WeOrthodox
EN UA

How three traditions answer which church is true after a split

The speaker compares how Catholics, Protestants, and Eastern Orthodox identify the true church after a split. Catholics rely on the Pope's authority as external confirmation. Protestants rely on private scriptural interpretation to judge each church.

Eastern Orthodoxy requires submission to the bishop and does not allow private scriptural judgment of the church. The speaker then challenges the Catholic and Protestant approaches. He notes that the Western Schism required a council to resolve competing papal claims, which challenges the Catholic method.

He also notes that when churches disagree, Protestants cannot determine whose scriptural interpretation is correct. Orthodox Christians instead appeal to the Holy Spirit working through the entire church, not one man's authority or individual interpretation. Through scripture, apostolic tradition, the fathers, and ecumenical councils, they can judge whether bishops remained faithful to the teachings handed down by the apostles.

Key moments

  1. 0:00 The question is how to know which side of a church split is the true church.
  2. 0:00 Catholics identify the true church by following the Pope as external confirmation.
  3. 0:00 Protestants identify the true church by privately judging each church against scripture.
  4. 0:00 Eastern Orthodoxy requires submission to the bishop and does not allow private scriptural judgment of the church.
  5. 0:00 The Western Schism required a council to resolve competing papal claims, challenging the Catholic method.
  6. 0:00 When churches disagree, Protestants cannot determine whose scriptural interpretation is correct.
  7. 0:00 Orthodox Christians appeal to the Holy Spirit working through the entire church, not one man's authority or individual interpretation.
  8. 0:37 Through scripture, apostolic tradition, the fathers, and ecumenical councils, we can judge whether bishops remained faithful to the teachings handed down by the apostles.
15 opinions in the discussion 13 participants, 9 replies to each other The opinion with the most support Beautifully put. Papalists and prots don't understand the EO position and strawman like crazy Read the discussion
69 comments at the source Original on Instagram

Discussion · 15

Opinions are anonymous retellings of real comments from the original discussion. The same colour marks the same participant.

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

  • opinion#3926

    Beautifully put. Papalists and prots don't understand the EO position and strawman like crazy

    • opinion#3927

      I'd highly suggest going to the nearest Eastern Orthodox church and asking a priest. When I first went to a priest I was amazed at how educated and spiritually beneficial it is

  • opinion#3924

    Nice try but the Orthodox don't actually believe the Holy Spirit guides the entire Church like they claim. If they did, they would've stayed unified with the Catholics after 2nd Lyon.

    • opinion#3928

      history doesn't reflect this. The eastern Church agreed with the western Church on papal authority, Filioque, and purgatory. The Church was unified for about 20 years until Andronikos ii became emperor. He arrested and exiled pro-union patriarchs, including John Bekkos xi, patriarch of Constantinople. Andronikos then rescinded all agreements from the 2nd council of Lyon. The two highest authorities in Christendom, the bishop of Rome and patriarch of Constantinople, were unified... and it was undone by the Byzantine emperor.

    • opinion#3929

      No, emperor Michael VIII was forcing the union even though nobody agreed with it, to gain papal protection and curb threats from Charles of Anjou and Latin powers. Also the western church had sent crusaders to brutally sack Constantinople and set up a Latin empire. So Orthodox Christians saw Rome as a foreign invader. They were being persecuted and forced to accept the Papacy, Filioque and Purgatory by Michael viii. Also none of the other patriarchs at the time agreed with John Bekkos xi, who was made Patriarch of Constantinople because he agreed with Michael viii. You're leaving a lot of context out.

    • opinion#3930

      Also 2nd Lyon didn't include most of the Orthodox patriarchs, so we see it as an invalid ecumenical council. Emperor Michael was just going to conform to all the West's dogma while pretty much all of the East disagreed. We will never conform with Roman Catholic heresy.

    • opinion#3931

      "brutally sack Constantinople" 1. Crusaders operated against orders. The western Church sent them to Jerusalem, not Constantinople. 2. They retaliated against the eastern Church for slaughtering 70,000 Catholics and selling the surviving women and children into slavery. "None of the other patriarchs agreed" Unknown definitively, but many did disagree, that's true. Michael viii was integral in convening the council with the assurance the Churches would be unified. Greek clergy were present. "John Bekkos" I actually feel bad for him. Michael viii imprisoned him when he opposed reunification and Andronikos imprisoned him for being pro reunification. I guess you really had to just go along with whichever emperor was in charge.

    • opinion#3932

      Lyon and Florence were attempts to exploit the situation by forcing Rome's view in exchange for military aid. But "the gates of hell shall not prevail against it" - the councils were rightly rejected. Lyon never discussed the Filioque. Florence did discuss it and couldn't find an answer, so they decided to say both views are the same thing in different languages. Church unity will only come when both churches go back to the seven ecumenical councils.

  • opinion#3925

    Well... Assyrian church of the East, Seventh-Day adventists, and Non-denoms are not protestant. I'd even argue quakers aren't either. 😌

    • opinion#3933

      if it isn't Catholic or orthodox, it's Protestant. It's not about theology, it's about history.

    • opinion#3934

      No. For starters, the Assyrian church cannot be protestant by definition because it existed before Rome and EO, at least as they are today. Second, you bring up history, but that's precisely why it's untrue that any organization outside EO or RC is protestant. The churches of the reformation have history behind the movement; RC and EO just strawman what protestantism is. Everything else outside prots is just variations of non-denoms, evangelicals, restorationists, or some weird things that came later.

    • opinion#3935

      you're partially right, there's also the Oriental Orthodox. But Adventist and non-denom are fundamentally Protestant (in historical origins and theological inheritance), just not classical Reformation Protestant if you want to be precise. We use Protestant as a broad term for the broad category.

  • opinion#3921

    it's not like Catholics have tons of verified saints (canonized due to documented intercessory miracles), the greatest charitable presence on earth (schools, hospitals, clinics, orphanages, etc), incorrupt saints, Eucharistic miracles and Marian apparitions. Haha wait, they do have all that 😉 debating whether religion is legal gets old, how about discussing how one saves your soul and what each church teaches on truly healing your heart and striving for union with God. Not clickbait that gets views, but more of what the gospel actually is! Let the preaching of it be followed by signs and wonders :)

  • opinion#3922

    Quotes- • Equal Bishops in Local Churches. In the NT and first centuries, every city had its own bishop leading the local community. As in Acts 15 (Council of Jerusalem), apostles and elders gathered to debate and decide jointly rather than bowing to one supreme ruler. • The Pentarchy. As the Church grew, five ancient apostolic cities became the main centers: Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, Jerusalem. None of these Patriarchs could interfere in another's territory or dictate belief to the whole Church. • First Among Equals. The Bishop of Rome got a primacy of honor because Rome was the imperial capital and where Peter and Paul were martyred. But this was respect and mediation, not supreme legal power over other bishops. • Canon 34 of the Apostles. This early rule says bishops of each region must recognize one head among them, yet that leader can do nothing without the consent of all the others. How this connects to Scripture on early death • Shared Interpretation. With no single patriarch ruling, early Christians across all five patriarchates used the same Greek OT (Septuagint) and NT writings to understand life and death. • Consensus on God's Mercy. Bishops in Antioch, Alexandria and Constantinople all taught from Wisdom 4:11-14 ("he was caught up lest evil change his understanding") and Isaiah 57:1 ("the righteous is taken away from before the evil"). Since this…

  • opinion#3923

    It is not Protestant private interpretation vs Catholic Church authority. That is still liar vs liar. God forbid. Let God be true. ROMANS 3:4 God forbid: yea, let God be true, but every man a liar; as it is written. The issue is not "which man gets to interpret?" The issue is: what did God say? Protestant tradition is not my authority. Catholic tradition is not my authority. Church fathers are not my authority. Councils are not my authority. My personal opinion is not my authority. God's preserved words are the authority. 2 PETER 1:20-21 no prophecy of the scripture is of any private interpretation, for the prophecy came not in old time by the will of man, but holy men of God spake as they were moved by the Holy Ghost. Scripture did not come from man's will, so man does not get to rule over it. God said what He meant. God preserves what He said. God interprets His own words. So stop making it Protestant vs Catholic. It is God's words vs man's words. Let God be true, and every man a liar.