WeOrthodox
EN UA
Eastern Orthodoxy Daily He/Who/Is with Timothy Instagram

One Orthodox Church or many? A response to the claim of 14 separate churches

The video presents a claim that there is no single Eastern Orthodox Church but rather 14 separate churches corresponding to 14 patriarchs, which disagree on governance, doctrine, and sacraments. The claim cites Russian theologian Vladimir Solovyov, who said that on the day the Russian and Greek churches formally break, the world will see the ecumenical Eastern Church is a fiction and only isolated national churches exist. The speaker echoes this view, calling it the on-the-ground reality.

The speaker then responds that the claim is intellectually dishonest and false. Not every autocephalous church is headed by a patriarch, and autocephaly means self-government within a wider communion, not independent denominations. The churches together constitute the Orthodox Catholic Church.

Breaks in communion between major sees are not unprecedented; Rome and Constantinople were out of communion for 35 years during the Great Schism. The Orthodox claim is that the one Church exists as a communion of local apostolic churches sharing the same faith, sacraments, and episcopacy, and a rupture does not entail that there is no communion.

Saint Cyprian of Carthage is cited: the episcopate is one, each part held by each one for the whole, and the Church is one, spread abroad into a multitude.

Key moments

  1. 0:00 The claim is made that there is no Eastern Orthodox Church, only 14 Eastern Orthodox Churches because there are 14 patriarchs, and they are not in agreement on governance, doctrine, or sacraments between the Russians and the Greeks.
  2. 0:00 A Russian theologian, Vladimir Solovyov, is quoted saying that on the day the Russian and Greek churches formally break, the world will see the ecumenical Eastern Church is a fiction and only isolated national churches exist.
  3. 0:30 The speaker echoes the theologian's view that there is no Orthodox Church, only Orthodox Churches, and says this is the on-the-ground reality.
  4. 1:02 The speaker responds that the claim there are 14 Orthodox Churches because there are 14 patriarchs is intellectually dishonest and false, because not every autocephalous church is headed by a patriarch.
  5. 1:02 Autocephaly means self-government within the wider communion of the Church, not multiple separate churches as independent denominations; the churches together constitute the Orthodox Catholic Church.
  6. 1:37 Breaks in communion between major sees are not unprecedented, as Rome and Constantinople were out of communion for 35 years during the Great Schism.
  7. 1:37 The Orthodox claim is that the one church exists as a communion of local apostolic churches sharing the same faith, sacraments, and episcopacy, and a rupture does not entail that there is no communion.
  8. 1:37 Saint Cyprian of Carthage is cited: the episcopate is one, each part held by each one for the whole, and the Church is one, spread abroad into a multitude.
21 opinions in the discussion 20 participants, 7 replies to each other The opinion with the most support Never bring up the western schism to Roman Catholics, the time the west had 3 popes at once, with canonized saints in their own church who backed different sides of it. Read the discussion
250 comments at the source Original on Instagram

Discussion · 21

Opinions are anonymous retellings of real comments from the original discussion. The same colour marks the same participant.

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

  • opinion#4129

    Never bring up the western schism to Roman Catholics, the time the west had 3 popes at once, with canonized saints in their own church who backed different sides of it.

    • opinion#4132

      @trueorthobro and that the way they ultimately resolved it was...... drumrolllllll.. a COUNCIL.

    • opinion#4133

      first of all it was during the medieval times so it would obviously take longer. The issue with the current schism vs western schism as the Catholic Church has very very easy means of fix schism, the schism only happened because of falsely elected popes, but the Catholic Church easily has means to fix it. We argue the orthodox do not have such easy means. Majority of schism are easily fixable within the Catholic Church as well, meanwhile the Orthodox Church has many many major schisms every century. How often is autography caused schism and has taken over a decade to fix. This schism is especially since the OCU is considered graceless while still being in full communion with the Greeks. Honestly it was shocking to see how long it took Georgia to get autocephaly

    • opinion#4134

      EO schisms? Theology and doctrine hasn't been changed. Rome constantly schisms because it's always changing and always will continue to change. We've all read Vatican I and II brother

    • opinion#4135

      so easy that it takes 17 years to be fixed?

  • opinion#4131

    Once you realize they're anachronistically overlaying Latin ecclesiology onto Eastern ecclesiology, their argument falls apart. They think a church is only a church if it has a pope.

  • opinion#4128

    Without lies Catholicism dies. What their bishops agree on is that they worship the same God as Muslims. What their modern bishops get right is that Rome had no jurisdiction in the East, which their own Chieti document states and church history confirms.

    • opinion#4136

      Yk ur own saints says the same right?

    • opinion#4137

      Btw chiety doesnt refute catholism..it proves it and refutes orthodoxy..maybe stop recyling same trash non sense like dyer and read it

    • opinion#4138

      Your church has the exact same teaching and it has never said otherwise.

  • opinion#4127

    This is so dumb coming from them. I'm Antiochian Orthodox and I could take communion at both, because both are still part of the Eastern Orthodox Church. They talk like the Church as a whole is divided. It's not.

  • opinion#4119

    I try to stay out of the Orthodox vs Catholic fights. I'm Orthodox too and I honestly just don't want to hear about it or get involved. But watching these two guys for so long, as a Mexican myself it's really strange how many interviews, podcasts and meetups they've had with Orthodox people, priests, maybe even bishops. And they're always so friendly, handing out compliments left and right. But the second they're not around those people, they've got nothing but smack to talk. Maybe the media makes it look worse than it is, but it feels like every video of them now is just them trash talking the Orthodox churches. And since I mentioned I'm Mexican, you know what it honestly feels like? Because the stereotype tends to be pretty true. It's like that family member who's sweet to your face and then talks crap about you to other relatives.

  • opinion#4130

    If they argue that internal schisms refute a church, they shoot the Catholic Church in the foot, since the Catholic Church (which Catholics claim is the church of the first millennium, though in truth that's just the Orthodox Church of the first millennium) went through the Acacian schism (mentioned in the video), the Meletian schism, the Photian schism, to name a few. This has never been a dealbreaking issue.

  • opinion#4118

    Why would a jurisdictional dispute count as a bigger schism than popes who each push totally different doctrine? Most of them don't agree with one another and enforce radically different rules while in office. So does that mean there's no Roman Catholic Church at all, just a series of separate popes?

  • opinion#4120

    Jonathan and Anthony "have eyes but do not see, have ears but do not hear." The One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church doesn't look like a Gothic Kingdom. It's a communion of many bishops and priests in many languages, and their disputes are usually over jurisdiction, not theology. That's how the Church was set up by the Apostles and how it still runs today. The truth of the early church is sitting right in front of them and they reject it to prop up papal power and authority, which is modelled on Gothic Kingdoms.

  • opinion#4121

    These two idiots don't get that plenty of patriarchs in history were heretics and that caused partial schisms, not complete ones. Greeks and Russians share the same doctrine. Meanwhile these two belong to a church that has different teachings inside it! The latins contradict the eastern rites. Total liars, both of them.

  • opinion#4122

    You can't be Catholic and "ethno centric". Walk into a Catholic Church and you see all races praying together. Walk into an Orthodox Church, go look for yourself. Catholic means the Roman and Eastern Rites only, the OrthoBros lost the Catholic rites in 1054, and Catholics practice Catholic Orthodoxy, so yours is (true but) optional for us. The door is open for reunion, I'm a child of each one, so I have a say, we welcome you back. We should be the church of the first millennium. Look at our fruits, full stop.

  • opinion#4123

    Ask any Catholic, Orthodox, or basically any Protestant these questions and watch how fast they pivot from Scripture to appeals to church authority. Why does ONLY Paul call it "my gospel" (Romans 2:16, Romans 16:25, 2 Timothy 2:8 KJV)? What's the difference between prophecy and mystery? Why does Paul say the gospel is "according to the revelation of the mystery, which was kept secret since the world began" (Romans 16:25 KJV) while Peter says it's what God "hath spoken by the mouth of all his holy prophets since the world began" (Acts 3:21 KJV)? How can something be kept secret since the world began and something else spoken by the prophets since the world began? Why does James say "by works a man is justified, and not by faith only" (James 2:24 KJV) while Paul says to him "that worketh not, but believeth on him that justifieth the ungodly, his faith is counted for righteousness" (Romans 4:5 KJV)? Why does Peter say "Repent, and be baptized every one of you... for the remission of sins" (Acts 2:38 KJV) while Paul says "Christ sent me not to baptize, but to preach the gospel" (1 Corinthians 1:17 KJV)? What does "Study to shew thyself approved unto God... rightly dividing the word of truth" (2 Timothy 2:15 KJV) actually mean? Do you know the difference between the Judgment Seat of Christ (2 Corinthians 5:10; Romans 14:10), the Judgment of the Nations (Matthew 25:31-46), and the…

  • opinion#4124

    Even if we were dishonest and granted them correct, there's still pride mass, Harry Potter mass, erasure of traditions, changing of doctrine (not just "developing" it, which is a problem in itself), ecumenism taken to an absolute detriment, the whole "pachamama" situation, THOUSANDS of clergy heavily involved in pedophilia, failing eastern "catholic" churches while their Roman church is estimated to be worth over 73 Billion. The list goes on and on. So even granting their false claim, that still doesn't touch the massive pile of other problems they've got.

  • opinion#4125

    As far as I know the Russians and Greeks just don't celebrate each other. But I was brought into the Orthodox Church in an EP parish and I've attended and communed in ROCOR parishes with no problem. And yes, I let the priest know, since we were just visitors.

  • opinion#4126

    Sorry, but if you're not in communion with Alexandria your altar is against the altar of the world, as St Augustine of Hippo says: "The Catholic Church would much more probably recognize this in those of her members who are in Egypt among the thousands of the servants of God who live in holy fellowship throughout the desert..." and he goes on: "Why do they not communicate with the Church that was foretold of the Egyptians? Or, if Egypt signifies the world in this prophetic allegory, why do they not communicate with the world?" And again: "but you raised one against the entire world and against the words of the one who commended his Church beginning from Jerusalem throughout all nations." It literally predicts pope Leo's rebellion against the church by using imperial force to call an episcopal council which was presided by Alexandria according to Nicea canon 1 (325), canon 6, a robber council for his time that emphasized Nestorianism wasn't read, which contradicts Nicea. And I could keep going on why the EO isn't the one true apostolic church.