WeOrthodox
EN UA

Questions for a Spiritual Father About Correcting Strangers Online

Questions for a Spiritual Father About Correcting Strangers Online

A satirical list framed as 'Things to say to my spiritual father' turns the lens on Orthodox Christians who spend their time correcting, exposing and condemning others online. One question cites Matthew 18:15, where Christ commands private correction before public rebuke, and asks whether Instagram stories have replaced it. Another asks how many hours of the Divine Liturgy qualify a person to pronounce ecclesiastical judgments.

The sharpest question turns inward: if I spend more time exposing everyone else's heresies than examining my own sins, am I actually defending Orthodoxy? The list ends by asking the priest to remind the speaker that the person he is desperately trying to correct online was once himself. The author frames the post with 'Lord have mercy upon us all, especially myself' and the Greek 'Δόξα τῷ Θεῷ πάντων ἕνεκεν' (Glory to God for all things), closing with ICXC.

The piece reads as a self-directed examination of conscience about online polemics, pride and the commandment to correct in private.

Main points

  • The list poses satirical questions to a spiritual father about judging bishops and other Orthodox online
  • It asks which service grants laypeople authority to declare bishops 'anaxios'
  • It invokes Matthew 18:15 on private correction versus Instagram stories
  • It asks whether exposing others' heresies while neglecting one's own sins counts as defending Orthodoxy
  • It closes by asking to be reminded that the person one corrects online was once oneself
5 opinions in the discussion 5 participants The opinion with the most support "I will not be asked how many hungry I fed, how many I clothed, or how many sick I nursed, but rather how many people I called heretics for making small mistakes online" -St Maria of Paris (probably). Read the discussion
33 comments at the source Original on Instagram

Discussion · 5

Opinions are anonymous retellings of real comments from the original discussion. The same colour marks the same participant.

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

  • opinion#3873

    "I will not be asked how many hungry I fed, how many I clothed, or how many sick I nursed, but rather how many people I called heretics for making small mistakes online" -St Maria of Paris (probably).

  • opinion#3870

    The overzealous fanatic will read this and immediately accuse me of piety signalling. So be it, I've been called much worse. The newest and maybe biggest accusation against me: ecumenist. Fine. The truth tends to expose our own pride, especially when we refuse to look at ourselves. So instead of getting defensive, take the satire to heart. And take it from someone who used to be swallowed up by exactly these arguments and semantics on this site, until Christ humbled me. I'm not talking down to anyone, I'm talking from experience. May God be with you all, and may the Lord have mercy on us all 🙏☦️❤️🕊

  • opinion#3872

    The Lord said that whoever "does and teaches" His commandments will be great in the Kingdom of Heaven (Mt 5:19). We Orthodox need to start learning some wisdom and discernment, and actually do what is good in God's eyes.

  • opinion#3871

    Ha, I actually commented on this. Somebody asked Father Josiah Trenham a question on his page, and catechumens were hurrying to answer it on his behalf.

  • opinion#3869

    For me, and I think for most people, the best thing is to work on my own repentance and fighting my passions. I'm only about a year and three months in, but it seems wisest to stick to a daily prayer rule, deal with my personal struggles, and take part in the life of my parish.