WeOrthodox
EN UA

Orthodox answer: salvation by grace through living faith, not three separate merits

The speaker responds to a critic who claims Orthodoxy requires faith, sacraments, and good works as three separate merits for salvation. He argues this misrepresents the Orthodox position, which holds that we are saved by grace through faith in union with Christ. The sacraments and obedience are not alternatives to faith but part of the life of faith Christ gave.

Scripture supports this: Peter says baptism saves, Christ says eating his flesh and drinking his blood gives life, James says faith without works is dead, and Paul speaks of faith working through love. The critic's use of Romans 4:5 does not prove faith alone apart from sacraments or works; Paul there denies earning righteousness as a wage, which Orthodoxy also denies.

James explicitly states a man is justified by works and not by faith alone. Orthodoxy teaches that the grace of Christ saves us through a living, sacramental, obedient faith working through love, as St. Cyril of Jerusalem describes baptism as a ransom, remission, death of sin, and new birth.

Key moments

  1. The critic lists three Orthodox requirements for salvation: faith, the saving sacraments (baptism, confirmation, repentance and confession, and the Eucharist), and good works, claiming faith is not enough.
  2. The speaker rejects the idea that faith, sacraments, and works are three competing methods to earn salvation.
  3. The Orthodox position is that we are saved by grace through faith in union with Christ, and the sacraments and obedience are part of the life of faith Christ gave.
  4. Scripture is cited: 1 Peter says baptism now saves you; Christ says unless you eat his flesh and drink his blood you have no life; James says faith without works is dead; Paul says faith works through love.
  5. The critic quotes Romans 4:5 about faith counted as righteousness for the one who does not work, but Romans 4:4 clarifies Paul is denying righteousness earned as a wage, which Orthodoxy also denies.
  6. Romans 4 does not say baptism, the Eucharist, obedience, and repentance are unnecessary; that must be read into the text.
  7. James explicitly states a man is justified by works and not by faith alone.
  8. Orthodoxy teaches the grace of Christ saves us through a living, sacramental, obedient faith working through love, as St. Cyril of Jerusalem describes baptism as a ransom, remission, death of sin, and new birth.
18 opinions in the discussion 17 participants, 8 replies to each other The opinion with the most support The Protestant mind just can't handle both/and Read the discussion
106 comments at the source Original on Instagram

Discussion · 18

Opinions are anonymous retellings of real comments from the original discussion. The same colour marks the same participant.

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

  • opinion#3882

    The Protestant mind just can't handle both/and

    • opinion#3884

      Not just the Protestant mind, it's the western mind in general. Protestants came out of Catholicism, so they get some of the blame too

    • opinion#3885

      We don't need to comprehend your doctrine when we have scripture. You keep adding hurdles to something simple and straightforward. The sacrifice has been made. Jesus has died. We are saved. Praise the Lord.

  • opinion#3880

    And it's not even confirmation, it's chrysmation

  • opinion#3881

    In reality orthodoxy is more sola scriptura than protestants, and protestants are the ones following tradition

    • opinion#3886

      How so? My argument is that the teaching of lived vs written tradition got defined around 300 ad, when the Nicene councils organized the books into the bible. So following the bible alone gets you a big part of the church, but only a part

    • opinion#3887

      The Orthodox were Orthodox before the Bible was formally compiled, through the same Church and Councils that established the biblical canon. And you're claiming we're "more Sola Scriptura than Protestants." You just don't understand the Faith properly.

    • opinion#3888

      They're all gonna miss your point

    • opinion#3889

      So the Orthodox are more sola because they follow what's said to do as works in the Bible as where protestants treat it as a suggestion and make it a tradition to do so.

    • opinion#3890

      He's saying Protestants follow their traditions more closely than the scriptures because they don't lol. He's saying orthodoxy holds to the true interpretation of the scriptures and actually does what the entirety of the scriptures says.

    • opinion#3891

      yea for example protestants blessing israel?😂😂 ridiculous claim

  • opinion#3883

    I do believe you're saved by faith alone without works, but I think the culture of orthodoxy is right anyway. Confession, baptism, the Eucharist and good works should be there, and should be "enforced" if you will, and I think that's basically all Orthodoxy is.

  • opinion#3876

    Paul says in 1 Corinthians 16:22 "If anyone does not love the Lord Jesus Christ, let him be accursed." And Jesus in John 14:15 "If you love Me, keep My commandments." Scripture makes it pretty clear that faith alone isn't enough for salvation. Glory to God ☦️

  • opinion#3877

    The Bible also calls faith a work. 1 Thessalonians 1:3 "Remembering without ceasing your work of faith, labor of love, and patience of hope in our Lord Jesus Christ in the sight of our God and Father."

  • opinion#3874

    Nobody finds it odd that the apostles wrote down Jesus' teachings and their own but never once mentioned veneration (asking for prayers) of the saints? If it's that important, why didn't the people who founded the church write it down? They wrote about baptism and communion. The didache doesn't mention asking saints for intercession either. And no early church father brings it up until the 3rd century. Looks like an added tradition to me. I'd be really interested in orthodoxy but I can't get past this, because nothing we have even mentions it until suddenly the 3rd century. If it mattered, wouldn't Jesus or the apostles have written about it? Happy to be proven wrong if someone has evidence I haven't seen. The problem with giving the church authority is that it can add things with no support from Jesus, the apostles, or the early church (300 years later isn't early)

  • opinion#3875

    Picture the thief on the cross getting to heaven's gate. "So, you were a thief? What sacraments did you do, where's your obedience to Christ, where are your works? Were you baptized? Confirmed? How did you get in?" And the thief answers: I believed in the man hanging next to me, and he said today you will be with me in paradise

  • opinion#3878

    Belief is a work... John 6:28-29: people ask Jesus what works of God they should do, and he answers that the work of God is to believe in the one he sent. But how is just agreeing with an idea a work? Because it's not mere mental approval. Look at the Greek for "believe." Pisteuō is broader and deeper than the English word, which we treat as intellectual agreement. In the NT it means trust, reliance, fidelity, commitment, entrusting yourself to someone. It's related to pistis, usually translated "faith" or "faithfulness," a word family about loyalty and reliability in relationship. So it's relational, not just intellectual. Faithfulness is commitment. Commitment is work. Simple as that. Even demons have intellectual belief; James 2:19 says they believe and shudder. Bare mental assent isn't enough. Philippians 2:12 says work out your salvation with fear and trembling; it's not a one-time legal ruling when you say you believe. That's why faith passages keep showing up with perseverance, obedience, baptism, repentance, and union with Christ instead of as private opinions. Faith is lived out in communion with Christ and the Church, not just agreed to in your head.

  • opinion#3879

    Bro, I don't know what I did, but ig locked my dms for 3 days. Sources though: Boniface VIII's bull Unam Sanctam (Nov 18, 1302) declares, proclaims and defines that submission to the Roman Pontiff is absolutely necessary for salvation. The "precursor of Antichrist" line is Gregory, Registrum Book VII, Letter 33, to Emperor Maurice around 596-597 (he actually says "universal priest," not "universal pope," but same idea). Him refusing the title "universal pope" for himself is his letter to Eulogius of Alexandria, Book VIII, Letter 30. About the title change: at an eastern council in 588, Bishop John "the Faster" of Constantinople took the title "Ecumenical Patriarch" from Emperor Maurice, but he didn't invent it. Versions of it had been used in addresses to Byzantine patriarchs since 518, they just hadn't claimed it themselves before John IV. Gregory the Great misunderstood the title because "ecumenical" basically means "imperial," and he read it as universal. He was wrong. There was even an "ecumenical Liberian" in Constantinople meaning an imperial Liberian, implying no authority over other Liberians. That's about it bro