Did Chalcedon Contradict the Fifth Ecumenical Council? An Oriental Orthodox Case
This post presents an Oriental Orthodox argument that the Council of Chalcedon (451) erred by rehabilitating figures and writings later condemned as Nestorian by the Fifth Ecumenical Council (Constantinople II, 553). The speaker focuses on the so-called Three Chapters: the writings of Theodore of Mopsuestia, Theodoret of Cyrus, and the letter of Ibas of Edessa.
He cites the tenth session of Chalcedon, where Roman legates declared Ibas's letter orthodox after it was read aloud—a letter in which Ibas calls St. Cyril of Alexandria an Apollinarian and praises Theodore of Mopsuestia as a teacher of the faith. Theodoret, likewise, was restored after merely anathematizing Nestorius, without his writings being examined or condemned.
The speaker concludes that Chalcedon directly contradicts Constantinople II, and argues that even a Chalcedonian interlocutor concedes the tension, casting doubt on whether the Holy Spirit guided Chalcedon. The discussion in the comments is substantive and two-sided. Supporters of the argument add that Chalcedon omitted Cyril's Third Letter to Nestorius and the Twelve Anathemas, suggesting Cyril's reception there was instrumental rather than genuine, and invoke Cyril's own letters to show he objected to two-natures language without proper qualifications.
Critics respond that the Three Chapters were not dogmatic decrees of Chalcedon but matters concerning persons and writings; that Constantinople II condemned specific Nestorian writings, not Chalcedon itself, and explicitly reaffirmed Chalcedon; and that Theodoret and Ibas were received only after making orthodox confessions. Others raise the parallel question of the Second Council of Ephesus and Eutyches, and debate whether the miaphysite formula's origins undermine the Oriental position.
The thread thus turns on whether the Fourth and Fifth Councils are genuinely irreconcilable, or whether later condemnation of specific writings is compatible with Chalcedon's earlier restorations.
Key moments
- 0:00 The Orthodox objection against Pope Vigilius is that by accepting the Three Chapters he embraced Nestorianism, making him a bishop of Rome who taught heresy.
- 0:37 The Council of Chalcedon (451) accepted the Three Chapters, which the Fifth Ecumenical Council condemned as Nestorian.
- 1:27 In the tenth session of Chalcedon, the letter of Ibas of Edessa was read to determine whether Ibas was Nestorian.
- 1:51 In the letter, Ibas calls Cyril an Apollinarian and praises Theodore of Mopsuestia as a teacher of the faith, criticizing those who condemn him.
- 2:07 The Roman legates at Chalcedon declared the letter perfectly orthodox and rehabilitated Ibas, showing acceptance of both the first and third chapters.
- 2:27 Theodore of Cyrus was tried at Chalcedon, claimed he was raised among the orthodox (including Theodore of Mopsuestia), and was rehabilitated after only anathematizing Nestorius, without any of his writings being condemned.