WeOrthodox
EN UA

Christ's Establishment of the Church as Institution in Matthew 18

A dialogue examines whether Christ established an institution. One speaker argues that religious systems and institutions kill the spirit of God and questions whether Christ founded an institution. The other responds that God established a way of salvation. The first speaker then cites Matthew 18 as explicit evidence that Christ did establish an institution.

He outlines the three-step process Jesus gives for dealing with a sinning brother: first confront him privately, then bring two or three witnesses, and finally bring the matter to the church. The speaker argues that this third step, bringing the matter to the church, demonstrates an institution that transcends the body of believers, concluding that the church is both a body and an institution.

Key moments

  1. The first speaker claims that religious systems and institutions are the things that kill the spirit of God in the world.
  2. The first speaker asks whether Christ established an institution.
  3. The second speaker answers that God established a way of salvation.
  4. The first speaker argues that Christ established an institution, pointing to Matthew chapter 18 as explicit evidence.
  5. The first speaker outlines the steps in Matthew 18: go to the brother privately, then bring two or three witnesses, which constitutes a church, and if they refuse to listen, bring them to the church.
  6. The first speaker concludes that this third category demonstrates an institution transcending just the body, affirming that the church is both a body and an institution.
4 opinions in the discussion 4 participants, 1 replies to each other The opinion with the most support This argument doesn't get enough credit. Any kind of church discipline that actually does anything requires being the exclusive church. Read the discussion
7 comments at the source Original on Instagram

Discussion · 4

Opinions are anonymous retellings of real comments from the original discussion. The same colour marks the same participant.

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

  • opinion#4052

    This argument doesn't get enough credit. Any kind of church discipline that actually does anything requires being the exclusive church.

  • opinion#4050

    He dodged the question. "I believe God established a way of salvation" - dude, that's not what was asked. Meanwhile Ben Michael just cut right to it, "Ok, I believe He established an institution." Now THAT is answering the question!

  • opinion#4051

    Protestants have their own institutions too. The moment laying on of hands is used to hand down authority and ordination, they've made themselves an authority, even if they downplay it as much as they can so they look like just equals with no institution behind them. And they run everything in their churches and between churches like a worldly organization. Most of them answer to other organizations anyway.

    • opinion#4053

      I think there's a big misunderstanding going on about Protestants and what sola scriptura actually means and how it works. I grew up in Baptist churches that exercised church authority according to each church's membership requirements (profession of faith, baptism, affirmation of the trinity). I don't have a problem with church authority and I'm not a mainline Protestant. I get that it's hard to critique because Protestants are all over the place, but some of us out here aren't part of the mainstream nonsense you see everywhere.