WeOrthodox
EN UA
Kyle YouTube

Former Catholic argues papal supremacy contradicts early church practice

Former Catholic argues papal supremacy contradicts early church practice 22:23

The speaker, a former Catholic who converted to Orthodoxy, responds to a Catholic apologist's defense of papal supremacy. He states that the apologist addressed only a few of his arguments and merely asserted Peter's universal jurisdiction without proof. He cites Acts 15 as a pan-Orthodox council that exercised binding authority without papal involvement, demonstrating that the early church could hold authoritative synods without a pope.

He contrasts Orthodox continuity with the first millennium, including unchanged liturgy, modern saints such as St. Paisios and St. Seraphim teaching the same faith, and no dogmatic contradictions, with Catholic innovations from Vatican II such as religious liberty, ecumenism, liturgical changes, and moral compromises. He references Pope Martin I's 649 letter acknowledging that Rome lacked canonical power to appoint the patriarch of Jerusalem, which he says contradicts Vatican I's claim of universal jurisdiction.

He notes that many bishops at Vatican I opposed papal infallibility and that Pope Pius IX rejected a proposal for a council of bishops by declaring "I am the tradition." He also argues from Galatians that Paul received his apostolic authority directly from Christ, not through Peter, and that Paul corrected Peter on a matter of faith and morals, showing Peter was not infallible.

He describes personal scandal at Vatican II's teaching that Catholics and Muslims worship the same God, John Paul II's kissing of the Quran, interreligious prayer, and modern Catholic saints promoting religious indifferentism, which he says contradicts early church spirituality. He uses the analogy of the U.S. Supreme Court chief justice as first among equals to describe the early church's view of the bishop of Rome, contrasting it with the modern papal monarchy that enables sweeping changes.

He concludes that Orthodoxy lacks nothing essential and that Catholics should consider the Orthodox Church.

Key moments

  1. The speaker identifies himself as an ex-Catholic who converted to Orthodoxy and says he is responding to a Catholic apologist named Pope Defenders who only addressed two or three of his many arguments against papal quote mines in a 25-minute video.
  2. The speaker argues that Acts 15 functions as a pan-Orthodox council that is authoritative and accepted by the whole church even though it is not called an ecumenical council, showing that Orthodoxy can have binding synods without the pope.
  3. The speaker contrasts the Orthodox Church's perfect continuity with the first thousand years, including reverent liturgy, modern saints like St. Paisios and St. Seraphim teaching the same faith, and no dogmatic contradictions, with the Catholic Church's evolving positions and modern innovations, concluding that even if Catholicism were true Orthodoxy would be missing nothing.
  4. The speaker cites Pope St. Martin's 649 letter in which Martin acknowledged that according to the canons Rome lacked the power to appoint the patriarch of Jerusalem directly, demonstrating that universal papal jurisdiction did not exist in 649 and contradicting Vatican I.
  5. The speaker notes that many bishops at Vatican I rejected papal infallibility and that an archbishop proposed adding that the pope is assisted by a council of bishops, but Pope Pius IX rejected this by saying 'I am the tradition,' which the speaker says sums up the monarchical shift of Vatican I Catholicism.
  6. The speaker describes his personal scandal at Vatican II's teaching that Catholics and Muslims worship the same God, John Paul II's kissing of the Quran and interreligious prayer, and modern Catholic saints promoting religious indifferentism, which he says contradicts early church spirituality and Orthodox fidelity to tradition.
  7. The speaker argues from Galatians that Paul's apostolic authority came directly from Christ and not through Peter, that Paul corrected Peter on a matter of faith and morals, and that this proves Peter was not infallible and did not possess universal jurisdiction.
  8. The speaker uses the analogy of the U.S. Supreme Court chief justice as first among equals, presiding, speaking for the group, and enjoying special honor but unable to unilaterally command or overrule the other justices, to explain the early church's view of the bishop of Rome, contrasting it with the modern papal monarchy that enables sweeping changes like Vatican II and the Novus Ordo.
14 opinions in the discussion 14 participants The opinion with the most support As a Mexican I can confirm what Kyle says. You really have to dig into all the lies and forgeries that piled up in medieval Europe between the 6th and 13th centuries to see that the papacy turned into a governmental hierarchy and stopped being an Orthodox… Read the discussion
106 comments at the source 12K views Original on YouTube

Discussion · 14

Opinions are anonymous retellings of real comments from the original discussion. The same colour marks the same participant.

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

  • opinion#4262

    As a Mexican I can confirm what Kyle says. You really have to dig into all the lies and forgeries that piled up in medieval Europe between the 6th and 13th centuries to see that the papacy turned into a governmental hierarchy and stopped being an Orthodox Church. If you don't grasp that you'll never leave Catholicism and you'll just cope forever. Thank you Kyle! It's been 3 years since your videos started me on the path into the Orthodox Church

  • opinion#4270

    I disagree, as someone who was non denom and picked catholicism over east orthodoxy, but I still really love the orthodox church, yall are cool.

  • opinion#4263

    Rome is so slippery. They claim popes have apostolic authority but then contradict that entirely by saying papal infallibility has only been exercised a few times in church history or some other nonsense. Then they aren't APOSTOLIC. We have the letters of Clement. The criterion for a New Testament book was that it be by an apostle, someone given an infallible public ministry by the Holy Spirit working through them uniquely like the old testament prophets. Scripture isn't scripture because God verbally dictated it to the apostles. Sometimes it is, like Isaiah, Ezekiel or Revelation. Often it isn't. Since the letters of Clement weren't recognized as scripture, to be logically consistent they'd have to completely redefine scripture apart from the actual historical event of the canon. "It is what it is because that's what we say it is" is what it always boils down to. Every single time. And with modernists and blatant contradictions they're forced into either ridiculous excuses or heretical contortions like bounded covenantal voluntarism. There's no point debating them. They're completely insulated from criticism by unfalsifiable hypotheses that again just end up as "because we say so".

  • opinion#4266

    The whole pope idea doesn't make sense even to a dumb person. Jesus is the head of the church, not an apostle. The 12 apostles were guides for building the early church and that's what the patriarchs are now. It's that simple, anything else is straight up heresy.

  • opinion#4264

    Constantinople 880 also ends modern papism. Honestly, a plain reading of church history refutes that entire schismatic sect

  • opinion#4275

    Kyle actually gets a few historical nuances right here, which is why surface-level apologists struggle, yet coming into the Catholic Church after years in Eastern Orthodoxy has genuinely been the best decision of my life, because Orthodoxy has the ancient bones and organs of the faith while missing the visible connective tissue and strength that only communion with Peter holds together. You don't have to look far to see the real fragmentation on the ground, from centuries-old splits with the Copts to Moscow and Constantinople breaking communion with each other right now, whereas Catholicism actually works as one visible, living Body across the globe. To anyone quietly discerning in the comments: don't let online polemics scare you away from coming home to the fullness of Christ's Church. "As I follow no leader save Christ, so I communicate with none but your blessedness, that is, with the Chair of Peter. For this, I know, is the rock on which the Church is built! This is the house where alone the paschal lamb can be rightly eaten. Whoever gathers not with you scatters; he who is not of Christ is of Antichrist." - St. Jerome, Letter 15 to Pope Damasus (376 AD)

  • opinion#4268

    As St Augustine said, "And so, lastly, does the name itself of Catholic, which, not without reason, amid so many heresies, the Church has thus retained; so that, though all heretics wish to be called Catholics, yet when a stranger asks where the Catholic Church meets, no heretic will venture to point to his own chapel or house." - Against the Epistle of Manichćus Called Fundamental

  • opinion#4274

    I like how in an infallible council Saint Cyril of Alexandria receives as doctrine "that the spirit comes from the son the way that the son comes from the father," but Filioque is such a grave heresy. And it's interesting Rome taught this for 500 years before the schism and the Eastern Bishops did nothing about this "grave heresy."

  • opinion#4265

    I was baptized in the RCC, and after considering going back to the Catholic Church, I found Orthodoxy, and by God's mercy I'll be Chrismated in the Orthodox Church. I'm not one for Apologetics, but this was well done. God bless! ☦️

  • opinion#4273

    I'm getting baptized catholic and I want to be as respectful as possible. Kyle, you say these things against catholicism in every video. I too disagree with some modern practices, but that's not enough for me to change my faith. Remember mass is celebrated because of the eucharist, and we have that. That's infinitely more important than anything else. And if you don't "feel holy enough" during the liturgy, I get it, but is that really a good reason to leave the Church? What I consider dangerous is the idea that "even if catholicism was true, be orthodox and you'd be fine". Even Vatican II, portrayed as too liberal, confirms the Church is necessary for salvation. We wouldn't definitively condemn anyone to hell, that's left to Our Lord, but in the Early Church, in the councils (Chalcedon, Sardica, Constantinople III) and the fathers (Optatus, Cyprian, Jerome, Leo the Great...), it's quite clear the chair of Peter is the sign of unity among believers, which makes sense. Jesus knew of all the splits, and in the papacy I see the place one could go and be assured of being in the true church, even without agreeing with every single thing. You know you're in that church. And in the future it would get far harder to spot the true church, it would look like a gamble. So if Catholicism is true (and I believe it is), rejecting the church would be seriously grave. So I'd advise you not to…

  • opinion#4267

    I've been wrestling with both Catholicism and Orthodoxy for a couple of months now, I'll admit I like the Divine Liturgy a lot more than the Novus Ordo mass, which is all that's in my area except the Ukrainian Catholic church, which I do like since it's basically the same liturgy as the Greek Orthodox church I attended several times. The problem with Orthodoxy though is it isn't as widespread as Catholicism and Protestant churches, and the priest I talked to even told me himself that Orthodox Churches haven't always done a good job evangelizing. I'm non denominational and open to studying both, but I struggle to agree with certain aspects of these two Faiths.

  • opinion#4269

    Horrible hill to die on. Pope Gregory condemns the idea of a universal Bishop. Modern Popes AGREE that back then popes didn't have this authority. To paraphrase Pope Benedict XVI "we cannot expect of them(the orthodox) than to follow the traditions of old." Historians agree it developed over time. You can see in historical sources that early popes had none of this authority, and they're so clear you can't read them any other way. They fixate on the medieval version, but that's not "the good version", they were glorifying war, yes, war against the muslims was necessary, but to say killing gets you to Heaven and call it a holy mission...

  • opinion#4271

    Mass in latin is dumb. There I said it. You're preaching the word of God, make it available in a language people understand. Jesus didn't preach in latin and neither did the apostles. So why should mass be in latin at all? The Catholic church switching mass to a language people understand was a long overdue necessity. Tradition for the sake of tradition is the way of the pharisees. God wants us to carry his word to the world, hiding it in a dead language of the people who killed the messias and oppressed the first Christians is just weird.

  • opinion#4272

    why would I never consider RC to be true? just look at its actions and words, especially the popes. praying in mosques + synagogues, declaring jews are still in covenant with god and we shouldn't try to convert them, ecumenism, aiding illegal migration...