One Orthodox Church or many? A response to the claim of 14 separate churches
The video presents a claim that there is no single Eastern Orthodox Church but rather 14 separate churches corresponding to 14 patriarchs, which disagree on governance, doctrine, and sacraments. The claim cites Russian theologian Vladimir Solovyov, who said that on the day the Russian and Greek churches formally break, the world will see the ecumenical Eastern Church is a fiction and only isolated national churches exist. The speaker echoes this view, calling it the on-the-ground reality.
The speaker then responds that the claim is intellectually dishonest and false. Not every autocephalous church is headed by a patriarch, and autocephaly means self-government within a wider communion, not independent denominations. The churches together constitute the Orthodox Catholic Church.
Breaks in communion between major sees are not unprecedented; Rome and Constantinople were out of communion for 35 years during the Great Schism. The Orthodox claim is that the one Church exists as a communion of local apostolic churches sharing the same faith, sacraments, and episcopacy, and a rupture does not entail that there is no communion.
Saint Cyprian of Carthage is cited: the episcopate is one, each part held by each one for the whole, and the Church is one, spread abroad into a multitude.
Key moments
- 0:00 The claim is made that there is no Eastern Orthodox Church, only 14 Eastern Orthodox Churches because there are 14 patriarchs, and they are not in agreement on governance, doctrine, or sacraments between the Russians and the Greeks.
- 0:00 A Russian theologian, Vladimir Solovyov, is quoted saying that on the day the Russian and Greek churches formally break, the world will see the ecumenical Eastern Church is a fiction and only isolated national churches exist.
- 0:30 The speaker echoes the theologian's view that there is no Orthodox Church, only Orthodox Churches, and says this is the on-the-ground reality.
- 1:02 The speaker responds that the claim there are 14 Orthodox Churches because there are 14 patriarchs is intellectually dishonest and false, because not every autocephalous church is headed by a patriarch.
- 1:02 Autocephaly means self-government within the wider communion of the Church, not multiple separate churches as independent denominations; the churches together constitute the Orthodox Catholic Church.
- 1:37 Breaks in communion between major sees are not unprecedented, as Rome and Constantinople were out of communion for 35 years during the Great Schism.
- 1:37 The Orthodox claim is that the one church exists as a communion of local apostolic churches sharing the same faith, sacraments, and episcopacy, and a rupture does not entail that there is no communion.
- 1:37 Saint Cyprian of Carthage is cited: the episcopate is one, each part held by each one for the whole, and the Church is one, spread abroad into a multitude.