Orthodox Sound
YouTube
Elder Savva distinguishes true humility from its counterfeit
11:14
What the video says
False humility is a counterfeit form that reveals itself through words of self-abasement and an outward appearance of meekness. Those who practice it repeatedly call themselves sinful and reveal faults, but react with anger when others agree with their self-deprecation.
The speaker describes two types of feigned humility, deliberate hypocrisy and unconscious error, and explains how outward displays of humility through words strengthen vanity, empty the soul, and become stumbling blocks to others. St. Basinufius and St. Ignatius Brianov both teach that true humility conceals itself, and it is better to appear proud outwardly while keeping a humble heart than to display false humility.
Key moments
- False humility defined as counterfeit feigned form revealing through self-abasement words and outward meekness; experienced spiritual person recognizes it as mania for appearing humble, a form of hidden pride.
- Example: person laments insignificance calling self sinful, wretched, abnormal, foolish; when someone agrees, attitude changes to anger and hostility, regards agreer as enemy.
- Story of monk wanting chains without blessing; abbot instructs blacksmith to test by striking cheek; monk strikes back, revealing false humility.
- Testing those who put themselves down reveals genuine vs feigned humility; reminding them of known faults can bring recovery; relationship may be damaged temporarily but person may later love corrector.
- False humility arises from negligence, laziness, vanity; person too lazy to work on self, takes path of false humility, boasts of it, cannot bear correction.
- Outward display of piety (frequent crossing, pronouncing God's name) mistaken for true religion; true piety keeps spiritual life hidden; taking God's name in vain in ordinary conversation and jokes is great sin.
- Two kinds of feigned humility: deliberate malicious (conscious hypocrisy for selfish purpose) and unconscious (doesn't understand spiritual laws); unconscious divides into those sincerely seeking salvation but revealing everything (emptying themselves) and those using humility as disguise for vanity.
- Outward display of humility through words harms salvation three ways: strengthens vanity and pride, empties soul through idle talk, becomes stumbling block leading to judgment envy and idle talk; St. Basinufius and St. Ignatius Brianov teach humility must be concealed.
Schema-Archimandrite Savva Ostapenko examines false humility in his chapter "False Humility" from "Seeds of Satan and the Love of Christ." He draws on Matthew 6:1-6 concerning the practice of righteousness before God rather than for human praise. The teaching identifies false humility as a counterfeit that reveals itself through words of self-abasement and outward meekness.
A person may repeatedly call themselves sinful, wretched, abnormal, or foolish, but reacts with anger and hostility when others agree, regarding the agreer as an enemy. Two types are described: deliberate hypocrisy for selfish purpose, and unconscious error from not understanding spiritual laws. The unconscious type divides into those sincerely seeking salvation but revealing everything and emptying themselves, and those using humility as a disguise for vanity.
A story illustrates this: a monk wanted chains without blessing; the abbot instructed a blacksmith to test him by striking his cheek; the monk struck back, revealing false humility. St. Basinufius and St. Ignatius Brianov teach that true humility conceals itself, and it is better to appear proud outwardly while keeping a humble heart than to display false humility.
Outward displays of humility through words strengthen vanity and pride, empty the soul through idle talk, and become stumbling blocks leading to judgment, envy, and idle talk. Testing those who put themselves down can reveal genuine versus feigned humility; reminding them of known faults can bring recovery, though the relationship may be damaged temporarily before the person may later love the corrector.
Main points
- False humility appears as self-abasement and outward meekness but reveals hidden pride when the person reacts angrily to agreement.
- Two forms: deliberate hypocrisy for selfish purpose, and unconscious error from not understanding spiritual laws.
- A monk seeking chains without blessing struck back when tested by a blacksmith, exposing his counterfeit humility.
- St. Basinufius and St. Ignatius Brianov teach true humility conceals itself; better to seem proud outwardly with a humble heart.
- Outward displays of humility through words strengthen vanity, empty the soul, and become stumbling blocks to others.