WeOrthodox
EN UA

Patristic Case Against Filioque: Spirit Proceeds from Father Alone

The author presents a polemical argument against Roman Catholicism, listing six doctrinal errors: the Filioque, papacy, purgatory, predestination, and two Vatican II documents (Nostra Aetate and Unitatis Redintegratio). The bulk of the text focuses on the Filioque, asserting that the Holy Spirit proceeds eternally from the Father alone.

The author cites numerous Old Testament passages (Psalm 32:6, Psalm 103:30, Psalm 113:25, Psalm 138:7-8, Isaiah 11:2-3, Isaiah 61:1) and New Testament passages (Matthew 10:19-20, Matthew 12:28, John 14:16, John 15:26, John 16:13-15, John 20:22, Acts 2, Romans 8:11, 1 Corinthians 2:11-12, Galatians 4:6). For each, extensive patristic quotations are provided from figures such as Basil the Great, Gregory of Nyssa, Gregory Nazianzen, Cyril of Alexandria, Ambrose, Augustine, John Chrysostom, and others, interpreting these verses as teaching the Spirit's procession from the Father.

The author also addresses John 14:16 ("I will ask the Father to send the Spirit") as evidence that the Son is not a cause of the Spirit's procession. Gregory Palamas is cited to distinguish eternal manifestation through the Son from eternal procession from the Son. The post concludes that the Filioque introduces two causes in the Trinity, subordinates the Holy Spirit, and contradicts the monarchy of the Father (Sola Arche).

The work is framed as a second volume in a series, opening with a prayer invoking saints such as Gregory Palamas, Photios the Great, and Mark of Ephesus.

Main points

  • Argues Catholicism has corrupted original doctrine, listing six errors including Filioque and Vatican II documents.
  • Contends the Holy Spirit proceeds eternally from the Father alone, citing Old and New Testament passages.
  • Provides extensive patristic commentary on Psalm 32:6 and Psalm 103:30 from Basil, Gregory of Nyssa, Gregory Nazianzen, Cyril, Ambrose, Augustine, Chrysostom.
  • Uses John 14:16 ("I will ask the Father") to refute the Son as a cause of the Spirit's procession.
  • Cites Gregory Palamas on the distinction between eternal manifestation through the Son and procession from the Father, warning that Filioque subordinates the Spirit.
20 opinions in the discussion 11 participants, 16 replies to each other The opinion with the most support the Spirit's procession from the Son isn't solely economic, there's an eternal procession of the Spirit from the Son as well Read the discussion
42 comments at the source Original on Instagram

Discussion · 20

Opinions are anonymous retellings of real comments from the original discussion. The same colour marks the same participant.

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

  • opinion#3939

    the Spirit's procession from the Son isn't solely economic, there's an eternal procession of the Spirit from the Son as well

    • opinion#3940

      dude I meant as a cause and I already clarified this, read where I describe Gregory Palamas

    • opinion#3941

      i saw that part, but the Spirit's eternal manifestation is distinct from His economic procession towards men. Maybe I'm misinterpreting but it seems like you collapse the eternal manifestation with the Spirit being given to men in time

    • opinion#3942

      No I don't, I explicitly affirm both in the text

    • opinion#3943

      do you believe that God poured his wrath on the son, damning him to hell in our place to satisfy his sense of divine justice?

    • opinion#3944

      That's pure Calvinism and not our belief, because this collapses the Trinity and it's a strawman

    • opinion#3945

      I know it's Calvinism and I know it's not Orthodox, however it is a real Calvinist position, especially among reformed baptists. Calvin himself believed this but with the caveat Jesus experienced damnation on the cross

    • opinion#3946

      go on my page and read the post on psa

  • opinion#3937

    Energetic procession exists lads, economic procession isn't the only procession we Orthodox hold to.

    • opinion#3947

      the eternal procession isn't energetic, it's an actual hypostatic relation from the Son that isn't causal

    • opinion#3948

      which is easily just energetic procession and eternal manifestational procession.

    • opinion#3949

      Dude I already know this, read my post completely, I explain the procession through the Son too

  • opinion#3938

    Its not "solely economic and not eternal" bro what

    • opinion#3950

      you're ignorant dude, ignorance will kill you. in slide 17 I explicitly affirm eternal manifestation, don't be ignorant

    • opinion#3951

      what do you think eternal manifestation is

    • opinion#3952

      The Holy Spirit rests in the Son as per St Cyril of Alexandria

  • opinion#3936

    i think cyril complicates your case a bit; he regularly speaks of the procession of the spirit of the son in a way that makes eternal manifestation seem like doctrinal retrojection. here are some quotes: cyril of alexandria in the thesaurus "That the holy ghost is out of (εκ) the essence of the father and the son." "Since therefore the Holy Ghost, coming to be in us, makes us conformed to God and He goeth forth out of (εκ) the Father and the Son, it is manifest that He is of the Divine Essence, being Essentially in It and going forth out of (εξ) It: even as the breath too which goeth out of (εξ) the mouth of man, though the illustration be poor and unworthy, for God will surpass all things." "that the Spirit is God and hath every way the same operation with the Son and is not alien from His Essence: also that, when God is said to dwell in us, it is the Spirit Who indwelleth." "Since Christ giveth laws, the Spirit, as being by Nature in Him and out of (εξ) Him, Himself too is Law-giver" cyril of alexandria in de trinitate "He sent us the Comforter out of (εκ) Heaven, through Whom and in Whom He is with us and dwelleth in us, not infusing into us an alien, but the own Spirit of His Essence and of that of His Father." "for how should the Spirit, that is both out of (εξ) Him and in Him and His Very Own, partake of Him and be sanctified relatively, like those things which are…

    • opinion#3953

      cyril of alexandria in explicatio duodecim capitum, written at the request of and approved by the same council of ephesus "The Only-Begotten Word of God, having become Man, remained thus too God, being all that the Father is, save only being the Father, and having as His own the Holy Ghost Which is out of (εκ) Him and Essentially inexisting in Him." cyril of alexandria in de recta fide, ad theodosium "He said, that He would baptize in fire and the Holy Ghost, infusing into the baptized no Spirit alien to Himself, in manner of a servant and minister, but as being by Nature God with supremest authority, [He infused] the Spirit Which is out of (εξ) Him and His Very Own." cyril of alexandria in de recta fide, ad reginas "The resurrection of Christ was not by the nature of the Body, although It was the very own Body of the Word Who was Begotten of God; but rather by that supreme power and Nature above creation, as in the Person of God the Father, out of (εξ) Whom the Son appeared equal and like in all things, and the Life-giving Spirit goeth forth through Both." (προεισι δι αµφοιν)." cyril of alexandria in de adoratione "Seeing He [the Holy Spirit] is the Spirit of God the Father and the Son also, Which is poured forth essentially out of (εκ) Both, i.e., out of (εκ) the Father through the Son." 2/3

    • opinion#3954

      i'll save you his longer quotations, but the point is that when speaking of the procession of the spirit from the son cyril regularly uses the preposition ek, as opposed to dia or par, not that he doenst use those words but he doesnt seem to distinguish them in the same way that later eastern theologians would. his preferred phraseology is something to the effect of proienai ek tou patros kai tou yiou, which the east regards as imprecise, since the proper relation of the spirit to the father is of the word ekporeusthai; not that cyril never uses this word but doesnt distinguish them either; hes will to say the spirit proceeds through both father and son as proiesi di' amphoin. there are other greek fathers who say similar things, notably epiphanius of salamis and athanasius. the west doesnt argue that the greek fathers taught the filioque, since its not clear that they did, but what the west does say is their language is closer to the latin filioque than to eternal manifestation or energetic procession 3/3

    • opinion#3955

      Show a single verse which says holy spirit proceed ONLY ECONOMICALLY from SON