WeOrthodox
EN UA
Orthodox Health Instagram

Your Doctor Has a Theology: Healthcare's Hidden Assumptions

The post promotes Episode 86 of the Orthodox Health Podcast, "The Roots of Healthcare: Why Your Doctor Has a Theology," featuring Dr. Zachary Porcu. The episode argues that healthcare categories, healthy, normal, disordered, progress, better, are not neutral. Each assumes a view of what a human being is, what human life is for, and what counts as flourishing.

Dr. Porcu contends that science is downstream from a religious worldview because there is no human control group outside culture, history, genetics, geography, and worldview. Every person inhabits a story that shapes what they fear, pursue, and expect from healthcare. If comfort becomes the highest good, suffering becomes meaningless.

If technological control becomes salvation, the tower of Babel simply puts on a lab coat. Christianity offers a different account: health is a real good but not the highest good. Illness can wake us up. Prayer, Holy Unction, holy water, and the Eucharist are not techniques of control but part of life in Christ.

The episode asks the underlying question: "What are you getting healthy for?" It compares artificial theosis through technology to Babel, noting that such progress disconnects one from reality. Science can describe how the body works but cannot answer what health is for, what counts as progress, what should be fixed, or what kind of life is worth preserving.

Those questions require a theological anthropology. Therefore, every doctor operates with a theology, whether acknowledged or not.

Key moments

  1. Religion is the top-level view of the world that informs smaller domains like science and culture.
  2. A doctor recommends carpal tunnel surgery while admitting the patient does not have carpal tunnel, showing that medical recommendations assume a definition of health and progress.
  3. Artificial theosis through technology is essentially the tower of Babel.
  4. The more progress achieved through artificial theosis, the less connected one is to the arcade and the less real one becomes.
  5. Science can explain how the body works but cannot determine what health is for, what counts as progress, what should be fixed, or what life is worth preserving.
  6. Answering those questions requires a view of what a human being is, a theological anthropology.
  7. Therefore, your doctor has a theology.
0 comments at the source Original on Instagram

Discussion · 0

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

There is no discussion from the source for this post. Be the first to comment.