  • opinion#4042

    I wonder if he's just repeating what he's heard so he can give an answer and not lose the debate. Because if he genuinely believed this, he wouldn't be Protestant. Hopefully he wakes up some Protestants through it all.

  • opinion#4043

    Don't attack Avery, he's in the middle of his journey. Many times he's said his ministry is focused only on bringing people to Christianity from Islam, Mormonism, Jehovah's Witnesses, etc. He's done more for Christ and with Christ than the both of us. I say this as an active Catholic. Your video is very narrow minded brother and you should feel ashamed.

  • opinion#4044

    Even the earliest church fathers never wrote about Mary's perpetual virginity.. but 3 centuries later it's necessary dogma.. if her ever virginity was oral tradition why did the earliest fathers never expand on it beyond just her being a virgin... My church won't cut you off from communion with God over whether you accept her ever virginity, your apostolic tradition will.. When Protestants agree with the church fathers they do it carefully in a way that doesn't contradict scripture.. you all need to stop the caricature of every Protestant as picky, choosy and stubborn.. all because I won't bar someone from communion with God over unnecessary dogma.