WeOrthodox
EN UA
Robel࿇🕊️ Instagram

Did St. John Chrysostom Refute 'Faith Alone'? Commenters Disagree

The post presents a video arguing that, according to St. John Chrysostom, belief in the Son by itself is not sufficient for eternal life. The video cites Christ's warning that 'not everyone who says to me, Lord, Lord, shall enter the kingdom of heaven,' and notes that blasphemy against the Holy Spirit alone is enough to condemn a person.

Although Scripture states that 'he that believes in the Son has eternal life,' the many commandments of the Gospels show that faith must be joined to a right manner of life rather than mere mental assent. The post is framed as Chrysostom 'debunking' the doctrine of faith alone, with hashtags appealing to Orthodox, Catholic, and general Christian audiences.

The comment section quickly became a debate between Orthodox and Protestant readers. Several commenters asked where the quote comes from, while others pushed back, citing Romans 11:6 and Ephesians 2:8-9 to argue that no works can merit justification, otherwise salvation would not be grace. A recurring theme in the discussion was definitional: some Protestants argued that sola fide was never meant as mere intellectual assent, and that genuine faith naturally produces good works, so Chrysostom's words do not contradict them.

One commenter claimed Chrysostom actually taught something like sola fide, noting his homilies on 1 Timothy speak of being raised by faith alone, while still affirming that faith without works is insufficient. Another suggested the dispute hinges on what 'sufficient for salvation' means: if it concerns meriting forgiveness, the quote would refute sola fide, but if it concerns presuming final salvation, Protestants can agree.

The thread thus illustrates that both sides often agree that true faith must bear fruit in a right life, while differing on how faith, works, and grace relate to justification.

Key moments

  1. Belief in the Son alone is not enough for eternal life.
  2. Christ said, 'Not everyone who says to me, Lord, Lord, shall enter the kingdom of heaven.'
  3. Blasphemy against the Holy Spirit is by itself enough to cast a man into hell.
  4. The many commandments in the Gospels show that faith must be accompanied by a right manner of life.
41 opinions in the discussion 32 participants, 17 replies to each other The opinion with the most support Works prove your faith, but works don't give salvation, yet faith without works is dead. Read the discussion
313 comments at the source Original on Instagram

Discussion · 41

Opinions are anonymous retellings of real comments from the original discussion. The same colour marks the same participant.

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

  • opinion#741

    Works prove your faith, but works don't give salvation, yet faith without works is dead.

    • opinion#747

      You understood it very well, my brother. God bless you.

  • opinion#746

    Where is this quote from?

    • opinion#748

      This is from St. John Chrysostom's commentary on John 3:35-36.

  • opinion#740

    Submit to Rome, brothers in Christ ✝️🇻🇦

    • opinion#749

      What do you think of Leo? He said we have a lot to learn from Islam.

    • opinion#750

      Christ's Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity is within the Roman Catholic Church ✝️🇻🇦 If you think you're saved by faith alone, that just believing in Jesus is enough for your salvation, that's a heresy. Satan believes in Christ, devil worshipers believe in Christ. Submit to Rome because Rome is Home ✝️🇻🇦

  • opinion#736

    John Chrysostom literally taught sola fide and sola scriptura. This quote is probably fake.

    • opinion#751

      You're clearly not very well read when it comes to the Fathers, which is why you assumed this quote was fake. And since you're a Protestant I don't blame your illiteracy. Next time do some actual reading before making accusations about something you obviously haven't bothered to verify.

    • opinion#752

      Protestantism brought literacy. You're an illiterate easterner who quotemines. Message me so I can embarrass you.

    • opinion#753

      I've sent you a private message, so let's talk it through then

    • opinion#754

      Does it work now? You should be able to send me a private message, because I can't message you

  • opinion#743

    Faith alone doesn't mean faith without works is sufficient. So Sola Fide isn't debunked.

    • opinion#755

      That is literally what sola fide means. "I believe Jesus Christ is my Lord and Saviour, and that He died for my sins, I'm now saved." Tell me that's not what you people teach.

    • opinion#756

      The common view is that any true believer would naturally try to live a god-fearing life. Conversely, someone who doesn't try to live according to Christ's teachings cannot be truly faithful.

    • opinion#757

      Protestant doctrine is not just faith alone. Scripture is the only infallible authority on faith, faith alone in Christ is what saves you, and grace is an undeserved gift from God to us. There is NOTHING you can do besides professing belief in Christ that will earn you salvation. Also, everyone likes to claim Protestants don't believe in works at all. That's false. Protestants, and the Bible itself, say your works won't save you, your works are like dirty rags to God. But through faith you produce good works, since that's part of Christ's command to love and help each other. An old Protestant phrase goes "Faith alone saves, but the faith that saves is not alone." Protestant teaching, like Orthodox teaching, is that you cannot add anything to Christ's finished work. It's not a works based salvation, it never is, never was, never will be. But you're encouraged to do good works because that's the right thing to do.

    • opinion#758

      That's the problem with the wording usually used to defend sola fide. "Faith naturally produces good works" sounds far too passive, almost like you don't actually do anything yourself. You have to struggle and toil to build up the virtues and root out your passions, every single day. It takes conscious effort.

    • opinion#759

      So to you works are heretical, right? That's your half assed protestant hill to die on? Faith alone... works be damned? Yeah, you people really hate Our Faith while preaching faith alone.... 😂

    • opinion#760

      So, as long as you have faith, you can be a total piece of garbage and still get into the Kingdom of Heaven?

    • opinion#761

      Sola Scriptura has produced 40,000+ sects of "Christianity".

    • opinion#762

      Saved by faith alone. Adding any other requirement is denying Christ's nature. Didn't he die on the cross so you could be saved? But that's faith, I fully trust that simply by taking Christ as my lord, he'll guide me in every moment. What works does a lamb perform for its shepherd? Isn't hearing his call and living within its nature enough? Are you afraid your spirit's nature is sinful when the bible plainly says we're innocents born into a sinful world? You don't have faith that once saved you'll behave like a saved person? Did Christ lie to the thief crucified beside him?

    • opinion#763

      It's presumption. It makes it sound like the works won't be hard at all. But Jesus even made salvific statements and parables about doing or not doing good works. In Matthew 25, the goats and sheep parable. And the unforgiving servant parable, I forget the verse. But Jesus said if you forgive others, the father will forgive your sins, but if you don't forgive others, you won't be forgiven. I read that as, all else being equal, you could be perfect in everything else, but if you're not forgiving people you won't be forgiven, which inevitably means no heaven.

  • opinion#742

    It's faith alone; no works can merit anything, otherwise it wouldn't be grace (Rom. 11:6; Eph. 2:8-9). We can't help God in order to be justified.

  • opinion#744

    The key is how you read "sufficient FOR salvation". If it means "worthy enough to MERIT forgiveness", that would debunk sola fide! But that is NOT what St John Chrysostom means at all. He means that faith by itself is not sufficient as a reason to presume you or anyone else will finally be saved at the end! And that's true, exactly right. The original reformers agree with this... There are other quotes where Chrysostom literally says "being justified by Faith Alone"!! "Faith alone" is a COMMON phrase in the Fathers, and it was used positively. Augustine is another example...

  • opinion#735

    I've read John Chrysostom and can confirm he believed in SOLA FIDE, but you need to understand what that means... John also said that by faith alone you're raised before God to the highest favor (Commentaries on 1. Timothy, I think from his homily on that epistle). Here he's simply saying faith without works isn't enough. We protestants say that too. What kind of faith brings no fruit, is it really alive? Or just confession without heart? Chrysostom believed in sola fide, read his works, he was so against man claiming his contribution to salvation by works.. Salvation is BY GRACE through FAITH

  • opinion#734

    Remember brothers, sola fide isn't "intellectual ascent" or "just believing and doing nothing more". Every christian needs good works, plenty of them actually. But if we're weak and sin, God is faithful to forgive all and keep us spotless before him. We must watch out for apostasy and unrepentant behavior, but also be very sure of our salvation. God perseveres all who love and believe in him, even addicts who can't quit but wish to.

  • opinion#745

    Also basic Protestant theology is for a right life. Yes, there are lazy Christians who claim faith alone with no actions, but there are Christians who mean faith with living works flowing from genuine faith. Religious studies scholars classify Protestants with other Christians for that reason, since they hold the same general idea with different analogies. Even Orthodox have an idea at the start of theosis where it's all faith before any works, then it becomes one, theosis as a divine ascent. Most Protestants have a similar analysis of faith in their traditions.

  • opinion#728

    an invisible arm stopped me from crossing the street once. It was physical too and a car zoomed past. Jesus Christ died for us and rose from the dead 3 days later and gave us The Holy Spirit. come back to orthodoxy. an invisible arm stopped me from crossing the street once, it was physical too. turn to orthodoxy

  • opinion#737

    Orthodoxy uses these surrounding verses to show that belief alone, without spiritual fruit and repentance, doesn't save: James 2:14, "What does it profit, my brethren, if someone says he has faith but does not have works? Can faith save him?" James 2:26, "as the body without the spirit is dead, so faith without works is dead also." Matthew 7:21, not everyone who says 'Lord, Lord' enters the kingdom, but he who does the will of the Father. Luke 4:34: the demons explicitly acknowledged Christ, crying "I know who You are, the Holy One of God!", yet stayed condemned because they lacked love, obedience and repentance. Lord have mercy ☦️ #nepsis #hesychasm #nous #logismoi

  • opinion#738

    Christ warns that a branch that does not bear fruit is cut off and burned (John 15:6). Paul says he disciplines his body so he won't be disqualified (1 Cor 9:27), and tells the Galatians they have "fallen from grace" (Gal 5:4). Christ warns the churches in Revelation that names can be blotted out of the Book of Life (Rev 3:5). In Orthodoxy salvation is not a legal transaction or a ticket received in the past. It's an ongoing process of becoming like God, theosis. Salvation requires our cooperation (synergy) with God's uncreated grace. God doesn't force anyone to stay in communion with Him. We believe: I was saved (at Baptism), I am being saved (now, through faith and repentance), and I hope to be saved (at the Final Judgment). Orthodoxy sees Eternal Security as dangerous spiritual pride, prelest. Believing future sins carry no consequence leads to sloth, lack of repentance, and a false security that blinds you to your real spiritual state. "Even the demons believe, and tremble" (James 2:19) dismantles salvation by mere intellectual belief or Once Saved Always Saved. The devil is the ultimate proof that faith without works is dead: he has perfect theology, knows exactly who God is, yet is totally cut off because he refuses to love, obey, repent. James 2:14 and 2:26, and Matthew 7:21, all show belief alone without fruit and repentance does not save.

  • opinion#739

    Doesn't this just mean that true faith will show itself in your fruits? Like Scripture says, you can cry "Lord!" but that doesn't mean you're actually saved. This would still be salvation through faith alone, since our works don't justify us, they're the product of real faith and the change inside us.

  • opinion#723

    Chrysostom is right that just saying "I believe in Jesus" while staying unrepentant isn't saving faith. But sola fide never claimed otherwise. We're justified by faith apart from works, yet the faith that justifies produces repentance and good works. Paul says both "a man is justified by faith without the deeds of the law" (Rom. 3:28) and that believers are "created in Christ Jesus unto good works" (Eph. 2:10). Works are the fruit and evidence of salvation, not its meritorious basis. 1 Cor. 6:11: "such were some of you: but ye are washed, but ye are sanctified, but ye are justified." James 2:24 and 2:17 aren't contrasting living faith with faith plus meritorious works, but living faith with a dead profession. Abraham's works show the reality of faith he already had; Gen. 15:6 "he believed in the LORD; and he counted it to him for righteousness." Rom. 4:2-5 says the same: to him who works not but believes, faith is counted for righteousness.

  • opinion#724

    Pt 4 (lastly) - We can always aim to please God, faith alone doesn't disrupt that. What faith alone shows is that nothing on our end can save us. Salvation is a GIFT received by faith (Rom. 3:21-31). We all fall, and Scripture says a righteous man falls and gets back up; repentance is itself a fruit a believer bears. God calls and gives us new hearts of repentance (Ezek. 36:25-27). Baptism, repentance, and faith all correspond in salvation: in Christ we were baptized, crucified with him in his death so our old selves would perish and stop being our nature forever. Our sinful selves died with him, and as he was raised, we too shall rise (all of this is in Romans 6). I hope you can see my heart here, I only mean care and hope God reveals his will to you, in Jesus name. God bless

  • opinion#725

    Pt 3 - Faith alone can be used loosely or badly by people, but the doctrine itself isn't wrong. You're right that Christians should live better, at least better than their old selves before Christ. But that's exactly what Grace does. It doesn't just forgive and accept us, it trains us, as Titus 2:11-14 says: grace appears, bringing salvation, teaching us to renounce ungodliness and live self-controlled, upright, godly lives, zealous for good works. The point about trying to change for Christ is we don't need to do anything because God made us new - 2 Cor. 5:17, if anyone is in Christ he's a new creation, old passed away, new come. We're not trying to gain anything or be perfect for Christ; we live as people already changed, "training up in righteousness," not chasing some daily goal. Yes we strive to be better, but not by human effort, rather as partners with God.

  • opinion#726

    Faith Alone isn't terrible terminology. Is it always well put? Maybe not. But the doctrine itself shouldn't be so doubted, because Paul says in Romans 5:1-2 that since we've been justified by faith we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ, and access by faith into this grace in which we stand. It doesn't say "justified by faith + or and works." It says justified (declared righteous) by faith (alone). Paul goes on to say that by Christ's death, blood, obedience and life we've been reconciled, saved from wrath and death, given grace, made new, given eternal life and more, none of which we contributed to. Our justification, our right standing, is granted by faith in Christ because of what He, God, did for us. I'll make a part 3

  • opinion#727

    Sorry friend, I was away for a while. You're right that we can't get ourselves into heaven, only faith in Christ does that (John 6:47, 10:1-16, 14:6; Eph. 2:8-9; Titus 3:5). You're right repentance is a must, but for believers God grants repentance (Acts 5:31, 11:18; Rom. 2:4; 2 Tim. 2:25). We don't have to be baptized with water to go to heaven; we're baptized by the Holy Spirit (Acts 1:5; 1 Cor. 12:13). We don't need the Eucharist either, but must believe in Christ, the true bread from heaven (John 6:35-63). I'll make a part 2 of a response.

  • opinion#729

    It really depends what you count as works, because look at Matthew 7:21: the people who said "lord lord" listed their works for God and he sent them away, while the ones he let in were the ones who followed love God with your whole being and love your neighbor as yourself

  • opinion#730

    As much as we love the church Fathers, they clearly believed things contrary to each other. They disagreed on many things. If one Father believing something makes it true, does that mean Irenaeus was right when he taught that the Lord Jesus Christ died at 50 years old? Where's that in scripture? What about the fathers who believed in Predestination? They believed different things, so picking one father over another obviously isn't the way. But what does Scripture say about it

  • opinion#731

    Romans 3:23-26 and Romans 4:3-6 directly contradict this claim from John. The verse he references is actually about people who think their works are enough to convey salvation but never truly had faith. As Matthew 7:22 shows, the "believer" rejected by God, and verses 23-24 show why he's rejected: he treated his works as his wage for salvation while ignoring the due work, which is faith. Salvation is a Gift by Christ Alone, otherwise we'd be participating in salvation, which isn't possible.

  • opinion#732

    There's nothing we can do to earn salvation. It's a free gift from God through Christ's finished work on the cross. "That if you confess with your mouth the Lord Jesus and believe in your heart that God has raised Him from the dead, you will be saved. For with the heart one believes unto righteousness, and with the mouth confession is made unto salvation... Whoever calls on the name of the Lord shall be saved." Romans 10:9-13

  • opinion#733

    The Jewish apostles are the patriarchy of the church, not the church fathers. It bears repeating. Something is off with the traditions of Orthodox, Catholic and many Protestant churches. Read Paul's instructions to the gentile believers and compare church traditions with Paul's heart toward the Jewish people (disbelieving Israel). Romans 3:1-4: the Jews were entrusted with the oracles of God, and their unfaithfulness doesn't nullify God's faithfulness. Romans 9:3-5: to the Israelites belong the adoption, glory, covenants, law, worship, promises, patriarchs, and Christ himself. Romans 11: they're enemies for your sake regarding the gospel but beloved for the forefathers' sake, the gifts and calling of God are irrevocable, and you don't support the root, the root supports you. And that's not the only tradition going against scripture. See Ezekiel 36