WeOrthodox
EN UA
Athonite Audio YouTube

Desert Fathers' Warnings Against Judging Others

Desert Fathers' Warnings Against Judging Others 9:10

Chapter 9 of the Sayings of the Desert Fathers collects stories and sayings that condemn judging one's brother. Abba Anthony compares a repentant monk expelled twice to a shipwrecked vessel that has reached harbor empty, asking whether they would sink it; the brothers reinstate him at once. When a priest orders a sinner out of church, Abba Bisarian leaves with him, saying, "I too am a sinner."

Abba Isaac of the Thebes mentally condemns a brother at a cenobium; an angel blocks his cell door and tells him God asks where he wishes the guilty brother sent. Isaac prostrates and apologizes; the angel says God has forgiven him but warns him not to judge before God has judged. At a disciplinary meeting in Scetis, Abba Moses carries a leaking basket of sand, explaining his own sins trail behind him unseen while he is asked to judge another's; the brothers pardon the offender.

Abba Poemen teaches that peace comes from asking "Who am I?" and judging no one, and that God overlooks the faults of those who overlook their brother's faults. He illustrates this by gently restoring a man an anchorite had expelled and rebuking the anchorite with a parable of a man weeping over another's corpse while ignoring his own.

Abba Pior carries a large bag of sand on his shoulders and a small basket in front, saying the bag represents his many sins placed behind him unseen, the basket the brother's sins he is tempted to judge; the fathers call this the true path of salvation. An anchorite bars a priest from serving after rumors; a voice says, "Human beings are taking my judgments upon themselves," and a vision of a golden well with pure water drawn by a leper leads the anchorite to recall the priest.

Key moments

  1. A monk expelled from Aba Elias's brotherhood goes to Aba Anthony, is sent back, expelled again, and Aba Anthony sends a message comparing him to a shipwrecked vessel that has reached harbor empty, asking if they would sink it; they reinstate him at once.
  2. When a priest orders a sinning brother to leave the church, Aba Bisarian leaves with him, saying 'I too am a sinner.'
  3. Aba Isaac of the thieves visits a synobium, passes judgment in his thoughts on a brother guilty of sins, returns to the desert, and an angel blocks his cell door, telling him God asks where he wishes the guilty brother to be sent; Isaac prostrates and apologizes, and the angel says God has forgiven him but warns him not to judge anyone before God has judged him.
  4. When a brother in Skete is found guilty, the elders call a meeting and summon Aba Moses; he arrives carrying a battered wicker basket with holes filled with sand, explains that his own sins run out behind him unseen while he is asked to judge his brother's sins, and the brothers pardon the offender.
  5. Aba Joseph asks Aba Poemen how to become a true monk, and Poemen replies that to find peace now and in the world to come one should say in every situation 'Who am I?' and pass judgment on no one.
  6. An anchorite tells an abbot to expel a transgressing brother; the brother weeps in the marshlands, refuses to see Poemen, but when Poemen sends for him he comes, is embraced and fed, and Poemen sends a message to the anchorite leading to a meeting where Poemen tells a parable of a man who leaves his own loved one's corpse to weep for another's, pricking the anchorite's conscience so he says 'Poemen has already risen up to heaven while I am still earthbound.'
  7. At a meeting in Skete discussing a brother's guilt, Aba Pior carries a large bag of sand on his shoulders and a small basket in front, explaining the bag represents his many sins placed behind him unseen, the basket the brother's sins he is tempted to judge, and that he should keep his own sins before him and ask God's forgiveness; the fathers say this is the true path of salvation.
  8. A priest who regularly consecrates the oblation for an anchorite is barred after rumors; a voice tells the anchorite 'Human beings are taking my judgments upon themselves,' and in a vision he sees a golden well with pure water drawn by a leper, refuses to drink, hears 'Why are you not drinking? Does it matter who draws it?' and realizes his error, calling the priest back.
0 comments at the source 69 views Original on YouTube

Discussion · 0

Log in Log in or sign up to join the discussion.

There is no discussion from the source for this post. Be the first to comment.